# Public Safety Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Public Safety Committee
**Date:** November 17, 2021 11:00 AM EST (2021-11-17T11:00:10-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5099/public-safety-committee-nov-17-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on November 17, 2021, to review departmental updates and vote on grant applications. The meeting was chaired by Vice Mayor Shanika Smith. The committee addressed the approval of previous minutes, reviewed financial grant applications for the Asheville Police Department (APD), and examined traffic stop data trends.

**Key Decisions**
The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding APD grant applications, the committee voted to move three grants forward to full council for further consideration. The motion to advance the Bike Safety Grant passed unanimously. Motions to advance the Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) and the Bulletproof Vest Grant both passed with a 2-1 vote.

**Discussion Highlights**
Police Chief David Zak presented an update on traffic stop data, noting that traffic stops and subsequent enforcement actions have declined significantly since 2019. He reported a 54% decline in traffic stops from 2019 to 2020, with a further drop in 2021, and stated that less than 5% of all traffic stops result in an arrest. When Councilwoman Kilgore asked if the racial breakdown of investigatory stops could be viewed as racial profiling, Chief Zak disagreed, explaining that officers are typically looking for a specific individual based on a call. Chief Zak also clarified that the number of citations issued does not fund the police budget and explained that officer discretion determines whether a driver receives a ticket or a warning. He described the proposed 2022 "Lights On" program as a community-based initiative where officers would issue vouchers for vehicle repairs instead of citations for equipment violations to build goodwill.

**Community Input**
One public commenter called in to express concern that the committee prioritizes the rights of those interacting with police over general citizen safety. The commenter questioned why any member would vote against a federal grant for officer overtime and criticized the decision to spend resources on further mining traffic stop data to investigate racial profiling. The commenter also requested that the City Manager provide a monthly chart showing police staffing levels, including vacancies, terminations, and new hires. After the comment period closed, no member or staff member responded to the specific requests or criticisms raised.

**Follow-ups**
In response to questions from Councilwoman Kilgore and Councilwoman Roney regarding the racial demographics of investigatory stops and the origin of drivers, Police Chief David Zak agreed to attempt to break the data down further for future presentations. Additionally, Vice Mayor Smith indicated that the next meeting, tentatively scheduled for December 28, might be rescheduled to January 2022 to avoid a holiday meeting. Staff agreed to provide information about the specific date and agenda items for the January meeting.

**Impact**
This meeting highlights the department's shift in traffic enforcement strategies, including a significant reduction in stops and the introduction of the "Lights On" voucher program. The committee’s decision to forward the Bike Safety, JAG, and Bulletproof Vest grants to full council means these funding opportunities will be considered by the entire council in the coming months. Furthermore, the commitment to provide more detailed breakdowns of traffic stop data addresses ongoing community questions regarding enforcement trends and demographics.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICNKOa-NdTk
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2898/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICNKOa-NdTk)
