# Transit Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Transit Committee
**Date:** April 20, 2021 3:30 PM EDT (2021-04-20T15:30:15-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5217/transit-committee-apr-20-2021
**Outcome:** Transit Committee approved the January minutes and tabled the motion to fund evening routes S3 and S6 due to a lack of quorum.

## Summary

The Transit Committee approved the minutes from the January 20, 2021 meeting and the current meeting agenda via roll call votes. Two other motions were introduced but did not result in a final decision. A motion to endorse a proposal for a de-escalation officer at the transit center was made and seconded, but no vote was recorded after staff indicated the proposal is still under review by the City Manager and Assistant City Manager. Additionally, a motion to fund evening service hours and routes S3 and S6 in the FY2022 budget was tabled because a quorum was not present during the roll call.

## Discussion Highlights

Staff provided updates on ongoing operations, noting that the contract with Yonge Transportation is expected to run through June 2021 to support social distancing measures. Staff also reported that over 21,000 masks are currently on hand for distribution on buses and at the transit center. Barry Reiling, General Manager of RATP Dev, presented on transit operations, highlighting a shortage of six full-time drivers and the challenges of maintaining service during the pandemic. Reiling noted that while he supports additional help, he believes criminal activity at the transit center will not simply cease.

Carmen Ybarra of Better Buses Together presented a proposal to replace conventional security guards with professionals trained in de-escalation, conflict resolution, and mental health intervention. In response, staff clarified that the city is not necessarily looking to remove all security guards but is reviewing what is feasible, including tracking issues at the station with RATP Dev. The committee also discussed the impact of free fares on bus capacity and on-time performance. Chair Rachelle Sorensen-Cox expressed support for implementing fares to manage capacity and prioritize essential riders, stating, "I am so glad you brought up fair [fares]. I would really like to encourage the team to look at increasing fairs first as a way to offset capacity because I do see some necessity riders."

## Community Input

No public comments were received for this meeting. The Chair noted the lack of input and encouraged the committee to actively solicit public comments during future open periods.

## Follow-ups

Staff agreed to double-check the exact end date of the Yonge Transportation contract and provide an update to the group. Staff also agreed to continue reviewing the Better Buses Together safety proposal with the City Manager and Assistant City Manager to determine feasibility. Staff stated they will present fare recommendations to the committee before moving forward and plan to present budget numbers and the master transit plan at the June meeting. The committee agreed to table the discussion regarding radio communication protocols for a later date.

## Impact

This meeting addressed critical operational challenges, including driver shortages and the management of rider behavior at the transit center. The committee’s focus on reviewing fare structures and security models reflects an effort to balance public safety with service accessibility. The decision to table the funding motion for evening routes due to a lack of quorum means that specific funding for routes S3 and S6 in the FY2022 budget remains unresolved until the committee meets again in June.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nj8G-NUuPg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3334/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nj8G-NUuPg)
