# Council Budget Work Session

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 9, 2021 1:03 PM EST (2021-03-09T13:03:21-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021

## Summary

The City Council recorded seven votes during the meeting, all of which passed. The Council unanimously (7-0) approved the Consent Agenda. Additionally, the Council unanimously (7-0) adopted motions to permanently close a portion of unopened right-of-way connecting east of Bellevue Road and west of Edgewood Road, and to permanently close an unopened right-of-way connecting to Biltmore Avenue, directly south of White Fawn Drive. The Council also unanimously (7-0) approved an ordinance for the voluntary annexation of 0.47 acres located off of Moorecrest Rd. and Oakhill Circle.

Two motions regarding the Asheville School Board passed with split votes. A motion to ask the local delegation to consider increasing the membership of the Asheville School Board to seven and to amend the selection process passed 5-2, with Council Members Esther Manheimer and Kim Roney voting no. A separate motion to ask the local delegation to amend the selection process to allow for all members of the Asheville School Board to be selected by the public passed 5-2, with Council Members Sheneika Smith and Antanette Mosley voting no. Finally, a motion to approve the initial zoning request to Residential Multi-family, High Density (RM-16) and Future Land Use map designation of Traditional Neighborhood passed 6-1, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no.

## Discussion Highlights

The primary focus of the meeting was a two-part Council Budget Work Session dedicated to the development of the upcoming fiscal year’s budget. Staff outlined the integration of equity and inclusion lenses into the budget process, guided by the Office of Equity and Inclusion, CAPE, and the Office of Data and Performance. The goal is to identify how services impact the most vulnerable community members and to adjust services to mitigate negative impacts. Training Consultant Paulina Mendez of the Office of Equity and Inclusion stated, "We focus on those that are most impacted, because when the walls of exclusion come tumbling down, everybody benefits."

Interim Chief Financial Officer Tony McDowell reported an improving financial outlook for Fiscal Year 2021 despite pandemic-related uncertainties. He noted that sales taxes are up 5.8% through the first five months and that the city avoided layoffs and service reductions by implementing a hiring freeze and keeping operating budgets flat. McDowell stated, "The take-away from this is that we have an improving outlook. But there is a lot of uncertainty remaining... We were able to avoid some of the more drastic measures that other local governments across the country had to take." The city projects adding approximately $2.8 million to the fund balance, ending the year slightly above the 15% internal policy target.

A significant portion of the discussion centered on employee compensation. Special Assistant to the City Manager Peggy Rose presented findings from a study by The Archer Company, which found that the city’s salary structure is below the market average, with midpoints at 91% of market. Rose noted that approximately 655 employees, or 50% of the workforce, earn below the recommended minimum salary, and that employee turnover reached 18% in 2020. Mayor Esther Manheimer emphasized the urgency of the issue, stating, "Compensation... is extremely important. And it is not just important every three or four years. It is important every year. And it is the reason that, unfortunately, other communities are able to compete relatively easily to attract our very, very talented employees away from us."

Council members debated the implementation of new pay ranges, with staff presenting a one-year full implementation option estimated at $7.8 million or a two-year phased implementation with a Year 1 cost of $4.9 million. Council Member Gwen Wisler encouraged staff to incorporate potential savings from reduced turnover into the budget calculations, stating, "I'm going to be a little disappointed if we just put the entire cost in there and assume that we have no savings whatsoever." Council Member Kim Roney highlighted the broader context, noting, "We have overlapping emergencies right now... And so I don't think this is going to be the time for business as usual."

## Follow-ups

Staff agreed to several specific follow-up actions to provide additional data to the Council. Staff will determine and report back on the current status of weekend and evening transit service on northbound routes. Regarding the revaluation year, staff will provide a breakdown of property tax revenue between residential and commercial properties and will request a breakdown of revaluation data by zoning and use from Buncombe County. Staff will also provide a breakdown of the 18% turnover rate, distinguishing between voluntary and involuntary separations, and will provide data on the average age of employees year-over-year.

Additionally, staff will benchmark parental leave policies and costs against Buncombe County and other surrounding employers to compare with the city’s proposed six-week paid parental leave. Staff committed to quantifying potential savings from reduced turnover, such as overtime and recruitment costs, to offset the cost of the new pay structure. Staff will also provide information on how other cities handle firefighter work hours and will bring back additional options or refined analyses to the Council, noting that one option from the Archer study had not been fully assessed.

## Impact

This meeting established the direction for the city’s upcoming budget, which will be presented as the Manager’s Proposed Budget on May 25, followed by a public hearing on June 8 and final adoption on June 22. The focus on equity integration and competitive compensation aims to address retention issues and ensure that city services effectively support vulnerable populations. The approval of zoning and annexation motions reflects ongoing development and land use decisions in the city.

## Votes

- Motion for the adoption of the Consent Agenda. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18530))
- Motion to permanently close a portion of unopened right-of-way connecting east of Bellevue Road and west of Edgewood Road. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18531))
- Motion to adopt a resolution permanently closing an unopened right-of-way connecting to Biltmore Avenue, directly south of White Fawn Drive. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18532))
- Motion to adopt the ordinance approving the voluntary annexation of 0.47 acres located off of Moorecrest Rd. and Oakhill Circle. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18533))
- Motion to approve the initial zoning request to Residential Multi-family, High Density (RM-16) and Future Land Use map designation of Traditional Neighborhood... — Passed, 6-1 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18534))
- Motion to ask our local delegation to consider increasing the membership of the Asheville School Board to seven, and to amend the selection process for membership to allow for four of the Asheville School Board’s members to be elected by residents of the Asheville City Schools District and three members appointed by the Asheville City Council, with the chair to be selected by the entire board. — Passed, 5-2 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18535))
- Motion to ask our local delegation to amend the selection process for membership on the Asheville School Board to allow for all members of the Asheville School Board to be elected by residents of the Asheville City Schools District. — Passed, 5-2 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/council-budget-work-session-mar-9-2021#vote-18536))

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6csCx-AFcY
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3011/segments

## Documents

- [minutes_2021-03-09_from_packet_27494.md](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5245/documents/30109/minutes-2021-03-09-from-packet-27494md)

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6csCx-AFcY)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
