# Public Safety Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Public Safety Committee
**Date:** September 28, 2021 11:00 AM EDT (2021-09-28T11:00:10-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5129/public-safety-committee-sep-28-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on September 28, 2021, to address three primary agenda items: the approval of previous minutes, an update on recovery efforts following Tropical Storm Fred, and a review of the Asheville Police Department’s (APD) after-action report regarding the 2020 summer protests. The committee also received a presentation on the Buncombe County Community Paramedic Initiative.

**Key Decisions**
The committee’s only formal vote was on the approval of the minutes from the previous month’s meeting. Vice Mayor Shanika Smith called for a vote, and Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore, Councilwoman Kim Roney, and Vice Mayor Smith all voted "Aye," resulting in the unanimous approval of the minutes. Regarding the Community Paramedic presentation, Councilwoman Kim Roney moved to recommend that the full council hear the presentation in a future agenda. City Manager Deborah Campbell accepted this recommendation, agreeing to include the presentation as part of a manager’s update. No formal vote was recorded for this motion.

**Discussion Highlights**
The committee received an update from Emergency Management on the federal emergency declaration process and recovery resources for Tropical Storm Fred, which caused flooding in August 2021. Division Chief Jeremy Knighton noted that all timelines have been met and that a document drop-off for damage claims opened at 59 Woodfin Place. Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that severe rain events may be becoming more frequent in western North Carolina, identifying gaps in preparedness as a major issue.

The committee also reviewed the APD’s implementation of recommendations from the 2020 summer protest after-action report. Police Chief David Zak stated that all 11 recommendations have been implemented, including policy changes and disciplinary actions. However, the discussion shifted to the use of chemical munitions, such as tear gas. Chief Zak argued that as a smaller city with limited resources, APD would be severely limited in its ability to respond if these tools were removed. City Attorney Brad Renham explained that the council has limited authority over APD policy that has been designated to the City Manager. Councilwoman Kim Roney stated she could not support the current stance, arguing that checks and balances are necessary for the use of chemical weapons on the public.

Additionally, the committee heard a presentation on the Buncombe County Community Paramedic Initiative, a pilot program formerly known as the Post-Overdose Response Team. Taylor Jones, the Buncombe County Emergency Services Director, presented data indicating a 5% decrease in opioid consumption and deaths in Buncombe County, contrasting this with a 40% increase across North Carolina.

**Community Input**
Two members of the public provided comments during the public comment period. One commenter from South Asheville expressed concern over police and fire department staffing shortages, noting the police force is down nearly 40%. Vice Mayor Shanika Smith responded by stating that the public comment period is for general comments to the council, not for answering specific questions. A second public commenter expressed disappointment in the wait time for the protest review and criticized the use of tear gas, urging the council to pursue a complete ban on chemical weapons in the community, citing other cities like Portland, Oregon. No member or staff member responded to this specific comment, and the chair immediately moved to adjourn the meeting.

**Follow-ups**
City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to include the Community Paramedic presentation as part of a manager’s update for the full council. Deputy Chief Mike Yelton stated that APD will change policy language regarding the destruction of property to use "public" instead of "citizens" to ensure inclusivity. Police Chief David Zak stated that APD will continue to investigate the 20 anonymous complaints submitted in November 2020, with completions expected in a "very short time." He also stated that APD will continue to research, adapt, and implement crowd control management strategies, including monitoring best practices on the use of chemical munitions.

**Impact**
This meeting provided residents with updates on critical safety and recovery efforts. The approval of the minutes formalized the record of the previous meeting. The Tropical Storm Fred update informs residents of available resources and document drop-off locations for damage claims. The review of the 2020 protest after-action report highlights ongoing policy adjustments within the police department, particularly regarding the use of force and chemical agents, which remains a point of significant community debate. Finally, the inclusion of the Community Paramedic presentation in the full council’s agenda signals that the city will continue to evaluate strategies for addressing the opioid crisis and mental health needs.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IN9J8POTT9I
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2927/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IN9J8POTT9I)
