# Boards & Commissions Committee - June 8, 2021

**Body:** City of Asheville — Boards and Commissions Committee
**Date:** June 8, 2021 10:00 AM EDT (2021-06-08T10:00:14-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5185/boards-commissions-committee-june-8-2021

## Summary

On June 8, 2021, the City of Asheville Boards and Commissions Committee convened to review recommendations for vacant seats on various city advisory boards and commissions. The meeting also included a review of a proposed Ethics Policy for these bodies. All agenda items were approved unanimously by the committee.

## Key Decisions and Appointments
The committee approved the minutes from the May 11 meeting. Following this, the committee voted to appoint or reappoint members to ten different boards and commissions. All appointments passed with a unanimous 3-0 vote.

*   **African American Heritage Commission:** The committee appointed Ryan Thomas. This decision came after Councilwoman Mosley raised concerns regarding the residency of the originally recommended candidate, Dwayne McAfee, noting that the board chair expressed a preference for a resident within city limits.
*   **Board of Electrical Examiners:** The committee reappointed Drew Pike, Russell Thatcher, and Roger Vault, and appointed Donald Massey. Councilwoman Roney noted that while Mr. Massey resides in Madison, his unique skill set warranted the appointment.
*   **Citizen Police Advisory Committee (CPAC):** The committee reappointed Robert Hooper to the Housing Authority staff seat.
*   **Civic Center Commission:** The committee reappointed Makunda Pacifici and appointed Mitchell Eaton.
*   **Historic Resource Commission:** The committee appointed Georgene Falcon.
*   **Human Relations Commission (HRCA):** The committee appointed Crystal Reed. Councilwoman Roney moved to appoint Ms. Reed over the originally recommended candidates, citing her experience in the residence council for Klondike, which aligned with the committee’s goal of finding someone with experience in housing authority neighborhoods.
*   **Multimodal Transportation Commission:** The committee postponed appointments and re-advertisement until next month. This decision was made to allow time for subcommittee designations to be finalized.
*   **Neighborhood Advisory Committee:** The committee reappointed Mike Wesmer and appointed Juan Pablo Charlecar for the 82801 seat.
*   **Noise Ordinance Appeals Board:** The committee reappointed Wayne Wheeler and Patrick Gilbert for full terms, and Todd Levin for one year. Assistant Clerk Jerry Goldberg clarified the motion to ensure the one-year term for Mr. Levin was correctly recorded.
*   **Public Art and Cultural Commission:** The committee reappointed Johanna Hargitay and Allie McGee, and appointed Reggie Tidwell.

## Ethics Policy
The committee approved a proposed Ethics Policy for advisory boards and commissions, which was drafted with the legal department and modeled after other North Carolina municipalities. The policy covers decorum, conduct, harassment, social media, and conflict of interest. During the discussion, Councilwoman Roney suggested adding language stating that a group "may act within the scope of their designated responsibilities as outlined in the establishing resolution." This addition was intended to clarify that advisory boards can perform duties specified in their resolutions, such as public education, rather than limiting them to advising Council only. The committee voted to approve the policy with this suggested amendment.

## Follow-ups
Staff members agreed to take the following actions:
*   Re-advertise and conduct targeted outreach for the remaining fifth position on the Board of Electrical Examiners.
*   Re-advertise for the two remaining open seats on the Citizen Police Advisory Committee.
*   Re-advertise for the last vacant seat on the Historic Resource Commission.
*   Re-advertise for the seats on the Multimodal Transportation Commission, with appointments postponed until next month.
*   Re-advertise for the 82803 zip code seat on the Neighborhood Advisory Committee, for which no applications were received.

## Impact
These decisions ensure that the City’s advisory boards and commissions are staffed with members who possess the specific skills and local experience required for their roles. The approval of the Ethics Policy establishes a standardized framework for the conduct and responsibilities of these advisory bodies, providing clarity on how they may operate within the scope of their establishing resolutions.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFmNKRNyvbE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2973/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFmNKRNyvbE)
