# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** September 8, 2021 4:00 PM EDT (2021-09-08T16:00:57-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5140/historic-resources-commission-sep-8-2021
**Outcome:** The Commission approved four renovation applications in the Montford Historic District and unanimously supported the National Register nomination for the High Top Colony neighborhood.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission held a virtual meeting on September 8, 2021, to review five applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (CA) within the Montford Historic District and one staff presentation regarding a National Register nomination. The Commission voted on four CA applications, approving three and approving one with specific conditions, while continuing one application for further revision. Additionally, the Commission unanimously voted to support a National Register nomination for the High Top Colony neighborhood.

**Key Decisions and Votes**

The Commission approved the Certificate of Appropriateness for new construction at Elizabeth Place by a unanimous vote of 6-0. Approval was conditioned on the applicant submitting a revised site plan to staff, specifically addressing the screening of the mechanical unit and landscaping between the house and the paved area. For 66 Flint Street, the Commission unanimously approved the CA for the removal of aluminum siding, restoration of original siding, and the addition of a rear porch/deck, with no additional conditions stated.

The application for a concrete driveway at 27 Houston Street passed with a vote of 5-1, with Commissioner Will Hornaday voting "No." The Commission approved the CA for an amended proposal featuring a 12-foot wide by 18-foot long concrete driveway, requiring the submission of a revised site plan to staff. The application for site work at 185 Pearson Drive was approved unanimously by roll call. The approval included four specific conditions: the removal of the proposed front yard parking change, ensuring the side yard fence terminates at least one foot recessed from the front door, amending the rear deck corners to be rectangular, and submitting a revised site plan and deck drawings to staff for review.

The Commission did not vote to approve or deny the application for 37 Watauga Street, which involved retroactive approval of unpermitted work and new features including a swimming pool, hot tub, and accessory structure. Instead, the Commission unanimously voted to continue the item, instructing the applicant to submit a revised packet by September 20th. The revisions must address the accessory structure’s height to meet the one-and-a-half-story limit and confine the pool and hot tub within the existing disturbed area to avoid further topographic alteration. Finally, the Commission unanimously voted to support the National Register nomination for the High Top Colony, recommending approval to the State Historic Preservation Office and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.

**Discussion Highlights**

During the review of 37 Watauga Street, staff expressed significant concern that the proposed elimination of terracing and further excavation would alter the topography more than what had already been done. A Commissioner noted that the original terracing likely would not have passed Commission review today and that further landscape reconfiguration felt like the "wrong direction." However, another Commissioner suggested that if the new changes could be confined to the already altered area to protect the remainder of the property, they would be more comfortable with the proposal. Chair Emily Kite advised the applicant to explore lowering the second-floor eve height and considering dormers to better reconcile the design with the one-and-a-half-story definition.

Regarding 185 Pearson Drive, staff opposed the new gravel parking area in the front yard, noting that an existing driveway provided sufficient off-street parking. Staff also disagreed with placing a fence near the porch railing, stating it would look out of character. The applicant agreed to amend the application to straighten the path and change the deck shape to rectangular. On the High Top Colony nomination, staff clarified that the Commission acts in an advisory capacity to state and federal bodies. A Commissioner praised the nomination as "very nicely written" and noted it was great to have one in the county outside city limits.

**Community Input**

A public commenter, identified as the owner of 64 Flint Street, expressed excitement about the removal of aluminum siding at 66 Flint Street, a feature that had bothered him for 23 years. He raised concerns that the proposed rear deck might appear as a "three-story deck," which he felt would be overwhelming and inconsistent with the neighborhood’s historic character. In response, a Commissioner noted that a neighboring house to the south has a similar deck that extends further east. Chair Emily Kite stated that the deck is detailed appropriately by being pulled away from the corners and that such a configuration on the rear of a house in Montford is not particularly precedent-setting. Another Commissioner clarified that the structure is a two-story deck/porch and noted that rear elevations are often taller than front elevations in the district.

**Follow-Ups**

Staff agreed to follow up with the applicant for Elizabeth Place in the next few days regarding the revised site plan. For 66 Flint Street, staff stated they would be in touch with the applicant in the next few days. Staff also agreed to follow up with the applicant for 27 Houston Street in the next few days. For 185 Pearson Drive, the applicant agreed to submit a revised site plan and new deck drawings to staff, and staff and the applicant agreed to touch base offline within the next day or so to finalize the deck drawing details. For 37 Watauga Street, the applicant agreed to revise the proposal based on the Commission’s feedback, and staff will review the revised submittal when it is brought back to a future meeting. Additionally, staff committed to discussing offline with Commissioner Shannon Watkins and another staff member whether an HRC representative should be included in technical reviews for properties within a National Register District, and to follow up with the Commission on this matter.

**Impact**

These decisions affect the physical character of the Montford Historic District, a designated area in Asheville where changes to properties must be reviewed to ensure they are appropriate to the historic context. The approvals for Elizabeth Place, 66 Flint Street, 27 Houston Street, and 185 Pearson Drive allow these specific renovations and constructions to proceed, subject to the conditions set by the Commission. The continuation of the 37 Watauga Street application means that the proposed pool, hot tub, and accessory structure cannot be built until the applicant revises the plans to address topographic and height concerns. The support for the High Top Colony National Register nomination provides a formal recommendation to state and federal preservation bodies, which may influence how the neighborhood is recognized and protected in the future.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0MMFBoN-04
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2949/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0MMFBoN-04)
