# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** June 9, 2021 4:02 PM EDT (2021-06-09T16:02:02-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5183/historic-resources-commission-jun-9-2021
**Outcome:** The commission approved certificates of appropriateness for a fence and a new building, continued the 119 Cumberland Avenue conversion to July, and reviewed the legal status of the Charlotte Street resolution.

## Summary

**Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: June 9, 2021**

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission met virtually on June 9, 2021, to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (CA) within the Montford Historic District and to discuss the legal status of a resolution regarding a development on Charlotte Street. The commission addressed three primary construction and renovation projects, with significant debate centered on the architectural compatibility of a proposed residential conversion.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The commission voted unanimously (8-0) to adopt the minutes from the March meeting. Regarding the application for 240 Pearson Avenue, the commission voted unanimously (8-0) to continue the item to the July meeting. For 90 Montford Avenue, the commission unanimously approved the CA to replace a chain-link fence with a 42-inch tall metal picket fence, set back four feet from the retaining wall. The CA was issued with the condition that the applicant submit revised fence drawings for staff approval. For 23 Cumberland Circle, the commission unanimously approved the CA for a new two-story primary structure. The CA was issued with four conditions: the applicant must submit shingle and siding samples, a stone sample for the retaining wall cap, lighting specifications, and mechanical unit specifications for staff approval.

**Discussion Highlights: 119 Cumberland Avenue**
The most extensive discussion concerned the application for 119 Cumberland Avenue, which involves converting a mid-century non-contributing structure (formerly a church) into 12 residential units. The commission debated the visual impact of metal balconies, which several members described as "heavy," and the painting of the brick facade. Chair Emily Kite stated that the commission had not reached a consensus on a successful outcome for the motion, identifying balcony detailing/proportion and painted brick as the main issues. Commissioner Lazarus expressed opposition to painting the brick, noting it is a separate era of addition. Commissioner Hornaday agreed that the brick should remain unpainted but expressed interest in seeing other versions of the balcony. Commissioner Eakins voiced concern about the visibility of the metal balconies from the street.

After further discussion, a motion was made to continue the application to the July 14 meeting. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously (8 ayes, 0 nays). The application will be resubmitted with revised plans.

**Community Input**
Public comment was received for the 119 Cumberland Avenue application. One public commenter, living on the alleyway side, expressed excitement about the project but opposed the metal balconies, arguing they do not fit the neighborhood character and requested that the east side be treated as a front-facing elevation. Another public commenter expressed confusion regarding the commission’s stance on preserving historical integrity while opposing painted brick but appearing open to "ultra modern contemporary" glass balconies.

In response to the comments, Chair Kite stated that the commission needs to be mindful of street frontage regarding balcony placement and suggested minimizing balconies on street-facing sides. A commissioner explained that painting the brick affects "architectural integrity," while balconies fall under guidelines for "alterations and additions" regarding compatibility. Another commissioner noted that glass railings allow the original unpainted brick to show through, helping preserve visual character. Members did not directly respond to the specific request to reclassify the east side as a front-facing elevation.

**Charlotte Street Resolution**
The commission reviewed the aftermath of a non-binding resolution passed in the previous month opposing the demolition of historic buildings associated with a new mixed-use development on the 100 block of Charlotte Street. The City Attorney provided an update on legal challenges raised by the developer’s attorney, clarifying that the commission was acting in an advisory capacity and that no conflict of interest existed. The City Attorney reported that the demolition permit passed the Planning and Zoning Commission narrowly (4-3) and will now move to the City Council.

**Follow-Ups**
Staff member Alex Smith agreed to follow up with the applicant for 23 Cumberland Circle regarding next steps and to check the file for the Hunter Banks building to verify if painted masonry was previously reviewed. Chair Emily Kite agreed to email the applicant for 119 Cumberland Avenue to confirm the timeline for resubmission and to send the legal memo and Charlotte Street resolution to all commission members. The City Attorney agreed to ensure every commission member sees the legal memo clarifying the HRC’s advisory role. The applicant for 119 Cumberland Avenue agreed to request a continuance, revise balcony railing designs and roof solutions, and communicate offline with staff regarding a target resubmission deadline around June 23 or June 28. Commission members also agreed to form a working group to plan future award celebrations and to explore pitching the city for reparations funds to support preservation of historically significant properties.

**Impact**
These decisions affect the physical character of the Montford Historic District. The approval of the fence and new construction at 23 Cumberland Circle allows for specific material and design modifications subject to staff review. The continuation of the 119 Cumberland Avenue application means that the conversion of the former church into residential units is not yet approved; the applicant must revise plans to address concerns about balcony visibility and brick treatment before the commission can vote on the project in July. The legal clarification regarding the Charlotte Street resolution confirms the commission’s advisory role in the ongoing development process, which is now before the City Council.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfMvD7LG0GI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2975/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfMvD7LG0GI)
