# City Council Budget Work Session – May 11, 2021

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** May 11, 2021 2:35 PM EDT (2021-05-11T14:35:05-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held its fifth and final budget work session on May 11, 2021, to review the City Manager’s recommended budget draft before its formal presentation at the regular council meeting on May 25, 2021. The session focused on the final stages of the budget-building process, which included internal departmental reviews, community engagement sessions, and employee input. Staff presented draft recommendations for various city departments, revenue sources, and tax rates, noting that these items are scheduled for a formal vote at the upcoming regular meeting. No public comment period was held during this work session, which was conducted between council members and staff.

**Key Decisions**
The council recorded several votes during the meeting, primarily regarding administrative appointments and fee structures, though the main budget items were deferred to the May 25 meeting. The council unanimously (7-0) voted to continue the public hearing until May 25, 2021, and to adopt the Consent Agenda. Unanimous votes (7-0) were also recorded to adopt a resolution authorizing the submission of the City’s Annual Action Plan for 2021-2022 to the U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development, and to approve an ordinance amending the fees and charges manual for Fiscal Year 2021-22.

The council approved an ordinance establishing the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Water Resources Fees & Charges by a vote of 6-1, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no. A motion to approve an ordinance amending the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Fees & Charges Manual to include a special event fee discount passed unanimously (7-0). Regarding appointments, the council unanimously (7-0) appointed Brandy Woodward and Chris Day to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, and reappointed Carol Goins and Carter Webb to the Civil Service Board for additional two-year terms. The council also unanimously (7-0) appointed Jane Mathews, Ben Williamson, and Jeremy Goldstein from the Riverfront Redevelopment Commission to the Design Review Committee, and reappointed Tanya Rodriguez, Veronica Coit, and DeLores Venable to the Human Relations Commission. A motion to appoint Robin Raines, Steven Lee Johnson, Bryan Moffitt, and Kimberly Hunter from the Downtown Commission to the Design Review Committee passed with a 5-2 vote, with Council Members Kim Roney and Antanette Mosley voting no.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff presented the draft budget, highlighting significant investments in reparations, neighborhoods, housing, youth services, public safety, transportation, environment, and economic development. Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that property taxes are the primary revenue source for North Carolina cities and expressed a desire to avoid increases that might force residents to move or sell their homes. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the numbers could not be balanced without a tax rate above revenue neutral and noted that some initiatives, such as the potential consolidation of 911 services with Buncombe County, will need to be finalized during the year.

Council Member Kim Roney expressed concern that raising property taxes to fund these initiatives could cause more harm, asking for clarification on which open positions were frozen and whether the city could fill them. Council Member Gwen Wisler opposed implementing compensation adjustments incrementally, arguing that delaying the full implementation would only defer the cost to the following year. Council Member Sage Turner expressed impression with the city’s response to the pandemic and hoped for discussions on additional positions to support staff. Finance Director Tony McDowell clarified that the budget assumes a 1.5% vacancy rate and does not budget 100% of every employee for the entire year. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody clarified that tree fund money can be used on private property, provided the city retains the ability to enforce tree maintenance.

**Follow-ups**
Finance Director Tony McDowell agreed to provide information on positions already at market rate and the specific breakdown of the $7.9 million compensation cost to address concerns about wealth gaps. He also agreed to share the previous Finance Committee presentation on property tax abatement/deferral programs and new information on Durham County’s tax deferral program with the full council. Additionally, he agreed to modify the tax impact slide to clearly state that it only reflects the city portion of the tax bill, excluding county and school taxes, and to provide data on the tax impact for homes assessed higher than the median upon request. He also agreed to send the draft budget electronically rather than printing it.

Assistant City Manager Ben Woody confirmed that tree ordinance "fee in lieu" payments are collected prior to the Certificate of Occupancy. City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to look into how the city can better assess needs for an Urban Forester position after understanding the current level of effort for tree ordinance enforcement. She also agreed to research other communities, such as Charlotte and Durham, for models of income-based property tax assistance programs to mitigate the impact of the tax increase on vulnerable residents.

**Impact**
The draft budget proposes a property tax rate 3 cents above revenue neutral (41.3 cents vs. 38.3 cents), which would generate approximately $5.7 million to cover new investments. For the median single-family home, assessed at $294,500, the city portion of the tax bill would rise from $995 to $1,215 annually, an increase of approximately $18.33 per month. The budget includes a $200,000 annual allocation and a one-time $1 million initial allocation for reparations, funded by fund balance. It also proposes $200,000 for a small-scale neighborhood grant program, $1.1 million for transit expansion starting in October, and $300,000 to maintain current household recycling levels. Employee compensation will see a full implementation of the Archer Compensation Study, costing approximately $7.9 million, along with the addition of two new paid holidays and expanded paid leave. Water rates will increase slightly, remaining below Fiscal Year 2020 levels, while solid waste and stormwater fees are not recommended for increase at this time.

## Votes

- Motion for the adoption of the Consent Agenda. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18519))
- Motion to continue this public hearing until May 25, 2021. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18520))
- Motion to adopt a resolution authorizing submission of the City’s Annual Action Plan for 2021-2022 to the U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development and authorizing the City Manager to sign all contracts or agreements required for the implementation of the 2021-2022 Annual Action Plan. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18521))
- Motion to approve an ordinance amending the fees and charges manual for Fiscal Year 2021-22. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18522))
- Motion to approve an ordinance establishing the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Water Resources Fees & Charges. — Passed, 6-1 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18523))
- Motion to approve an ordinance amending the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Fees & Charges Manual to include a special event fee discount. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18524))
- Motion to appoint Brandy Woodward (HACA staff member) and Chris Day (general housing experience) as members of the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, to each serve until September 1, 2021, and then to each serve a fully three-year term, terms to expire September, 2024, or until their successors have been appointed; and (2) appoint ZaKiya Bell-Rogers (general housing experience) to fill the unexpired term of Parker Smith, term to expire September 1, 2024, or until ZaKiya Bell’s successor has been appointed. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18525))
- Motion to reappoint Carol Goins and Carter Webb as members of the Civil Service Board, to each serve an additional two-year term respectively, terms to expire May 11, 2023, or until their successors have been appointed. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18526))
- Motion to appoint Robin Raines, Steven Lee Johnson, Bryan Moffitt and Kimberly Hunter from the Downtown Commission as members of the Design Review Committee. All term expirations are to coincide with their term expiration on the Downtown Commission, or until their successors have been appointed. — Passed, 5-2 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18527))
- Motion to appoint Jane Mathews, Ben Williamson and Jeremy Goldstein from the Riverfront Redevelopment Commission as members to the Design Review Committee. All term expirations are to coincide with their term expiration on the Riverfront Redevelopment Commission, or until their successors have been appointed. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18528))
- Motion to (1) reappoint Tanya Rodriguez, Veronica Coit and DeLores Venable as members of the Human Relations Commission, to each serve a two-year term respectively, terms to expire June 1, 2023, or until their successors have been appointed; and (2) appoint Emma Worthy to serve a two-year term, term to expire June 1, 2023, or until Emma Worthy’s successor has been appointed. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/city-council-budget-work-session-may-11-2021#vote-18529))

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFEpUY_AHqA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3221/segments

## Documents

- [minutes_2021-05-11_from_packet_27333.md](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5204/documents/30111/minutes-2021-05-11-from-packet-27333md)

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFEpUY_AHqA)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
