# Civil Service Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Civil Service Board
**Date:** December 2, 2021 2:38 PM EST (2021-12-02T14:38:54-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5091/civil-service-board-dec-2-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Civil Service Board met on December 2, 2021, to review personnel matters and departmental updates. The meeting began with the swearing-in of two new board members, Mr. Hahn and Mr. Escovitz. The primary agenda item involved the review of updated minimum promotional requirements for the Asheville Fire Department, alongside an update on the city’s interim COVID-19 employee safety policy.

The board took several actions during the session. The agenda was accepted unanimously (5-0), and the minutes from the September 2, 2021 meeting were approved unanimously (5-0). The board voted to reappoint Rick Devereaux for a new term; Mr. Devereaux abstained from the vote, and the motion passed 4-0. The board also unanimously approved (5-0) the proposed changes to promotional requirements for six Fire Department positions: Assistant Fire Marshal, Fire Investigator, Fire and Life Safety Educator, Senior Deputy Fire Marshal, Safety and Training Officer, and Division Chief. The meeting was adjourned unanimously (5-0).

Chief Burnett presented the changes to the Fire Department career ladder, which generally aimed to broaden the applicant pool by removing specific time-in-rank requirements or designating certain certifications as "preferred" rather than required prior to promotion. These certifications would become required within 12 months of promotion. Regarding the removal of the two-year senior firefighter requirement for the Assistant Fire Marshal role, Chief Burnett stated, "What we have found is those additional two years of experience as a firefighter did not give that candidate a lot of additional experience in what the work of the assistant fire marshal... does." He explained that the role primarily involves fire inspections, which senior firefighters do not perform. On the "preferred" certifications, he clarified, "Those three certifications are important, but they're not important to begin doing the job. And so we felt that we could increase the applicant pool by making those preferred and required after promotion."

City HR staff provided an update on the interim COVID-19 employee safety policy, which requires masking in city buildings and vehicles, as well as either vaccination or weekly testing for unvaccinated employees. Shannon Barrett, City HR, stated, "If employees are found to be in violation... they may be subject to corrective action in alignment with our established disciplinary process." John, City Staff, addressed religious and medical exemptions, noting, "Most of the exemptions that we received were for they took exception of being required to take a COVID vaccine. While our policy doesn't require that anybody take a COVID vaccine, it is that they be vaccinated or that they be tested on a weekly basis. So a number of those exemption requests were denied on that basis because there is an alternative to taking the vaccine built into the policy already." Staff noted that an appeal related to this policy had just been filed with the board.

No public comments were submitted during the meeting. Regarding follow-ups, Chief Burnett stated that the Fire Department is currently five positions short of its budgeted 292 employees. He noted that 19 of the 24 current vacancies will be filled by academy graduates, and the department is preparing to start another hiring process and academy to fill the remaining gaps. No specific follow-up action was taken at this meeting regarding the pending COVID policy appeal, though the board was advised of the case.

These decisions impact residents by potentially expanding the pool of qualified candidates for key Fire Department leadership and safety roles, which may influence the speed and composition of future hires. The approval of the promotional requirements allows the department to move forward with filling its current vacancies, while the ongoing discussion of the COVID-19 policy highlights the city's approach to workplace safety and employee compliance.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iu5s8tNEtBU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2889/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iu5s8tNEtBU)
