# City Council Budget Work Session – March 23, 2021

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 23, 2021 2:25 PM EDT (2021-03-23T14:25:08-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021
**Outcome:** Council reviewed the financial status of enterprise funds and discussed proposed water rate changes, with no votes taken.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held an informational budget work session on March 23, 2021, serving as the second of three scheduled sessions for the current budget cycle. The meeting was strictly informational, with no votes taken and no public comment accepted. The primary focus of the session was to review the financial status of the city’s enterprise funds and to discuss proposed changes to utility rates in response to the economic impacts of the pandemic.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
No decisions, motions, or votes were taken during this work session. The council did not approve, reject, or adopt any budgets, fee changes, or other actions. The session was designed solely to provide data and context for future deliberation.

**Discussion Highlights**
The council reviewed the financial performance of the city’s enterprise funds, which operate similarly to private businesses and rely primarily on fees rather than property taxes. While the general fund has held up well financially, enterprise funds were adversely impacted by the pandemic. Specific impacts included:
*   **Harris Center:** Revenue decreased by approximately $2 million in the first eight months due to cancelled events, with expenses managed by reducing personnel and supplies.
*   **Parking:** Revenue decreased by approximately $2.2 million due to waived fees and reduced demand.
*   **Transit:** The fund experienced a loss of approximately $700,000 in fare revenue due to fare-free service, along with approximately $2 million in additional expenses for supplemental buses to maintain social distancing.
*   **Stormwater:** No fee increase was implemented this year due to the pandemic, creating a future shortfall for capital needs.

A significant portion of the discussion focused on water rate realignment. Director of Finance Tony McDowell presented the necessity to adjust water rates to recover revenue lost from the discontinuation of the Capital Improvement Fee (CIP) following a 2018 North Carolina Supreme Court ruling. McDowell emphasized that the city is examining fees through an "equity lens" to understand how changes may impact customers, particularly in light of the economic impact of COVID-19. Consultant Doug Carter from DEC and Associates stated that the proposed realignment retains fairness and comparability to peer utilities, allowing for better forecasting over a five-year planning cycle. Council Member Sage Turner expressed support for returning to a system that allows the city to get on track with water infrastructure.

Regarding transit, Council Member Kim Roney noted that the approximately $700,000 in lost fare revenue is instead being spent in other ways in the community because the city did not create a barrier to entry by requiring a fare. A staff member explained that as long as social distancing standards are in place, bus capacity will be limited, mirroring restrictions in restaurants and retail. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the city is cognizant of the cumulative impact of multiple fee increases, rather than looking at each fee in isolation.

The council also received an initial overview of the American Rescue Plan (ARP). Director of Finance Tony McDowell noted that the city is expected to receive about $26 million directly allocated from the federal government, with a current deadline of December 31, 2024, to use those dollars. He emphasized that specific guidance from the U.S. Department of Treasury is still pending, leaving many questions unanswered regarding allowable uses.

**Follow-ups**
Several specific follow-up actions were agreed upon by staff or requested by council members during the Q&A portion of the meeting:
*   **Transit Data:** In response to questions from Council Member Kim Roney, a staff member agreed to provide a report on the number of missed trips due to equipment breakdowns, fleet issues, or staffing shortages. The same staff member also agreed to provide the ridership data used to justify the suspension of weekend and late-night service on the N1 route to UNCA.
*   **Water Rate History:** In response to a request from Council Member Gwen Wisler, staff indicated they would provide a history of water rates over a 10-year period, including a comparison with the Metropolitan Sewer District (MSD), for the upcoming Finance Committee meeting.
*   **General Fund Support:** Director of Finance Tony McDowell stated he would verify the exact amount of General Fund support provided to the Transit fund (estimated at ~$7 million) and share the specific number with the Council.
*   **Rate Sheet Access:** Council Member Sage Turner stated she would send the link to the water rate sheet to the Council, noting that it is available online.

