# Design Review Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Design Review Committee
**Date:** June 17, 2021 12:00 PM EDT (2021-06-17T12:00:18-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5179/design-review-committee-jun-17-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee met on June 17, 2021, to review three primary development projects and address the status of a fourth. The agenda included a formal design review for a new mixed-use building at 120 Biltmore Avenue, a conditional zoning review for an expansion of the Four Points Sheraton at 22 Woodfin Street, and an informal design review for the Aloft Hotel expansion at 51 Biltmore Avenue. Additionally, the committee discussed the status of the Collier Avenue project, which was postponed to the next meeting.

**Key Decisions**
The committee approved the formal design review for the 120 Biltmore Avenue project by a unanimous vote of 5 ayes. This approval allows the nine-story mixed-use building, which includes extended-stay hotel units, residential condos, and retail space, to proceed to its next phase of review. For the 22 Woodfin Street project, a substantial addition to the existing hotel, the committee approved the project with conditions by a unanimous vote of 5 ayes. The conditions require the applicant to review the building’s interface with the urban landscape at specific corners and pedestrian entrances, provide landscaping or public art activation along Central Avenue, and work with City Council to provide additional civic contributions commensurate with the project's size. The committee noted that while the project exceeds the maximum horizontal wall dimension, the applicant has mitigated this by breaking up the massing. No vote was taken on the 51 Biltmore Avenue Aloft Hotel expansion, as this was an informal review; staff informed the applicant that the project must next submit for technical review, followed by formal design review and Planning and Zoning Commission review. The meeting adjourned by unanimous vote among the remaining members.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the review of 120 Biltmore Avenue, the architect explained that the design balances modern glass with sand and stone-colored fiber cement panels to blend with the historic context. The architect also agreed to revise the roof structure holding solar panels to align columns with the solid portions below and thicken the roof edge to improve integration. For the 22 Woodfin Street project, committee member Jeremy Goldstein disclosed that he is an adjacent property owner but has no financial interest in the project; the committee voted to allow him to participate. Staff identified four areas of non-compliance with the Unified Development Ordinance, including exceeding setback requirements and failing to reset ground floor elevation where the sidewalk drops more than six feet. Debate centered on the interpretation of the 145-foot maximum horizontal wall dimension; staff noted the standard intends to break up mass for light and air, while the architect argued that step-backs and material changes meet the intent of the guideline. Concerns were raised regarding the lack of pedestrian activation on the steep Central Avenue side and the generic appearance of the southwest corner, which one member criticized as feeling like a "parking lot."

For the 51 Biltmore Avenue expansion, the committee discussed the industrial-age aesthetic of the facade and the plan for a placeholder mural on the alley-facing wall. Staff cautioned against replicating the slick sidewalk material of the existing Aloft hotel, suggesting a different approach for the new addition. The architect proposed relocating the bus stop to better align with the building design. Regarding the Collier Avenue project, a member stated, "I'm assuming we are pushing the Collier Avenue project to the next meeting."

**Community Input**
No public comments were received for the 120 Biltmore Avenue or 51 Biltmore Avenue projects. For the 22 Woodfin Street project, staff noted that prior public comment had been received via voicemail and email from a resident who stated the project was out of scale, expressed concern about the height, and raised issues with the lane reduction on Woodfin Street. A committee member responded to the height concern, stating he did not find it out of scale compared to nearby buildings, but agreed with the resident’s recommendation for civic contributions along Central Avenue. During the discussion of the Collier Avenue project, a public commenter thanked the committee for extending the meeting time and asked that specific residents send email comments regarding the 44 Collier project to the staff team before the next meeting. No member of the committee explicitly responded to this request or confirmed they would relay the message.

**Follow-Ups**
The architect for 120 Biltmore Avenue agreed to revise the solar panel roof structure as discussed. The civil engineer for that project stated they would continue coordinating with city stormwater staff regarding public system connections. For 22 Woodfin Street, the civil engineer stated he would double-check emails regarding the traffic impact study and NCDOT approval for the lane reduction. The architect stated they would work on clarifying the pedestrian entry and potentially narrowing the sidewalk by two feet to allow for a planting strip along Central Avenue. Staff stated she would investigate the interpretation of the "maximum horizontal wall dimension" guideline. The Collier Avenue project was pushed to the next meeting, and residents were invited to send email comments regarding 44 Collier to the staff team prior to that meeting.

**Impact**
These decisions advance significant development projects in the downtown area. The approval of the 120 Biltmore Avenue project allows a new nine-story mixed-use building to move forward, adding housing, retail, and parking to the corner of Biltmore Avenue and South Market Street. The conditional approval of the 22 Woodfin Street expansion requires the developer to address specific urban design concerns, including pedestrian activation and civic contributions, before the project can proceed further. The informal review of the Aloft Hotel expansion provides initial feedback on the design of the new seven-story condominium hotel addition, which will undergo further technical and formal reviews. The postponement of the Collier Avenue project allows for additional public input and staff preparation before the committee takes action on that item.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rRJ-j09HJSo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3216/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rRJ-j09HJSo)
