# City Council Retreat – Day 1 Afternoon

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 31, 2021 3:42 PM EDT (2021-03-31T15:42:42-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5231/city-council-retreat-day-1-afternoon-mar-31-2021
**Outcome:** Council discussed the 20-year vision, 13 strategic priorities, and reparations, agreeing to refine the list to a smaller set of critical priorities for the next day.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
On March 31, 2021, the City Council of Asheville held the afternoon session of its strategic retreat. The primary focus of this closed-door session was a comprehensive review of the City’s 20-year vision statement, adopted in 2016, and the 13 strategic priorities established in 2019. The agenda was dedicated to discussion, reflection, and planning, with no formal votes, motions, or official resolutions taken during the afternoon.

**Status of Strategic Priorities**
Staff presented a detailed status report on the 13 priority areas, acknowledging that the 2020 pandemic shifted some focus to crisis management but noting that progress was maintained. Key accomplishments highlighted included transportation improvements, such as increased on-time ridership from 50–60% to approximately 70% and the completion of transit center renovations. In affordable housing, staff reported the creation of 373 units leveraging city tools and private partnerships, including the 360 Hilliard project and the purchase of the former Matthews Ford site. Crisis response efforts included the use of the Harrah’s building for 60 congregate housing beds and the Red Roof Inn for 136 non-congregate housing placements, with 33 individuals moving to permanent housing. Other areas reviewed included the creation of an "Equity Collaborative" with the school system, the implementation of a race and gender-conscious Business Inclusion Policy, and the adoption of a climate emergency resolution.

**Discussion on Reparations and Prioritization**
A significant portion of the debate centered on the concept of reparations. Staff noted that while "reparations" was not explicitly listed as a standalone priority in the 2016 vision, the work done in equity, housing, and public safety serves as a form of reparation. City Manager Deborah stated, "What you probably don't see is you don't see reparations. And that was intentional... I think all of these things that we've accomplished... is about reparations... If adopting the resolution and creating a process of addressing our concerns is the best that we can do, then shame on us." Council members debated whether reparations should be a named, standalone priority or an embedded value. Council Member Gwen Wisler proposed that it be "embedded as a value as opposed to kind of this like a priority because that just does seem like you're putting it in a silo." Council Member Antanette Mosley countered that "Reparations is very targeted... We're doing what's best for Asheville based on the overall need. But reparations... repairs and heals parts of history that has not affected everybody the same." Facilitator Nicholas added, "I think history has its eyes on you... You could create a model for what this looks like inside of a community."

**Public Safety and Economic Recovery**
The council also discussed public safety and economic recovery. Council Member Sheneika Smith stated, "I think our goals around reimagining public safety should be furthered... There's some really incredible and unique opportunities... specifically earmarked for very precise things... We might need more EMTs within the fire department to partner with the county system." Council Member Sage Turner suggested, "I would say perhaps greater collaboration amongst... other local governments, regional government, county government... how might we work together to ensure a just recovery." Regarding staff performance, Mayor Esther Manheimer remarked, "I feel proud of y'all. And I feel proud of our talented staff for making all this happen for us today."

**Follow-ups and Next Steps**
No formal action items were assigned, but several commitments were made for the continuation of the retreat. Council members agreed to spend the evening reflecting on their individual priorities and to bring their "critical few" recommendations to the table for the next day’s session. Staff committed to providing clear direction and implementation support for the priorities selected by the council. The facilitator stated that the group would work on refining the list of 13 priorities down to a smaller "critical few" and integrating new topics, such as reparations and pandemic recovery, into the strategic plan for the coming year. Additionally, the City Manager stated that staff would continue to work on the "30-60-90 day work plan" related to social unrest and equity, and that the city would continue to track data on the success of education "pods" to determine if the model should continue.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2eJsRb2MBYM
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3227/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2eJsRb2MBYM)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
