# City Council Retreat – Day 2 Morning

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 1, 2021 8:30 AM EDT (2021-04-01T08:30:03-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5230/city-council-retreat-day-2-morning-apr-1-2021
**Outcome:** Council refined its strategic plan by consolidating focus areas and proposing new priorities, including a Housing First model and community benefits agreements.

## Summary

**City Council Retreat: Strategic Planning Refinement**

On April 1, 2021, the Asheville City Council convened for the second day of a strategic planning retreat, focusing on the morning session to refine the city’s long-term goals. The agenda centered on the "messy middle" of the planning process, where the council and staff moved from initial brainstorming to defining specific, actionable priorities. The session was a closed-door working meeting with no public comments recorded. No formal votes were taken, as the session was dedicated to consensus-building and strategic refinement rather than legislative action.

A primary focus of the discussion was streamlining the city’s existing eight focus areas and 13 specific priorities by identifying logical overlaps. The council reached a consensus that "Equitable and Diverse Community" should serve as a guiding lens applied to all other goals, such as housing and environment, rather than a standalone category. Staff and members also suggested combining "Clean and Healthy Environment" and "Financially Resilient City" under a broader sustainability framework. Council Member Sage Turner noted that sustainability includes multiple arms, while Council Member Kim Roney emphasized that transportation sits at the intersection of equitable access, environmental responsibility, and economic mobility.

The council conducted a status review to distinguish between goals that are fully completed, those that are "operationalized and monitored," and those that remain active policy priorities. For example, the council determined that the strategy for city-owned land is not fully complete and remains a priority to address land acquired through urban renewal and redlining. Conversely, the development of the small and minority business inclusion policy was deemed complete, though its implementation remains a priority requiring funding and staffing. The council also shifted the transit focus from identifying new tax revenue to identifying opportunities to fund transit through collaboration with Buncombe County, noting that legislative requests for a transit tax have already been submitted.

To replace completed or operationalized items, the council proposed several new strategic goals for the upcoming term. These proposed priorities include identifying funding for reparations, implementing community benefits agreements for all conditional uses, and distributing COVID-19 relief funds with a focus on equitable distribution. Other proposed goals include adopting a "Housing First" model, implementing participatory budgeting, increasing home ownership rates, developing resilient food systems, assessing land availability to address NIMBYism, and reimagining public safety through a "divest and invest" strategy that decentralizes focus from the Asheville Police Department to all city departments.

During the session, Mayor Esther Manheimer remarked on the tendency to inadvertently add items to lists during brainstorming that later lack clear purpose. Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith emphasized the need to be respectful of staff who will execute the work after the meeting concludes. Council Member Sandra Kilgore noted that presenting ideas in a structured form has reduced tension between the council and the community. Staff member Nicholas Beeman advised the group to focus on the logical connections between vision themes rather than the sequence or naming of categories.

Staff members agreed to provide additional information on the operationalization status of various goals to assist the council in its decisions. Staff are also tasked with continuing to operationalize and monitor items moved off the new priority list, such as transit corridor studies and UDO amendments. Additionally, staff agreed to provide cost estimates for proposed transit service changes, including extending service hours and increasing frequency in South Asheville. A staff member is documenting the decisions in real-time to create a refined list of priorities.

The council agreed to continue the detailed review of the 13 priorities in a consolidated group format to ensure all voices are heard. Council members are to finalize the new list of priorities, including timelines and funding requirements, before the end of the retreat. They will also review the "operationalize and monitor" list to ensure it is comprehensive. This process aims to create a clear, accountable strategic plan that reflects the city’s interconnected goals for equity, sustainability, and community well-being.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7ZPl_Fm5t8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3037/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7ZPl_Fm5t8)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
