# Planning & Zoning Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Planning and Zoning Commission
**Date:** May 5, 2021 4:59 PM EDT (2021-05-05T16:59:22-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5208/planning-zoning-commission-may-5-2021

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a virtual meeting on May 5, 2021. The body addressed administrative items, including the approval of previous minutes and the continuation of a pending rezoning request. The Commission also conducted legislative hearings on two significant development proposals: a residential project at 70 Mills Gap Road and a mixed-use development at 101 Charlotte Street.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to approve the minutes from the April 7, 2021 meeting, incorporating a requested correction regarding the terminology of a "site" versus a "space." The body also voted unanimously (7-0) to continue the rezoning request for 1617 Hendersonville Road to a future date of June 2, 2021. Additionally, the Commission approved the rezoning of 99999 Glendale Avenue from Residential Multifamily High Density to Commercial Industrial, including a Future Land Use Map amendment, with a vote of 6-0 as one commissioner was disconnected. The body also approved amendments to Articles 3, 4, 6, and 7 of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to align with recent state legislation, also passing with a vote of 6-0.

**Discussion Highlights: 70 Mills Gap Road**
The Commission reviewed a request to conditionally rezone a 34.5-acre property for 76 single-family homes, including five affordable units. Staff recommended denial due to environmental impacts, specifically noting that the design exceeded steep slope grading limits and encroached on aquatic buffers. Staff Planner Shannon Tuck described the project as "a little bit too impactful" and suggested a different design would be more compatible with the environment. Commissioner Jenifer Bubenik expressed concern about a 25-foot retaining wall near homes, while Commissioner Brenton Faircloth opposed the project due to driveway lengths shorter than a standard parking space. Commissioner Archibald requested a traffic study to address cumulative impacts in the area. The applicant’s representative stated they would discuss potential changes with their engineer and client, indicating the client might submit a revised plan or request an up-or-down vote at the next meeting. The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to recess the public hearing until June 2, 2021, without making a final decision on approval or denial.

**Discussion Highlights: 101 Charlotte Street**
The Commission heard a request to conditionally rezone 17 parcels in the Chestnut Hills National Historic District for a mixed-use development featuring approximately 210,000 square feet, 181 residential units, and commercial space. Staff recommended denial primarily due to the demolition of 12 contributing historic structures and a lack of sufficient information to assess neighborhood compatibility. The applicant’s attorney argued that while the structures are contributing to the National Register, they are not individually designated local landmarks, and thus there is no federal restriction on their removal. The City’s Historic Preservation Planner clarified that National Register listing affects tax credit eligibility but does not prevent demolition. The applicant presented a revised cross-section for Charlotte Street, showing a donation of 13–25 feet of private land to the public right-of-way for improved pedestrian and bike infrastructure. Commissioner Levi raised concerns about the height of the proposed buildings relative to nearby structures, and Commissioner Faircloth expressed concern about the long-term affordability of the units. No motion was made, and no vote was recorded for this item in the provided transcript segment.

**Community Input**
Public commenters were divided on the 101 Charlotte Street project. Supporters, including residents and a professional urban planner, argued that the project addresses the city’s housing crisis, promotes the maker economy, and improves pedestrian safety, with one planner stating that opposing the project constitutes "economic segregation." Opponents, including an attorney for the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County, argued that the demolition of historic structures would damage the neighborhood’s character, noting the organization has 4,000 signatures on a petition for an alternative approach. The Chair responded to the public comments by stating that commission members are volunteers who spend significant time reviewing information and expressed frustration with a specific email regarding technical difficulties. The Chair noted that questions raised during public comment would be answered after the comment period closed.

**Follow-ups**
For the 70 Mills Gap Road project, the applicant’s representative agreed to discuss potential changes with their client and engineer, with any changes to be submitted to planning staff before the next hearing. Staff confirmed that an email response from the city traffic engineer regarding cumulative traffic impacts would be sufficient for the Commission’s review. For the 101 Charlotte Street project, the Deputy City Attorney requested that the applicant clarify the total number of for-sale versus rental units in the B1 conditions, and the applicant agreed to provide this clarification. The applicant also stated that conversations are ongoing with the city’s affordable housing department regarding the potential to increase the affordable unit count to 20% to qualify for a Luigi Grant.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions impact residents by determining the future development of two significant properties in Asheville. The 70 Mills Gap Road project remains pending, with the Commission seeking further information on traffic and environmental impacts before a final decision. The 101 Charlotte Street project involves a large-scale mixed-use development in a historic district, raising ongoing debates about the balance between new housing density and historic preservation. The approval of UDO text amendments ensures the city’s development code remains aligned with current state legislation.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pLV0FC4yprk
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3004/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pLV0FC4yprk)