**Impact and Next Steps**
This work session provided the council with critical data regarding the financial strain on enterprise funds and the rationale for proposed water rate adjustments. The discussions highlighted the city's approach to balancing fiscal recovery with equity considerations during the pandemic. Staff intends to bring proposed fee changes to the City Council for approval at their last meeting in April, prior to the final budget adoption. Additionally, staff is working to schedule a Finance Committee meeting for early April to review fee changes, and the next budget work session is scheduled for April 13, with a focus on the Capital Improvement Program (CIP).

## Votes

- Councilwoman Turner moved for the adoption of the Consent Agenda with the deletion of Consent Agenda I.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Wisler and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18506))
- Councilwoman Wisler moved to approve the resolution amending the City Council 2021 meeting schedule as described above.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried 6-1 on a roll call vote, with Councilwoman Roney voting "no." — Passed, 6-1 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18507))
- Councilwoman Turner moved to continue the public hearing to consider an ordinance to amend Articles II and XVI of the Unified Development Ordinance to update definitions and regulations related to homestays until May 11, 2021. This motion was seconded by Vice-Mayor Smith and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18508))
- Councilwoman Wisler moved to approve the proposed wording amendments to Chapter 7 Articles V, VIII, IX, XI and XII of the UDO and find that the proposed amendments are reasonable, are in the public interest,  are consistent with the City's comprehensive plan and meet the development needs of the community in that the amendments will, 1) promote responsible growth based on holistic decision making; and, 2) bring City ordinances into compliance with the new North Carolina General Statute Chapter 160D, regarding land use development.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Kilgore carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18509))
- Councilwoman Turner moved to permanently close an unopened right-of-way known as Trade Street. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Kilgore and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18510))
- Councilwoman Wisler moved to adopt the resolution approving the 2021 Limited Obligation Refunding Bonds.  This motion was seconded by Vice-Mayor Smith and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18511))
- Councilwoman Wisler moved to adopt the resolution approving the 2021 Special Obligation Refunding Bonds.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18512))
- Councilwoman Wisler moved to adopt the resolution approving the Bond Order for the 2021 Special Obligation Refunding Bonds.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Roney and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18513))
- Councilwoman Mosley moved to adopt a resolution to direct the City Manager to move forward with the demolition and removal of the Vance Monument as recommended by the Vance Monument Task Force, to authorize the City Manager to execute a contract with Chonzie, Inc. in the amount of $114,150, for the demolition and removal project as well as to execute any change orders that may arise during the project up to the contingency amount of $11,415 (10%), and to authorize the City Manager to initiate the Pack Square Visioning Process as presented.  This motion was seconded by Vice-Mayor Smith. The motion made by Councilwoman Mosley and seconded by Vice-Mayor Smith carried on a 6-1 roll call vote with Councilwoman Kilgore voting "no." — Passed, 6-1 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18514))
- Councilwoman Mosley moved to adopt a budget amendment in the amount of $70,000 from General Fund unassigned fund balance for the cost of the comprehensive Community Vision Document.  This motion was seconded by Vice-Mayor Smith and carried on a 6-1 roll call vote, with Councilwoman Kilgore voting "no." — Passed, 6-1 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18515))
- Mayor Manheimer moved to (1) reappoint James Carter as a member of the Asheville School Board to serve a four-year term, term to expire on April 1, 2025, or until his successor has been appointed; and (2) appoint Jacquelyn Carr McHargue and Peyton O'Conner as members to the Asheville School Board to each serve a four-year term respectively, terms to begin on April 1, 2021, and expire on April 1, 2025, or until their successors have been appointed.  This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Turner and carried unanimously by roll call vote. — Passed ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/city-council-budget-work-session-march-23-2021#vote-18516))

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8xGka0_XXg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3224/segments

## Documents

- [minutes_2021-03-23_from_packet_27535.md](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5235/documents/30107/minutes-2021-03-23-from-packet-27535md)

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8xGka0_XXg)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
