# Public Safety Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Public Safety Committee
**Date:** June 1, 2021 3:00 PM EDT (2021-06-01T15:00:39-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5190/public-safety-committee-jun-1-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee held a virtual meeting on June 1, 2021, to address critical public safety staffing issues, drug enforcement funding, and significant revisions to local noise and alarm ordinances. The agenda focused on the department’s capacity to handle emergencies, the allocation of federal grants, and the balance between community quality of life and local economic activity.

**Key Decisions**
The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting unanimously (3-0). Regarding the High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area (HIDA) grant, a motion to approve the resolution to apply for and accept the 2021 grant and move it forward to City Council passed with a vote of 2-1. Vice Mayor Smith and Councilwoman Kilgore voted in favor, while Councilwoman Roney voted against. The committee also unanimously (3-0) voted to recommend the revised noise ordinance to the full council, incorporating specific changes to match the daytime, nighttime, and curfew recommendations of Wilmington, North Carolina, along with a provision to revisit the ordinance in six months. Finally, the committee unanimously (3-0) voted to send the revised alarm ordinance forward to the full council for its first reading on June 22, 2021.

**Discussion Highlights**
APD Chief David Zak presented data highlighting a severe staffing crisis, noting that 82 officers have left since January 2020, resulting in a 35–38% daily reduction in sworn staff. This shortage has led to a 50% reduction in the detective bureau and significant increases in response times, such as 38 minutes longer for priority 3 calls. Chief Zak stated that the department is "completely gassed out" with the volume of investigations and will have to triage cases based on severity. He also noted that violent crime levels, including shots fired calls and homicides, have remained steady compared to the previous year.

Development Services Director Ben Woody presented final recommendations for the noise ordinance, which utilizes a two-fold enforcement approach: an objective decibel standard for commercial and industrial zones and a subjective "noise disturbance" standard for residential and public spaces. Woody clarified that businesses on their own property are not subject to decibel limits, but must adhere to standards when noise affects others. He explained that the city is dropping the specific music venue permit, meaning venues, bars, and breweries do not need a permit provided they meet the ordinance's decibel levels. For street musicians, or buskers, staff noted that enforcement will initially focus on education, acknowledging that duration and location are factors alongside decibel levels. Staff also clarified that they lack the authority to stop vehicles for noise violations, a responsibility that remains with APD, though the department currently lacks the capacity to enforce this effectively.

A police presenter outlined a revised alarm ordinance designed to reduce the high rate of false alarms, which has been 97% since 2018. The proposal includes enhanced call verification requirements for alarm companies, new fee schedules, and graduated penalties to reduce the burden on APD resources.

**Community Input**
Residents and stakeholders provided extensive input, primarily regarding the noise ordinance and police accountability. Commenters representing downtown residents and occupational health experts argued that the proposed 85-decibel sound exceedance limit is a public health hazard and an "absurd" occupational standard for a community setting, warning that such noise levels would force residents to convert homes to short-term rentals. Commenters from the music industry, including a musician/producer and a co-founder of Asheville Music Professionals, argued the ordinance would be "detrimental to the lifeblood of the music scene," noting the industry supports the local economy with over $170 million annually. They requested the city honor compromises reached with the Coalition of Asheville Neighbors regarding event numbers and curfews.

Other commenters expressed frustration with the city’s handling of the 2020 protests and the focus on "war on drugs" tactics. A long-time resident and veteran argued the council was not adequately addressing transnational organized crime and fentanyl. A West Asheville resident and real estate agent urged the removal of $276,000 from the police budget to hire professionals for mental health, substance use, and housing issues. A homeless resident called for a reduction in the police budget and an increase in harm reduction services. A city staff member spoke regarding the officer exodus, attributing it to a lack of accountability and public anger, and stated that the community wants the police defunded. A downtown resident raised concerns about Section 1088, which allows for private, for-profit outdoor amplified music events, arguing it would privatize public space. A board member of the Asheville Area Arts Council responded by clarifying that the "exceedance permit" limits events to one or two per year unless specific mitigation efforts are shown. Members did not respond to these comments during the recorded portion of the transcript.

**Follow-ups**
APD Chief David Zak agreed to provide a breakdown of how the $158,000 in COVID emergency supplemental funding was spent. Vice Mayor Smith proposed reformatting committee meetings into a "work group" or "think tank" to actively work through reimagining public safety, consolidating 911, and reorganizing relationships with the school system and housing authority. City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to structure conversations around these challenges to provide status reports and feedback to the committee. Development Services Director Ben Woody stated that staff are working with APD to implement regular data dumps of dispatch call data to help proactively address chronic noise issues. Staff agreed to convene a group including the Coalition of Asheville Neighbors and the Asheville Music Professionals to discuss decibel levels to ensure partner consensus before the full council vote. Additionally, staff agreed to bring the noise ordinance back to the committee in six months for review and potential adjustment, as part of the passed motion.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions reflect the city's ongoing efforts to balance limited public safety resources with community needs. The approval of the HIDA grant and the revised alarm ordinance aims to address high-level drug trafficking and reduce the burden of false alarms on police resources. The noise ordinance revisions, which will be reviewed again in six months, attempt to balance the economic interests of the music industry with the quality of life for residents, while the committee’s shift toward a "think tank" model signals a broader intent to restructure how public safety services are delivered and funded.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K55A0IedfEA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3217/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K55A0IedfEA)
