# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** June 11, 2021 9:29 AM EDT (2021-06-11T09:29:25-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5182/downtown-commission-jun-11-2021
**Outcome:** Downtown Commission deferred a vote on the draft noise ordinance to allow for further stakeholder input and forwarded the hotel design submittal to the Design Review Committee.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met on June 11, 2021, to address the status of the city’s draft noise ordinance, review a design submittal for a major hotel development, and receive updates on parking and the downtown budget. The primary focus of the meeting was the ongoing development of the noise ordinance, which has been in process for nearly two years, including a ten-month halt due to the pandemic.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission approved the minutes from the May 14, 2021 meeting via a unanimous roll call vote. No vote was taken on the noise ordinance; the Chair determined it was not prudent to vote at this time because recommendations are not finalized and further stakeholder meetings are scheduled. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn.

**Discussion Highlights**
Development Services Director Ben Woody presented an update on the noise ordinance, emphasizing that the city is reimagining noise enforcement as a program rather than a simple ordinance update. He outlined a transition of enforcement from the Asheville Police Department to a Development Services program focused on a "good neighbor" approach, prioritizing education before enforcement. Staff recommended a six-month trial period to collect data, potentially finalizing the ordinance by January 2022. The proposed ordinance includes a context-based "noise disturbance" standard for public and residential areas and objective decibel standards for commercial private property. A tiered permit system was proposed for events exceeding base limits, ranging from simple notice for up to two events per year to an acoustical engineer’s plan for up to 30 events, limited to existing performance centers.

Members debated the proposed decibel levels and curfews. Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson urged the Commission to support city staff’s recommendations for lower decibel levels and earlier curfews, stating that a 12:00 AM curfew is too late for an area with many residents. Vice Chair Ruth Summers expressed concern that the proposed 75 decibel level and allowance for up to 30 events annually would discourage people from moving downtown. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher shared an experience where a downtown venue declined to restart its music program due to uncertainty surrounding the ordinance. Commissioner Sage Turner noted concerns about increased car noise and suggested that design guidelines, such as sound-reducing windows and tree plantings, could help mitigate noise. Commissioner Dane Barriger summarized the sentiment of some stakeholders as a request to delay the ordinance until there is a better understanding of its needs.

The Commission also reviewed a complete design submittal for a hotel expansion and new building at the existing Four Points Sheraton site on 22 Woodfin Street. Senior Planner Shannon Tuck presented the design, which features light and red brick, anodized aluminum, and perforated metal balconies. Staff raised concerns regarding blank wall expanses on the Central Avenue elevation and a foundation wall exceeding height limits; the applicant has revised the design to add fenestration to address these issues. Design comments will be forwarded to the new Design Review Committee, while non-design comments will go to the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council. Additionally, Karen Ramsey, representing the Parking and Transportation Working Group, highlighted challenges including poor signage, aging garages, and the lack of a long-term strategy, noting that downtown is the only area where the city charges for parking.

**Community Input**
The Commission received nine pages of written comments regarding the noise ordinance. A letter from a downtown resident who had recently passed away was read by Commissioner Sage Turner. The resident expressed concern that the proposed ordinance would allow noise levels dangerous to health and would discourage residential development, urging the Commission to advise the City Council to modify the ordinance to ensure downtown remains livable for residents. The Chair thanked the Commissioner for sharing the letter, though no specific member responded directly to the content in the transcript.

**Follow-ups**
Development Services Director Ben Woody agreed to connect with Commissioner Dane Barriger after the meeting to provide a link for a Monday meeting with a coalition of Asheville neighborhoods and music professionals to discuss decibel levels. Chair Moffitt stated he would work with Commissioner Dane Barriger to contact interested members and reconstitute the parking working group to address the issues raised. Additionally, in response to a question from Commissioner Ruth Summers, Chair Moffitt agreed to request that the applicant provide specific product specifications for the "light brick" material before the Design Review Committee meeting on June 17.

**Impact**
This meeting is significant for residents as it addresses the balance between commercial entertainment and residential livability in the downtown core. The noise ordinance, scheduled for full City Council consideration on June 22, 2021, will determine the allowable noise levels and curfews in the area. The Commission’s decision to defer a vote allows for further stakeholder input, particularly regarding the decibel standards and curfew times that directly affect residents living near venues. Additionally, the reconstitution of the parking working group aims to develop a long-term strategy for downtown parking, addressing concerns about the lack of investment and the unique charging model in the downtown area compared to other parts of the city.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gFgwsgEVdg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2974/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gFgwsgEVdg)
