# Civil Service Board

**Body:** City of Asheville — Civil Service Board
**Date:** June 3, 2021 2:29 PM EDT (2021-06-03T14:29:30-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5186/civil-service-board-jun-3-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Civil Service Board held a virtual meeting on June 3, 2021, to review recommendations from the Asheville Fire Department (AFD) regarding changes to promotional criteria and processes for Fiscal Year 2022. The primary focus of the agenda was updating minimum requirements and promotional process weights for Assistant Fire Marshal, Lieutenant, Battalion Chief, and Division Chief positions.

The Board approved the minutes from the February 4 meeting by a unanimous vote of 4 ayes and 0 nays. Following this, the Board voted on two substantive motions regarding the fire department’s personnel policies. First, a motion moved by Mike Hahn and seconded by Rick Devereaux to accept changes to the minimum requirements for Assistant Fire Marshal and Lieutenant positions passed unanimously with 4 ayes and 0 nays. Second, a motion moved by Mike Hahn and seconded by Carter Webb to approve component changes for the Battalion Chief and Division Chief promotional processes also passed unanimously with 4 ayes and 0 nays.

During the discussion, Chief Burnett of the AFD explained the rationale behind the proposed changes. For the Assistant Fire Marshal role, the change aligns with North Carolina Department of Insurance protocols, replacing the "Fire Inspector 2" requirement with "Fire Inspector 1 plus a probationary Level 2 certificate" because the state now requires inspectors to perform as a "probationary level two" under supervision before taking the final certification test. Regarding the Lieutenant role, Chief Burnett stated, "We feel that removing that fire inspector one requirement frees up their attention to the things that are applicable to the job that they do every day," proposing to replace the certification with an in-house "AFD Community Risk Reduction" course.

The Board also discussed adjustments to the promotional processes for Battalion Chief and Division Chief, which involved shifting percentage weights for structured interviews and role-play exercises and adding a 5-point "Fire Chief’s Discretion" component. Chair Alan Escovitz asked about the optics of using discretion points, asking, "How do you address that and how do you get around that kind of perception or optics?" Chief Burnett responded, "For me transparency and openness is key... I made sure that all of the candidates that were involved in the process heard directly from me that I am applying these points because this person has stepped up and acted out of class." Additionally, Rick Devereaux asked if assessors tend to cluster scores at the top of the range; Chief Burnett replied that while the most common score is in the middle, top performers are often separated by a very narrow margin.

No public comments were received for this meeting. Staff confirmed that no live comments were provided and no written comments were received beforehand.

Regarding follow-ups, Carter Webb stated that he would not be able to attend the next meeting, which he believed was scheduled for July 1st. Staff member Beth noted that the city is working through the transition to in-person meetings, with the first in-person City Council meeting scheduled for the 8th, but there is no current timeline for when all city boards will resume in-person meetings; she promised to keep the board updated. Outside counsel John Henning stated that he would look into the status of a bill in the General Assembly intended to clarify remote meeting rules, specifically regarding hybrid meetings.

These decisions update the qualification standards and evaluation methods for senior fire department promotions. The changes ensure that the minimum requirements for Assistant Fire Marshal and Lieutenant roles align with current state insurance protocols and departmental needs, while the adjustments to the Battalion Chief and Division Chief processes modify how candidates are scored during interviews and role-plays.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58-dkpnrwaA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3215/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58-dkpnrwaA)
