# Civil Service Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Civil Service Board
**Date:** September 2, 2021 2:30 PM EDT (2021-09-02T14:30:10-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5144/civil-service-board-sep-2-2021
**Outcome:** The Civil Service Board reviewed the new Asheville Police Department disciplinary matrix for informational purposes and approved the previous meeting's minutes.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The City of Asheville Civil Service Board held a virtual meeting on September 2, 2021. The primary agenda item was the presentation of a new disciplinary policy for the Asheville Police Department (APD), specifically the incorporation of a disciplinary matrix.

**Key Decisions**
The Board approved the minutes from the previous meeting held on June 3, 2021. The motion to approve the minutes was seconded by Mike Han, and the vote was taken with ayes from Mike Han, Rick, Carter Webb, and Allen Escovitz. Regarding the APD disciplinary policy, the Board did not vote to approve it. The City Attorney clarified that this is a departmental policy rather than a city policy, meaning it does not require Civil Service Board approval. The Board’s role was limited to reviewing the document for informational purposes, as they may hear cases involving this policy in the future. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn made by Mike Han and seconded by Rick D’Averaux.

**Discussion Highlights**
Chief Sack presented the background of the new policy, explaining that it was developed collaboratively with employee groups (PBA and FOP) to address concerns regarding consistency, fairness, and transparency. The Chief noted, "This did not just come down from the ivory tower. This is something that we worked on collectively... I think when we're collaborating in the fashion that we are, the acceptance from the rank and file will come much, much easier." Board members asked questions regarding how baseline penalties are adjusted, the calculation of suspensions for employees working 12-hour versus 8-hour shifts, and the role of supervisors in coaching versus documenting violations.

Chief Sack emphasized the severity of dishonesty, stating, "There is no circumstance that exists within the police department... that any lack of truthfulness will be tolerated on any level... If you lie on a report or you lie under oath or you alter a document... you're gone." He clarified that suspensions are based on cumulative hours, with one "day" defined as an 8-hour tour for consistency. City Attorney John Maddox commented on the collaborative nature of the policy, stating, "This is pure policy and pure policymaking... I'm very happy at moments like this to say, you guys figure out what you want to do. And I think in this case, they worked very hard to do something equitable." Board member Mike Han praised the effort, saying, "My hat's off to you and Rick for after 16, 17 years finally eliminating some of the ambiguity in the disciplinary policy at APD... I think it's been 17 or 18 [years]... outstanding job."

**Follow-ups**
Chief Sack stated that all APD employees will receive copies of the new disciplinary matrix, it will be rolled out at roll call briefings, and employees will be tested on it to ensure understanding. The Chief also indicated the department plans to roll out information about the new policy through social media and public policy channels to improve transparency. Regarding leadership training, the Chief stated the department will "explore all those options" for supervisors, including looking at schools across the country, to ensure they are equipped to apply the new matrix effectively. Additionally, Sergeant Tullis identified a grammatical error in the Category D description of the policy (changing "substantial risk of an officer" to "substantial risk to an officer") and stated it would be corrected.

**Impact**
This meeting provided residents with insight into the internal disciplinary structure of the Asheville Police Department. The introduction of a disciplinary matrix aims to standardize how violations are categorized and penalized, using mitigating and aggravating factors to ensure discipline is applied evenly regardless of rank. While the Civil Service Board did not approve the policy, their review serves as a check on the department's internal governance, ensuring that the new framework is equitable and transparent before its full implementation.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ST7xa3IMKYY
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2938/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ST7xa3IMKYY)
