# Planning & Economic Development Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee
**Date:** March 8, 2021 4:00 PM EST (2021-03-08T16:00:42-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5247/planning-economic-development-committee-mar-8-2021

## Summary

The Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee of the City of Asheville held a virtual meeting on March 8, 2021. The committee approved the minutes from the previous February meeting by a unanimous 3-0 vote. Regarding the proposed revisions to the homestay ordinance, the committee did not approve the full package of changes presented by staff. Instead, Councilwoman Sage Turner moved, and Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore seconded, to forward a limited version of the ordinance to City Council. This limited version includes only three specific changes: minor revisions for compliance with state law, a prohibition on using detached accessory structures as homestays (with grandfathering for existing ones), and a clarification that non-bathroom sinks are not permitted in homestays. The motion passed unanimously with a 3-0 vote.

## Discussion Highlights

Staff presented a draft zoning text amendment for homestays that included three main proposed changes: revising the definition of a "kitchen" to allow full-size appliances, allowing non-resident property owners to participate in management, and prohibiting detached structures from being used as homestays. The committee focused heavily on the kitchen definition change. Councilwoman Sage Turner expressed significant concern that allowing full kitchens could convert affordable, long-term rental units, such as basement apartments, into short-term tourist rentals, stating, "I am very worried about freeing up and creating more flexibility that could impact long-term rentals becoming short-term rentals." She emphasized that the city is in a housing crisis and that she was more concerned about the impact on renters than the experience of homestay operators.

Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore agreed with Turner, noting that the current situation seemed to be a regulation problem that needed to be controlled before moving forward with changes, stating, "if you can't count it and measure it, then you really have no control over it." In response, Shannon Tuck, Principal Planner, explained the rationale for the kitchen change, citing increased interest in flexibility during the pandemic and enforcement challenges where owners would remove stoves to obtain permits and then replace them. Chair Gwen Whistler clarified the committee’s position on detached structures, stating that prohibiting their use as homestays was a significant change she wanted to see implemented, even if the other proposed changes were not adopted.

## Follow-ups

In response to Councilwoman Turner’s request for data on the potential impact on housing stock, Chris Collins, Site Planning Division Manager, agreed to attempt to generate a report or "ballpark" estimate of the potential housing stock affected by the kitchen definition change. Collins noted that the data would be "a little fuzzy" because many basement spaces are not formally documented as separate units, but staff would try to come up with a sense of the numbers. Additionally, Shannon Tuck stated that the committee would "come back maybe with some more analysis and thought" regarding the proposal to allow owner participation and management, as the committee was not ready to move that specific part forward.

## Impact

This decision limits the scope of the homestay ordinance changes sent to City Council, excluding the controversial expansion of kitchen definitions and the allowance for non-resident owner management. By restricting the forwarded ordinance to compliance updates, the prohibition of detached structures, and the clarification on sinks, the committee addresses specific enforcement loopholes and structural concerns while deferring the broader changes that raised housing availability concerns. The pending analysis on housing stock impact and further review of owner participation rules will inform future discussions on these deferred elements.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlPoGU7N2kk
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3321/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlPoGU7N2kk)
