# Asheville Area Riverfront Redevelopment Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Asheville Buncombe Riverfront Commission
**Date:** March 11, 2021 3:59 PM EST (2021-03-11T15:59:36-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5241/asheville-area-riverfront-redevelopment-commission-mar-11-2021
**Outcome:** The Riverfront Commission approved the January minutes and discussed the proposed merged Design Review Committee and Open Space Task Force.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The Asheville Buncombe Riverfront Commission held a virtual meeting on March 11, 2021, from 4:00 PM to 5:05 PM. The primary focus of the session was a detailed discussion regarding the proposed new Design Review Committee and the communication dynamics between the Riverfront Commission, City Staff, and City Council. The meeting also included an update on the Open Space Task Force.

**Key Decisions**
The only formal vote taken during the meeting was to approve the minutes from the January session. A motion was made and seconded, and a roll call vote resulted in all present members voting "Aye," thereby approving the minutes. No votes were taken on the design review changes or the open space task force recommendations, as these items were presented for discussion and information only. The meeting was subsequently adjourned at 5:05 PM.

**Discussion Highlights**
Commissioners expressed frustration regarding a perceived communication gap, noting that their recommendations were not always reflected in final City Council decisions or that the rationale behind those decisions was not communicated back to the advisory boards. One commissioner noted that some task force members feel their attendance is merely to "say that they had community input" rather than to influence outcomes. In response, a staff member acknowledged that current communication mechanisms may not be working as well as they should, stating, "I really want to hear from you where these things... misses are happening... You don't feel appreciated. And it's not transparent enough." She committed to having further conversations to identify specific "case studies" of where communication breaks down.

Councilwoman Sage Turner, identified as the new council liaison, stated, "I will be attending all the meetings and I will convey what I think the group wants to relay to council without any kind of personal filter." She clarified that while input is sent to council, the difference between being "heard" and having an issue "enacted" is distinct, as the full council makes the final decision.

Regarding the new design review process, a commissioner expressed that the proposals from staff seemed to ignore the commission's suggestions, leaving the group in a "lurch." Todd Oclicchini, Planning and Urban Design Director, respectfully disagreed that *no* changes were incorporated, explaining that staff presented to the commissions to solicit input and that four members from the Riverfront Commission will be designated to the new joint design review body. He stated, "We felt as staff, we really advocated for involvement from both the downtown riverfront commissions... and we agree we felt that was very important." Councilwoman Sage Turner added, "I actually agreed [with the commission's reluctance to let go of design review]... But what I was able to encourage and get other folks to support was that at least those members would be on these commissions... I hope that that is a helpful thing."

Shannon Tuck, Principal Planner, explained that the new committee will merge the Downtown and Riverfront design review subcommittees into one independent standing committee of nine members. She emphasized that while design expertise is required for the majority of seats, the structure allows for "equitable representation" and voices beyond just design professionals. She clarified that Level 1 and 2 projects (smaller/ministerial) typically end at the Planning Zoning Commission, while Level 3 projects (over 100,000 sq ft or over 50 residential units) and conditional zonings move through the full process, including the new Design Review Committee.

Todd Oclicchini stated that the Open Space Task Force was created because the city was receiving "differing priorities from different boards and commissions... that were butting against each other." He noted the goal is to look at revising open space standards "in a more holistic way" to remove barriers to infill housing while balancing environmental goals. Chair Darren Green reminded the body that the AARC's purpose is to "recommend to the city and county an overall policy for the continued development and sustainability of the regional riverfront."

**Follow-ups**
Staff informed members that applications for the new Design Review Committee are being accepted through March 19, with appointments to be made by City Council on April 27. A staff member indicated that the Open Space Task Force will likely recommend different open space requirements for strategic areas of higher density. Commissioner Parker Sloan stated he is working on a task force to review water quality and quantity issues (floodplain, sedimentation, coli) and said, "I'll hopefully have an update for you guys in April or May on that." He also noted that the county has released an RFP for a consultant for the comprehensive plan and will be appointing a 10–14 member task force to oversee it, asking for public feedback on this process. Councilwoman Sage Turner stated she would prepare a standing update for future meetings, noting she was previously unaware this was a regular agenda item.

**Impact**
This meeting highlighted ongoing tensions between advisory commissions and the final decision-making body, City Council, regarding how input is processed and communicated. The establishment of a merged Design Review Committee aims to streamline the review process for large projects while maintaining representation from the Riverfront Commission. The Open Space Task Force’s work is significant for residents as it seeks to resolve conflicting priorities between different city boards to better balance housing development with environmental protection.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMeGtLkKF-E
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3007/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMeGtLkKF-E)
