# Human Relations Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Human Relations Commission of Asheville
**Date:** July 15, 2021 5:30 PM EDT (2021-07-15T17:30:15-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5169/human-relations-commission-jul-15-2021
**Outcome:** The Human Relations Commission approved the minutes from two meetings ago by unanimous vote and discussed the Land Acknowledgment statement and the transition of the Office of Equity and Inclusion.

## Summary

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a virtual meeting on July 15, 2021. The session addressed procedural matters, community crises, and the future direction of the City’s Office of Equity and Inclusion. The meeting concluded with the approval of previous minutes and a motion to adjourn.

## Key Decisions
The Commission approved the minutes from two meetings ago by unanimous vote. A motion was made to adjourn the meeting, which was seconded and passed by roll call vote. No formal vote was taken on the Land Acknowledgment statement; the Chair indicated that if the Commission wishes to adopt it as a body, it must be added to a future agenda for a vote once a quorum is established.

## Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting focused on the Land Acknowledgment statement, which the Chair has been reading at the start of meetings. Commissioners debated whether the Commission should formally adopt this statement, considering its potential impact on different community groups and procedural requirements. Staff from the City Attorney’s office noted that while the ordinance does not expressly task the Commission with this duty, it is not prohibited. Some commissioners expressed concern about exacerbating tensions between cultural groups in Western North Carolina, while others emphasized the need for clarity and collective agreement.

The discussion expanded to address recent shootings in Asheville and the broader issue of racial equity. Commissioners argued that the Commission must move beyond awareness toward actionable steps, such as holding city entities accountable for data on health disparities, school discipline, and minority business development. One commissioner noted that racism is the number one public health crisis in America and that work groups alone are insufficient without concrete action. Another commissioner emphasized the need to use existing disparity studies to hold entities accountable rather than relying on the suffering of others to legitimize the Commission’s work. Additionally, one commissioner urged the media to be held accountable for spreading false narratives regarding community violence.

The Commission also discussed the transition of the Office of Equity and Inclusion, including staff departures and the upcoming hiring of a new Director. A Deputy City Attorney stated that an announcement regarding the Director of Equity and Inclusion was anticipated early the following week, with the City Manager and the Deputy scheduled to meet to determine a path forward through the transition period. Some commissioners expressed frustration that the department had "run away" and that the Commission had been left alone trying to find purpose due to a lack of support from City Council.

## Follow-ups
Several members and staff agreed to specific follow-up actions:
*   **Health Disparities:** A commissioner agreed to gather data on health disparities in Asheville, specifically regarding mortality rates, vaccine distribution, and the impact of the pandemic on mental health and income.
*   **School Discipline:** A commissioner agreed to bring information from the United Way impact report and school district disciplinary data, specifically regarding disparities affecting Black boys, to the next meeting.
*   **City Schools Accountability:** The Vice Chair and a commissioner agreed to contact Asheville City Schools to discuss suspension rates and support for Black students.
*   **Minority Business Development:** The Chair agreed to reach out to the Minority Business Office to invite them to the next meeting to provide data on business development.
*   **City Manager Presentation:** The Chair requested that the City Manager attend the next meeting to discuss the path forward for the Office of Equity and Inclusion. A Councilwoman agreed to make this request known to the City Manager’s office to support the transition.
*   **Social Media:** A commissioner agreed to follow up via email regarding the Chair’s suggestion to create a Human Relations Commission Facebook page for community interaction.
*   **Meeting Logistics:** Staff confirmed that the next meeting will be in-person on August 19 at 5:30 PM in the first-floor conference room of City Hall and will send an email with parking details.

## Impact
This meeting highlights the Commission’s intent to shift its focus from general awareness to specific accountability measures regarding health, education, and economic disparities. By assigning specific data-gathering tasks to commissioners and requesting the City Manager’s presence at the next meeting, the body is seeking to address the transition of the Office of Equity and Inclusion and ensure that city entities are held responsible for addressing racial equity gaps. The decision to return to in-person meetings in August signals a move toward more direct community engagement as the Commission continues its work.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9A67GB3z-ag
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3298/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9A67GB3z-ag)
