# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** November 10, 2021 4:00 PM EST (2021-11-10T16:00:57-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5101/historic-resources-commission-nov-10-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) met on November 10, 2021, to review several Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) applications, a preliminary design review, and a federal preservation agreement. The meeting concluded with the approval of three CA applications, the continuation of one design review to a future meeting, and the approval of a programmatic agreement with the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO).

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Commission accepted the October minutes and amended the August minutes to correct a description regarding a gate installation at 240 Pearson Drive; both motions passed unanimously. For the CA application at 37 Watauga Street in the Montford Historic District, which involved a new accessory dwelling unit (ADU), pool, and site improvements, the Commission voted 7-1 to approve the application and issue the CA with the condition that mechanical unit specifications be submitted for staff review. Commissioners Spring, Lazarus, Hornaday, Gardner, Oliva, Falcon, and Watkins voted in favor, while Commissioner Vaughn voted against. The Commission unanimously approved the CA for 80 St. Dunstan’s Road in the St. Dunstan’s Historic District to enclose a screened porch, with conditions requiring revised elevation drawings and clad window specifications. Additionally, the Commission unanimously approved the CA for 61 Pearson Drive in the Montford Historic District for window and door modifications, with the condition that revised door specifications be submitted for staff review. The preliminary design review for new construction at 43 Elizabeth Place was continued to the December meeting by unanimous vote. Finally, the Commission unanimously approved and authorized the Chair to sign the Programmatic Agreement between the City of Asheville, SHPO, CDBG, HOME, and COC.

**Discussion Highlights**
Significant debate occurred regarding the 37 Watauga Street application. Commissioner Vaughn voted against the proposal, stating, "My belief is that we were presented with a property that had problems because there was work done that was not brought before us before... Instead, we aggravated it by adding a pool and then to add insult to injury, we're putting up an accessory dwelling to hide that rather than putting it, the structure where it was historically." Commissioner Spring expressed concern that the ADU was "oddly far away from the home" and suggested following the historic pattern of the neighborhood. Commissioner Hornaday agreed with staff and Chair Kite that a rear placement would be ideal but noted, "in this case, there's more benefit to the ADUs placement closer to the home for current usage."

Regarding the 80 St. Dunstan’s Road application, Chair Kite noted that a "more traditional kind of punched opening rather than sort of the glazing in that gable end is probably more consistent" and that the design "needs a little bit more traditional windows." For the 43 Elizabeth Place design, Commissioner Spring observed that the rear of the structure felt like it was "floating" and suggested using "a broader type of stone column or something to give it a little bit more grounding" to avoid a "Florida type feel."

The Commission also discussed the SHPO Programmatic Agreement, which allows the City’s historic preservation planner to review HUD-funded rehabilitation projects. Commissioner Lazarus remarked, "As someone who's written a whole bunch of PAs, this is a beautiful, short, lovely PA." Staff member Alex noted the agreement has been in development for three years and is close to finalization. The group also addressed the ongoing vacancy on the Commission, with staff expressing urgency to fill the seat. Staff noted that while the City communicates vacancies effectively, the County does not, and discussed desired qualifications such as experience in historic preservation, restoration carpentry, or public history. A commission member noted that previous appointees have struggled to complete terms due to other commitments.

**Community Input**
No members of the public spoke during the public comment periods for the 37 Watauga Street, 80 St. Dunstan’s Road, 61 Pearson Drive, or 43 Elizabeth Place agenda items.

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Alex agreed to follow up with the applicants for 37 Watauga Street, 80 St. Dunstan’s Road, and 61 Pearson Drive in the next couple of days regarding the approved CAs. For the 43 Elizabeth Place project, the architect, Scott, agreed to contact staff by the following Wednesday to confirm whether the project will be presented at the December meeting or continued to January; staff also stated they would be in touch with the applicants between now and Wednesday of next week. Regarding the SHPO agreement, staff noted the Chair will sign it once comments from tribes and other stakeholders are received. Staff stated they had reached out to potential candidates for the vacancy, including Jessie Landall and Michael Logan of Logan Restoration, and asked commission members to help network to find candidates. A commission member offered to share information with the Asheville Home Builders Association and the Board of Realtors.

**Impact**
These decisions impact property owners in the Montford and St. Dunstan’s Historic Districts by formalizing approvals for specific renovations and new structures. The approval of the SHPO Programmatic Agreement establishes a framework for the City to review federally funded rehabilitation projects, ensuring compliance with historic preservation standards. The discussion on the Commission vacancy highlights the ongoing effort to secure members with specific technical expertise, such as restoration carpentry, to support the review of complex historic structures.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjRpST4nPp8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2902/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjRpST4nPp8)
