# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** November 12, 2021 9:30 AM EST (2021-11-12T09:30:07-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5100/downtown-commission-nov-12-2021
**Outcome:** Downtown Commission postponed the hotel conversion at 2123 Haywood Street and voted to support the open space amendment.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission convened on November 12, 2021, to address project reviews, updates to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), and administrative business. The meeting began with the approval of the previous meeting’s minutes, which passed by roll call with all present members voting Aye. The session concluded with a motion to adjourn. No public comments were recorded, as the chair confirmed there were no written submissions, voicemails, or live queue participants.

**Key Decisions and Project Reviews**
The Commission reviewed a development impact request to convert a previously approved condominium into a small hotel at 2123 Haywood Street. This item was postponed because the applicant had not met administrative requirements under the UDO, specifically regarding building setbacks and storefront activation. The chair confirmed the decision to continue the review to a future date once the applicant is ready, noting that no specific date was set. Additionally, the Commission voted to pass a resolution submitting a letter to City Council in support of the open space amendment. This resolution explicitly noted the exemption for the Central Business District (CBD/Downtown) and supported associated tree canopy improvements.

**UDO Policy Discussions**
Planning and Urban Design staff presented proposed updates to the UDO focusing on open space, design review composition, and hotel definitions. Staff clarified that open space is not required in the CBD, with proposed changes aiming to improve open space quality, incentivize stormwater management, and remove barriers to infill development. During discussion, members raised concerns that current regulations may not adequately address post-COVID accessibility needs or "lived experience."

The Commission also debated refining definitions to distinguish between traditional hotels, small boutique hotels, and "condo-tel" style extended stay properties. Large hotels are defined as requiring 24/7 on-site supervisory personnel, while small hotels require on-site supervisory personnel (not necessarily 24/7) and are limited to 35 rooms or fewer. Extended stay properties were redefined to fall under the "large hotel" category, requiring 24/7 on-site staff and location within specific overlays. Debate centered on whether "on-site" strictly requires physical presence or if virtual check-in is acceptable. Staff noted the intent to stop the submission of "condo-tel" versions that circumvent hotel regulations. Regarding parking, members suggested that off-site parking should only be permitted through a Conditional Zoning (CZ) process.

**Discussion Highlights**
Chair Bryan Moffitt reflected on the need to align stated priorities with actual time spent, stating, "I would like to do better this year and making sure that what we say we're going to do is what we're actually spending time on." He also clarified the intent behind hotel definitions, stating, "I think that's actually what this is doing, Sage, is that we're saying you are a hotel. Okay. You're acting like a hotel. So just go ahead and call yourself a hotel and then follow the guidelines."

Commissioner Robin Raines emphasized the importance of the "on-site" requirement, noting, "I think that the onsite for me... is important because... that means that there is someone who works there who manages the place and makes it less likely that it's just going to be this multiple owner condo situation." Commissioner Andrew Fletcher stated, "I think that parking should absolutely be onsite. And I would say there should be no exceptions built in to code. If they want an exception, they can go to council and ask for one."

A staff member explained the regulatory challenge, stating, "My understanding was that we wanted to stop seeing and stop allowing these condo tell versions that kept being submitted. And there is not a practical way to stop them without limiting them." Although the transcript summary includes a quote attributed to "Commissioner Kimberly Hunter" regarding equity concerns, this individual is not listed on the official roster for the Downtown Commission; therefore, the specific name is omitted in this recap, but the sentiment regarding the need to exceed federal and state laws to ensure equitable community design was part of the discussion.

**Follow-ups and Administrative Business**
Staff members agreed to several follow-up actions. Vidhila Satvika from Planning & Urban Design agreed to review members' concerns regarding ADA inclusivity and "lived experience" in the design process. Shannon from Planning & Urban Design agreed to include member feedback on the "on-site" definition and parking requirements in the staff report to the Planning and Zoning Commission. Dana from City Staff agreed to send an email update regarding Pritchard Park safety measures to commissioners. Additionally, Dana notified members that a skills and priorities survey would be distributed the following week to help identify priorities for upcoming vacancies.

**Impact and Next Steps**
These discussions matter to residents as they shape the regulatory framework for development in the downtown area, particularly regarding the definition of hotel types and parking requirements. The Commission noted that two commissioners are rolling off, and vacancies were posted with a deadline of December 20, with appointments expected on January 11. Staff also announced a joint meeting with the Multimodal Commission scheduled for December 16 to review the public space management framework.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c1QDvGtMu0I
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2904/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c1QDvGtMu0I)
