# Urban Forestry Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** May 4, 2021 1:00 PM EDT (2021-05-04T13:00:21-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5209/urban-forestry-commission-may-4-2021
**Outcome:** The Commission approved alternative compliance requests for two Foundy Street properties and recommended that City Council fund an Urban Forester position and oppose state housing bills.

## Summary

The Asheville Urban Forestry Commission convened on May 4, 2021, to address alternative compliance requests, state legislative advocacy, budgetary needs, and proposed ordinance amendments. The meeting focused on balancing development requirements with tree canopy preservation, particularly in areas with limited soil conditions or existing commercial infrastructure.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission approved the minutes for January, February, and March 2021 unanimously. The body voted unanimously to approve alternative compliance requests for two properties at 11 Foundy Street and 36 Foundy Street, allowing for smaller tree caliper sizes and the substitution of native shrub-like grasses and perennials for some required shrubs. Additionally, the Commission unanimously passed a motion recommending that the City Council fund an Urban Forester position and an Urban Forest Master Plan. The Commission also unanimously voted to recommend that the Asheville City Council oppose the enactment of Senate Bill 349 and House Bill 401. The meeting adjourned via a unanimous 7-0 roll call vote.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff and presenters discussed the alternative compliance requests for the Foundy Street properties, noting that industrial, compacted soil and limited space make standard planting difficult. Jennifer Blevins, Urban Planner for Development Services, stated that the site’s conditions might inhibit growth, adding that planting at smaller sizes seems to encourage trees to settle in better. Matt Sprouse, Landscape Architect for SiteWorks Studios, emphasized the goal of giving trees a chance to thrive, noting that smaller sizes have proven successful in previous development phases.

Regarding state legislation, the Commission discussed SB 349/HB 401, which would strip local governments of authority over single-family zoning, potentially forcing dense development and reducing tree canopy. Patrick Gilbert, Vice Chair, explained that the bill’s effect would be a loss of trees and tree canopy. Perrin DeYoung, a member, described the legislation as "anti-local control" and suggested that attacking it as a "Trojan horse" for anti-conservative initiatives is a productive line of argument. Steve, a member, expressed concern about how canopy coverage would be maintained in densified areas, stating the Commission needs to be involved.

The Commission also reviewed proposed amendments to the tree canopy protection ordinance regarding "Urban Centers." Sharon, a member, raised concerns that the current ordinance allows developers to use existing "building impact trees" as credit, which could reduce new planting in areas with low existing canopy. She suggested that building impact trees should be part of the requirement rather than a credit. Chris Collins, Assistant Director of Planning & Urban Design, clarified that street trees usually do not count toward canopy requirements because they are in the right-of-way, but theoretically, a preserved street tree on the property meeting dimensional requirements could count.

**Community Input**
A public commenter, identifying as a member of the Tree Protection Task Force, spoke against SB 349/HB 401, arguing that stripping local zoning authority would lead to tree canopy loss and exacerbate climate change impacts. The commenter noted that a separate bill, SB 436, would preserve local tree protections and asked the Commission to issue a statement opposing the housing bill. A member expressed appreciation for the input and affirmed the need to oppose the bill.

**Follow-ups**
Patrick Gilbert agreed to compile talking points from previous budget pushes for Ed Fisher and Dawn Chavez. Dawn Chavez, of Asheville Green Works, agreed to lead the budget advocacy effort, while Kim Roney, the City Council Liaison, agreed to include the Commission’s recommendation in her report to Council ahead of the May 11 budget work session. Regarding the 424 Sunset remediation plan, Sharon from the Technical Review Committee and Ed Macy agreed to walk the property with owners in two weeks to offer suggestions for soil remediation and replanting. Ed Fisher stated that the Policy Working Group will focus on a complete rewrite of Chapter 20 (trees on public property) and will convene a meeting in the next week or two. Patrick Gilbert agreed to send current ordinance language and notes on requested changes to the Policy Working Group for the Urban Centers review, which the group agreed to place on their agenda for the next meeting. Dawn Chavez agreed to edit the draft mission statement to better address equity and inclusion, with the group agreeing to circulate edits for a vote at the next meeting. Patrick Gilbert also offered to draft a resolution or letter opposing SB 349/HB 401 for Commission review at the next meeting.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission’s active role in advocating for tree canopy preservation amidst legislative and development pressures. By recommending funding for an Urban Forester and a Master Plan, the Commission is seeking to establish long-term infrastructure for managing the city’s urban forest. The approval of alternative compliance requests for the Foundy Street properties allows for development to proceed while adapting planting strategies to challenging soil conditions. The Commission’s unified stance against SB 349/HB 401 reflects a concern that state-level changes to zoning authority could undermine local efforts to maintain tree canopy and mitigate heat island effects.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CULVEBhLgmo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3303/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CULVEBhLgmo)
