# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** October 13, 2021 4:00 PM EDT (2021-10-13T16:00:08-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5120/historic-resources-commission-oct-13-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on October 13, 2021, to conduct evidentiary hearings for three Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) applications and to discuss old business regarding reparations recommendations. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous session, which passed by a vote of 6-2, with two members abstaining. The Commission then addressed individual preservation requests before closing the meeting at 6:44 PM.

**Key Decisions and Votes**

The Commission made three primary decisions regarding preservation applications. First, for the application at 37 Watauga Street in the Montford Historic District, the Commission did not vote on the merits of the project. Instead, a motion to grant a continuance passed unanimously (8-0). The applicant is required to further study the placement of a new accessory structure in its original historic location or to demonstrate specific hardships preventing that placement before resubmitting.

Second, the Commission approved the CA for 3 Branbury Cross in the Albemarle Park Historic District. The approval included specific conditions: cross-bracing must be installed on four wood carriage doors, the doors must be painted or darkly stained, and the specific color must be submitted to HRC staff for review before application. Both motions regarding this property passed by roll call with all voting members in favor.

Third, the Commission approved the CA for the relocation of a historic playhouse from 30 Rice Branch Road to the wooded area behind the Rice-Cornell Brown House at 29 Rice Branch Road. The Commission cited that the relocation preserves the structure and maintains historic relationships with the landscape. The motion to issue the certificate passed by roll call with all voting members in favor, and the certificate was issued without conditions.

**Discussion Highlights**

The discussion for 37 Watauga Street focused on the placement and height of a new accessory structure relative to historic guidelines. Chair Emily Kite stated she was looking for compelling reasons to approve the project but emphasized the need to ground the decision in the standards. Commissioner Will Hornaday expressed difficulty approving the project as it stood, noting that the location did not closely follow the standards for accessory carriage houses. Commissioner James Vaughn raised concerns about setting a precedent by violating guidelines regarding story height and original positioning. The applicant’s architect, Michael McDonough, expressed concern that the Commission was raising new concerns about the original footprint that had not been addressed previously.

For 3 Branbury Cross, the discussion addressed an after-the-fact request to replace a roof and install new wood carriage doors. The applicant, Barbara Crew, apologized for not submitting an application initially, stating she believed a door replacement did not require one. Staff noted that standards require all exposed wood to be painted or stained. Commissioner Hornaday suggested pushing for a paint or dark stain to match other garage doors in the area. The applicant agreed to have family members install the cross-bracing and apply a finish to the wood.

The relocation of the playhouse involved testimony from the presenter, who explained the structure’s family history and its architectural ties to the nearby Rice-Cornell Brown House. She emphasized that the playhouse would be placed in a flat, wooded area without cutting trees, would have no electricity or plumbing, and would be painted white. Commissioners asked about the foundation, chimney, and pathway, and several expressed support for the preservation of the structure.

**Follow-ups**

Staff member Shannon Watkins agreed to look up the submittal schedule for the 37 Watauga Street resubmittal and email the applicants regarding the timeline. For the 3 Branbury Cross and Playhouse applications, staff indicated they would follow up with the applicants in the next couple of days regarding the conditions of the approved Certificates of Appropriateness. Regarding the old business on reparations, Shannon Watkins agreed to work with another staff member to look into the application process requirements for submitting a list of Black historic properties to the reparations committee. The Chair suggested sending an email between meetings to prepare for the next session so the Commission would not miss the opportunity to weigh in.

**Impact on Residents**

These decisions impact the preservation of historic structures in the Montford, Albemarle Park, and Rice-Cornell Brown House areas. The approval of the playhouse relocation ensures the preservation of a circa 1930s structure and its architectural details within a local landmark setting. The approval of the 3 Branbury Cross repairs, with conditions for painting and bracing, ensures that the exterior wood of the accessory structure meets historic district standards. The continuance for 37 Watauga Street means that the proposed new pool, courtyard, and accessory structure will not proceed until the applicant addresses the Commission’s concerns regarding the structure's placement in its original historic location. Additionally, the Commission’s work on the reparations list aims to advocate for the preservation of Black historic properties in the region.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWecN9vIrIg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3207/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWecN9vIrIg)
