# African American Heritage Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — African American Heritage Commission
**Date:** October 14, 2021 4:29 PM EDT (2021-10-14T16:29:23-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5118/african-american-heritage-commission-oct-14-2021
**Outcome:** The Commission approved the September minutes unanimously and deferred the African American art memorial funding discussion to November.

## Summary

The African American Heritage Commission of the City of Asheville held a regular meeting on October 14, 2021. The session focused on administrative approvals, updates on ongoing community projects, and a presentation from the City’s Office of Data and Performance (ODAP) regarding the use of data for equitable outcomes.

## Key Decisions
The commission approved the minutes from the September 9, 2021 meeting via a unanimous roll call vote. Additionally, the group agreed to change the date of the next regular meeting from November 11 to Wednesday, November 10, 2021, due to the city holiday on November 11. This scheduling change was confirmed by the chair after members expressed agreement, though no formal vote was recorded.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff provided updates on several key initiatives. The reparations project, managed by Tequity, is scheduled to kick off on October 18, with members receiving communications regarding participation opportunities such as applying for impact area commissions or serving as neighborhood nominees. Staff also noted that they did not have time to schedule presentations by local historians or the North Carolina African American heritage representative for this meeting but will begin that process immediately, aiming to include them on the next agenda.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by representatives from the City’s Office of Data and Performance (ODAP). ODAP explained their mission to empower community and staff to use data for equitable outcomes, emphasizing that their role is to enable others to do the work rather than just provide analysis. They outlined their use of a framework called Results-Based Accountability (RBA) to define outcomes and measure success. ODAP Manager Eric Jackson stated, "Our job is primarily to enable others to do the work... We're also directly see ourselves as in service to the community. So our goal is also to make a difference in the community's ability to advocate for themselves using data." Jackson also highlighted the importance of tying data thinking into the city budget process for sustainability. Commissioner Michael Hayes remarked, "I think it's imperative for us to take the information that they just shared and utilize concerns it to the best of our ability... Data can make people wake up to us present up to producing results... We have the ability to do that." City Council Liaison Sandra Kilgore added, "I really appreciate the fact that you all are going the extra mile so that we actually can get data that we can use to really impact and make a difference... I really believe that this can actually be a game changer for the community moving forward."

The commission also discussed $20,000 in funding, split between the City and County, originally approved around 2013–2014 to commemorate African American art in the area of the Vance Monument. Because the original presenter was absent, the item was deferred. Staff agreed to contact the Public Art Program liaison to brainstorm ideas and send an email to members about next steps, with a formal presentation planned for the November meeting. Staff also noted they would check with the County regarding their portion of the funding.

## Community Input
A public commenter asked all commissioners to complete a survey released by the Transportation Development Authority (TDA) regarding input for historical markers planned from East End to Depot Street. The commenter noted the deadline was the following day and urged members to review the plans for representing African American history. No specific member responded to this request in the transcript.

## Follow-ups
Staff member Brenda Mills agreed to email the ODAP presentation and contact information to the commission members. She also agreed to contact the Public Art Program liaison to discuss ideas for the memorial project funding, send an email to members about next steps, check with the County regarding their funding for the memorial project, and update the calendar for the next meeting to November 10. Mills further agreed to meet with the Chair and Vice Chair within the next two weeks to coordinate a visit from the North Carolina African American heritage representative to discuss strategic planning. Staff member Leonard Jones agreed to provide information on how individuals can participate as "community ambassadors" for the Buncombe County comprehensive plan if interested. The Chair and Vice Chair agreed to meet with staff to plan the strategic planning session, potentially involving a retreat or document review, for the November/December timeframe.

## Impact
This meeting established a clearer pathway for the commission to utilize data-driven tools for advocacy, as ODAP offered to support the commission in building a "scorecard" or tracking system for African American initiatives. Additionally, the deferral of the memorial project funding discussion ensures that a formal presentation will occur in November, allowing for a more thorough review of the $20,000 allocation. The coordination with Buncombe County on the comprehensive plan and the upcoming dedication of the Remembrance Project historical markers on October 30 highlight the commission's ongoing role in connecting city and county efforts to recognize and address African American history and equity.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmsCo-dZvZw
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2916/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmsCo-dZvZw)
