# Human Relations Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Human Relations Commission of Asheville
**Date:** June 24, 2021 5:31 PM EDT (2021-06-24T17:31:26-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5176/human-relations-commission-jun-24-2021
**Outcome:** The Human Relations Commission discussed internal conflict, reviewed the Director of Equity and Inclusion hiring, and established a framework for using working groups to handle complex issues.

## Summary

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a regular meeting on June 24, 2021. The session addressed the commission’s operational scope, ongoing hiring processes, and internal dynamics, while also reviewing community initiatives and procedural mechanisms for handling complex issues.

## Key Decisions
The commission moved forward with the June 24, 2021 agenda without a recorded vote, following advice from the City Attorney that a formal vote was not required to proceed. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was seconded and passed unanimously via roll call vote, with all present commissioners voting in favor.

## Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to addressing interpersonal conflict within the commission. One commissioner stated that their continued participation is contingent on actionable steps to address abusive language used by another commissioner in the previous meeting. The commissioner who used the language responded with an apology, explaining that the incident was a technical issue regarding microphone control and was not directed at any specific individual.

The commission also reviewed Ordinance No. 4663 to clarify the body’s scope, duties, and membership criteria. Staff provided updates on the hiring process for the Director of Equity and Inclusion, noting that the City Manager’s office is in the final stages of reviewing candidates. Additionally, staff announced that advisory boards are expected to return to in-person meetings in August, with a transition period involving CDC-compliant safety measures.

Commissioner Daniel Young raised concerns about the lack of city support for the Young Men’s Institute (YMI) and Goombay, contrasting it with funding for other events. He noted, "They gave $52,000 for fireworks. And on the reals, the city really didn't donate nothing for June 10th... We need some help." The commission discussed the possibility of holding a meeting at the YMI and inviting a presentation from the organization.

The commission discussed the use of working groups to handle complex issues efficiently. The City Attorney explained that working groups, which consist of fewer than a quorum, can conduct research and bring back finished proposals to the full board, streamlining the decision-making process. He clarified, "The working groups themselves have no power in and amongst themselves. Their job would simply be to do some additional work to streamline the process and then to bring it to the consideration of the full body to take action if they so choose to do so."

Regarding virtual public comment, one commissioner noted that community members have requested the continuation of virtual public comment options for City Council meetings for accessibility reasons. Another commissioner stated she did not support making a recommendation to City Council, noting that virtual comment had been a short-term measure and that the commission currently lacks sufficient public participation to warrant such a recommendation. A third commissioner expressed support for a working group on virtual access, citing accessibility issues for disabled and low-income residents. Staff noted that the lack of live calling comments was due to staff capacity and that they are exploring options as they return to in-person meetings.

## Community Input
No public comments were received via email or live audience during the public comment period.

## Follow-ups
Staff agreed to send the draft minutes from the May meeting to the committee folder as soon as possible. The City Attorney agreed to review the "Honor Native Land" document and provide input at the next meeting. He also agreed to provide a one-sheet report on the status of minority contracts issued by the city. Regarding the YMI, the City Attorney stated that city staff are exploring options to provide assistance and that the new Director of Finance has been asked to look into it. The Chair invited two commissioners to work together on a recommendation regarding virtual public comment for the next meeting. Additionally, the Chair proposed inviting a representative from the YMI to present to the commission at the next meeting.

## Impact
This meeting established a framework for the commission to handle complex issues through working groups, which allows for streamlined research and proposal development before full body consideration. The discussion on virtual public comment highlights ongoing debates regarding accessibility and the balance between short-term pandemic measures and long-term procedural changes. The focus on supporting the YMI and reviewing minority contracting data reflects the commission's role in advocating for equitable resource distribution and community engagement within the city.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6MapcF4p34Q
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2965/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6MapcF4p34Q)
