# Board of Adjustment

**Body:** City of Asheville — Board of Adjustment
**Date:** April 26, 2021 1:59 PM EDT (2021-04-26T13:59:45-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5216/board-of-adjustment-apr-26-2021

## Summary

The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held a virtual meeting on April 26, 2021, to address zoning variances and administrative matters. The agenda included the adoption of previous minutes and the review of two variance petitions: a sign variance for a commercial property on South Tunnel Road and a grading variance for a residential lot on Altamont View.

**Key Decisions**
The board unanimously voted to adopt the minutes from the March 2021 meeting. Regarding the first case, a sign variance request for the Asheville Marketplace at 4 South Tunnel Road, the board voted to continue the hearing. The decision was made to allow the applicant to obtain a precise measurement of the existing sign, as the current square footage had not been accurately verified by the city or the applicant. For the second case, a grading variance for a property at 662 Altamont View, the board voted to grant the variance, allowing the maximum grading allowance to increase from 15% to 25%. The petitioner was informed that they have one year to utilize the granted variance.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the discussion of the sign variance, the petitioner argued that adding signage was necessary to accommodate new tenants in a struggling retail center. The Chair expressed skepticism regarding the claimed hardship, stating that the need for additional sign space was likely self-created by subdividing lease spaces rather than being unique to the property. Another board member noted difficulty in identifying an "unnecessary hardship" based on the petitioner's responses. Staff indicated that while a second sign could potentially be placed on the property’s north frontage by right, the petitioner argued that location was not visible to passing traffic.

For the grading variance, the petitioner’s agent argued that the property was "unbuildable" under the current 15% disturbance limit because the minimum required house size exceeded the allowed area. The agent emphasized that the site plan would adhere to state requirements for stormwater management and site drainage regardless of the increased disturbance. The Chair stated that the request passed the legal tests for a variance, and another board member agreed, noting that without the variance, the lot would essentially be useless and that the proposed footprint did not exceed those of surrounding homes.

**Community Input**
Two members of the public provided comments regarding the grading variance. One resident, who owns the property directly below the subject lot, expressed concern about drainage and erosion affecting their private driveway, asking for assurance that the new home would not create additional hardships. The petitioner’s agent responded by assuring the board that the site plan would adhere to state requirements for proper drainage and stormwater management. A second resident, an adjacent neighbor, expressed support for the petitioners, noting that the lot was cut before the current slope ordinance was passed and that the owners had worked hard to minimize impact. No specific board member replied directly to this second comment before the board moved to discussion.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to be available to meet with the sign company on-site to assist with the precise measurement of the existing sign for the 4 South Tunnel Road case. The staff member indicated that the case would typically be scheduled for the next meeting in May, though this was noted as tentative depending on the contractor's availability. No specific follow-up actions were assigned for the granted grading variance at 662 Altamont View.

**Impact**
This meeting resulted in the approval of a grading variance for a residential property in a steep slope zone, allowing for a larger house footprint than previously permitted. The sign variance for the commercial property on South Tunnel Road remains pending, with the next step being the accurate measurement of the existing signage to determine if a variance is actually required.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0XqSirx2M0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2997/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0XqSirx2M0)
