# Human Relations Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Human Relations Commission of Asheville
**Date:** September 16, 2021 5:29 PM EDT (2021-09-16T17:29:51-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5134/human-relations-commission-sep-16-2021
**Outcome:** The Human Relations Commission discussed the Non-Discrimination Ordinance, reparations process, and recreation center funding without voting on the minutes due to a lack of quorum.

## Summary

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville convened on September 16, 2021, to address a broad range of equity, safety, and administrative issues. The meeting began without a quorum, which prevented the Commission from voting on the approval of the August 2021 minutes. Consequently, no vote was taken on the minutes, and the body proceeded to discuss other agenda items. The session included the introduction of a new member, updates from City staff on ongoing projects, and a detailed review of the newly implemented Non-Discrimination Ordinance.

A significant portion of the discussion focused on the Commission’s future direction and its relationship with City staff. City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized the broad scope of the Commission’s duties, stating that the group needs to define its specific role and how it supports the City. She advocated for a collaborative approach, noting, "I think we ought to work collaboratively... we got to roll up our sleeves and we've got to get to it." New Commissioner Alex Nava agreed with this approach, stating it is important for the Commission to "recognize the limitations of a volunteer run organization" and to start small. Campbell also defined equity as "sharing and caring" and inclusion as "applying to as many conditions as possible."

Commissioners raised concerns regarding public safety and resource allocation in neighborhoods such as Shiloh, Hillcrest, and Deva View. Commissioner Daniel Young expressed frustration that community centers, including Reed, Moffitt, and Pierce-Caview, were closed or stripped of resources, leaving youth without safe spaces. He stated, "Asheville stopped being a community when y'all stopped stripping us from the stuff that was going right for our community... As a black child in Asheville, there's nothing to do." In response, Campbell reported that the recent budget included funds to extend recreation center hours, improve maintenance, and partner with United Way for programming. Additionally, Commissioner Suzy Chandler presented statistics indicating that Buncombe County has worse mortality rates for African American residents than the state average, with cancer and heart disease as leading causes. She asked how the Commission can recommend prevention measures, noting the disparity was "really shocking."

City staff provided updates on several key initiatives. Campbell reported that the Office of Equity and Inclusion (OEI) director position was posted for recruitment, with three support positions also advertised, and that the department is currently staffed by one dedicated interim director. Regarding the reparations process, Campbell noted that Council approved resources to hire a project manager and that a commission of approximately 25 members, including neighborhood representatives and technical experts, will be formed to guide the process. Assistant City Attorney Erin Miles presented the enforcement process for the Non-Discrimination Ordinance, which took effect on July 1, 2021. She explained that the OEI handles complaints for public accommodation and employment discrimination, while housing complaints are referred to the North Carolina Human Relations Commission. The process involves a 10-day response window, investigation, and potential voluntary resolution or a $100 civil penalty.

The Commission also addressed the status of the controversial paintings in Council Chambers. Chair Tanya Rodriguez asked about their current status, and Campbell confirmed they are covered with images of mountains as an interim measure, with plans to replace them with images that better reflect Asheville’s diversity. Staff proposed using a Doodle poll to determine the date and time for the Commission’s upcoming retreat, allowing all members to participate in scheduling. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was made and seconded.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. City Manager Campbell agreed to provide Commissioner Young with additional information regarding the status of new funding for recreation center hours and United Way partnerships. She also stated she would speak with the community engagement division regarding the visibility of the "South Side" name in the citywide 2036 plan and bring that information back to the Commission. Staff will update the Commission on the selection process for the reparations commission and the onboarding of the project manager. Assistant City Attorney Miles agreed to provide a copy of the complaint process forms to the Commission, and staff and the Chair agreed to send a Doodle poll to all members to finalize retreat logistics.

There were no live public comments, emails, or voicemails submitted for this meeting. The discussions and updates provided at this session offer residents insight into the City’s ongoing efforts to address health disparities, improve community resources, and implement new non-discrimination protections. The Commission’s focus on defining its role and collaborating with staff signals a continued effort to integrate equity considerations into City operations.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25cS0GQlLgg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2930/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25cS0GQlLgg)
