# Historic Resources Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** May 12, 2021 3:59 PM EDT (2021-05-12T15:59:21-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5203/historic-resources-commission-may-12-2021
**Outcome:** Historic Resources Commission approved three Montford Historic District applications, continued two to June, and recommended the South Asheville Cemetery for the National Register.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission held a virtual meeting on May 12, 2021, to review applications within the Montford Historic District and address administrative updates. The commission approved the minutes from the April meeting and conducted evidentiary hearings for five property applications. Additionally, the body reviewed state law changes, a National Register nomination, and upcoming events, and elected its executive officers for the new term.

The commission took action on four of the five Montford Historic District applications. For 90 Montford Avenue, the commission unanimously approved a Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) to replace a non-historic section of a retaining wall and associated sidewalk, with the condition that the applicant eliminate the fence from this specific approval. For 32 Panola Street, the commission unanimously approved a CA for the installation of 17 solar panels on a southeast-facing roof. For 279 Cumberland Avenue, the commission approved a CA for a new primary structure, subject to five conditions including an arborist consultation regarding a mature Spanish Oak, and staff approval of specifications for garage doors, patio materials, flagstone, and mechanical units. The application for 240 Pearson Drive / 240 Cumberland Avenue, which involved modifying a historic carriage house, was continued to the June meeting.

During the discussion of the 240 Pearson Drive / 240 Cumberland Avenue application, Chair Emily Kite emphasized the importance of retaining character-defining elements, stating that the proposed carriage door was "too big" and that the commission is more protective of the street-facing elevation. Commissioner Will Hornaday expressed concern that the proposed gate did not fit the historic district, noting, "This is the historic district... very few fences and even fewer gates." The applicants were advised to revise their drawings to remove the gate and adjust the carriage door width to a range of 10 to 12 feet before resubmitting.

On the 23 Cumberland Circle application for a new two-story house, the commission continued the application to the June meeting. Staff expressed concern that the proposed board-and-batten siding created a "very vertical feeling" that was too contemporary for the neighborhood. The architect was asked to revise the design to use more traditional horizontal siding, such as lap siding or shingles, and to adjust the color palette to be lighter.

Administrative items included an update on the state’s recodification of land use laws under Chapter 160D. Staff explained that appeals of commission decisions will move to Superior Court, notice requirements will be limited to adjacent property owners rather than those within 200 feet, and discretionary decision-making powers will transfer from staff to elected or appointed officials. The commission also voted to recommend the South Asheville Cemetery, the oldest African-American cemetery in Western North Carolina, for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Finally, the commission elected its executive officers: Emily Kite as Chair, Emily Spring as Vice Chair, Gail Lazarus as Secretary, and Will Hornaday as Treasurer.

Staff agreed to several follow-up actions. Deputy City Attorney Jannice Ashley will update the commission’s Rules of Procedure to reference Chapter 160D and remind members of quasi-judicial standards at the next meeting. Assistant City Clerk Alex Smith will follow up with applicants regarding material submittals for 90 Montford Avenue, the resubmittal deadline for 240 Pearson Drive, and additional information for 279 Cumberland Avenue, including landscaping plans. Smith will also collect RSVPs for the HRC Award event scheduled for May 22.

These decisions impact residents by establishing standards for new construction and renovations within the Montford Historic District, ensuring that changes to historic structures and new homes align with the neighborhood’s architectural character. The approval of the National Register nomination for South Asheville Cemetery recognizes its historical significance, while the updates to the commission’s procedures reflect new state laws that affect how land use decisions are made and appealed in the city.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7TddXeb2Vo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2995/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7TddXeb2Vo)
