# Urban Forestry Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** October 5, 2021 1:00 PM EDT (2021-10-05T13:00:16-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5127/urban-forestry-commission-oct-5-2021
**Outcome:** Urban Forestry Commission approved a budget request for a second City Forester and the Urban Forest Master Plan and approved compliance requests for two development projects.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission met on October 5, 2021, to review development compliance cases, update members on legislative and budgetary matters, and discuss ongoing task force work. The agenda included reviews of two specific development projects, staff reports on tree losses and the Tree Protection Ordinance, and updates on the Urban Forest Master Plan and Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) landscape standards.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission approved the minutes from the previous meeting unanimously. The body also voted unanimously to approve alternative compliance requests for two development projects. For 50 Collier Avenue, the Commission approved a request regarding street tree spacing and Silva cell installation. For 424 Sunset Drive, the Commission approved a remediation plan prepared by commission members, with the specific condition that the decision on the street-side fir trees be deferred until a later date to assess maintenance and potential conflicts. Finally, the Commission unanimously approved a budget request recommendation to City Council supporting the funding for a second City Forester and the Urban Forest Master Plan. This motion included two amendments: one adding language to integrate the comprehensive urban forestry program into the climate justice initiative, and another clarifying that the previous "Zero Net Loss" resolution is a statement of agreement rather than official city policy.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Open Space Amendment and the use of fee-in-lieu funds. The Commission debated the City Attorney’s recommendation to pause the expenditure of these funds due to legal ambiguity regarding the definition of "immediate area" and associated litigation risks. Members expressed frustration with the legal stance, with one member stating, "The city attorney's office is entrenched in its position to not take a position... That's an obstruction... We cannot sit on our hands and watch Asheville get... nickel and dimed away until there are no good options left." In response, a staff member noted, "We take risks all the time in our office. It's just a risk aware situation... To deny the outcome here would be to just deny reality."

The Commission also discussed state legislation, specifically HB 496, which prevents local governments from passing tree protection ordinances without state authorization. It was noted that HB 496 was included in the major appropriation bill (SB 105), which went to a conference committee, though its final status was unknown at the time. Additionally, the Commission reviewed a proposal to address urban canopy coverage for urban centers by amending the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance to require a minimum 25% canopy coverage for a new category of urban centers.

Regarding the UDO Landscape Standards Revisions, the Open Space Task Force reported on proposed changes including third-party inspections and minimum soil volume requirements. Cecil Bothwell, a Commission member, emphasized the critical need for enforcement, stating, "The thing I keep returning to is enforcement... There’s no reliable enforcement of these rules. Never, never, never, never are there reliable enforcements." Mark Foster, the City Arborist, added, "It is way easier to meet at commission meetings and talk about the things that you want to have... Getting the staff is the hard part."

**Community Input**
A resident living adjacent to the 424 Sunset Drive property provided public testimony. The commenter alleged that the general contractor regularly ignored city ordinances during the two-year project, including unauthorized land clearing, and reported that on August 15, two men cut down healthy trees, including an oak. The resident urged the commission to ensure the damage is fixed and to be realistic about the trees near the street to prevent future problems. The Chair acknowledged the comments, stating the commission is aware of enforcement issues throughout the city and is working to address them. The Chair noted that the homeowners appear to be trying to improve the property from this point forward and stated, "I can’t speak to the past infractions."

**Follow-ups**
The Chair stated the commission will "keep an eye on" the 424 Sunset Drive property and is available for future questions. The Chair also stated, "I will continue to work with Mark [Foster] as well on the street tree potential issue." Staff member Chris Collins agreed to review written comments regarding a specific project (719.3) where tree identification may be lacking. The Commission agreed to aim for a timeline to have revisions to the canopy amendment ready for the February 2022 meeting. The Open Space Task Force is waiting for a final draft of the amendment to write a position statement for the Planning & Zoning Commission meeting in early November. A member identified as Perrin stated they would provide a legal analysis of the statutes regarding fee-in-lieu funds to the Commission. The Chair, along with two other members, agreed to work on a PowerPoint presentation for City Council to highlight the Commission’s work and the budget request. A member identified as Kim, a Council liaison, agreed to look up the exact legal distinction between a resolution and a policy.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission's focus on balancing development with environmental preservation and the challenges of enforcing existing tree protection laws. The approval of the budget request for a second City Forester and the Urban Forest Master Plan signals a strategic effort to increase the Commission’s visibility and capacity to address urban forestry issues. The debate over the Open Space Amendment fee-in-lieu funds underscores the legal and financial complexities involved in utilizing local funds for open space and tree preservation. Furthermore, the discussion on state legislation and the lack of reliable enforcement for local ordinances reflects the ongoing tension between local goals for a healthy urban forest and the limitations imposed by state law and staffing constraints.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wPDbxMUxDg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2932/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wPDbxMUxDg)
