# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** February 26, 2021 2:29 PM EST (2021-02-26T14:29:35-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5251/downtown-commission-feb-26-2021

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
On February 26, 2021, the City of Asheville Downtown Commission held a special work session to finalize recommendations and priorities for their report to City Council. The primary objective of the session was to narrow down a list of potential recommendations using a point-based ranking system, focusing on the most critical issues for the current year.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission voted to adopt three specific recommendations for their final report to City Council. A motion was made and seconded to adopt these items, and the motion passed unanimously with 7 ayes and 0 nays. The three adopted recommendations are:
1.  **Fund Downtown Master Plan Updates:** Specifically regarding public space management and updates to design guidelines for both the downtown and riverfront areas. The Commission committed to involvement in outreach and oversight, with a requirement that updated design guidelines include socially and physically disadvantaged community members.
2.  **Support Policies for Local Independent Businesses:** This includes maintaining storefronts for local small businesses, incentivizing property owners to choose local tenants, and strengthening policies that encourage ground-floor uses. The Commission also added a provision to ensure appropriate levels of city services for downtown management, such as sanitation.
3.  **Address Justice for Families Who Lost Land Due to Urban Renewal:** The Commission recommended that City Council address this issue, using the specific phrase "justice for families who lost their land due to urban renewal."

**Discussion Highlights**
During the session, the group debated the scope of the Downtown Master Plan, with staff noting that the Master Plan and Design Guidelines are distinct documents. The Commission decided to focus the recommendation specifically on public space management and design guidelines, acknowledging that a full Master Plan update is a larger, multi-year effort. Chair Brian Moffitt stated, "My goal in this was to use a little bit of deductive analysis and more or less eliminate things that we didn't think were as important to submit to council this year and then narrow in on the ones that we thought were most important."

Significant debate occurred regarding the language used for the urban renewal recommendation, with members discussing terms such as "justice," "restitution," or "land equity." Commissioner Hunter expressed a strong preference for concrete action over further research, stating, "I am not in agreement with more studies... I wanna remove studying black people out of everything, because that's how we continue to be studied and people keep taking while they're studying us like we're like animals or something." Regarding business support, Councilmember Sage Turner noted, "One of the things that we know is that property owners really hold the key... I do think that there could be a key in working with them and creating some kind of incentives." Staff member Todd Olick clarified the distinction between guidelines and code, noting, "Guidelines are mandatory review, voluntary compliance, code is code. So, when you say you want something in the guidelines I don't think that I think what you're saying is you want something to be required is what I'm hearing so just to be super clear about that guidelines don't get you what you want necessarily."

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, offered to provide an update or report on the city’s efforts regarding urban renewal mapping and its tie-in to the reparations effort. Commissioner Johnson suggested requesting this staff update at a future meeting, potentially the March 12th meeting, to help the Commission craft a more specific direction for City Council. Additionally, staff confirmed they will return to the Downtown Commission on March 12 to provide a more in-depth presentation on the new design review process. Staff member Todd Olick informed the Commission that applications for the new Joint Design Review Committee are due by March 19, with the Boards and Commissions Committee expected to review applications tentatively on April 13, and City Council expected to make appointments on April 27.

**Impact**
These decisions establish the Downtown Commission's formal priorities for the upcoming year, directing City Council's attention toward equitable design standards, local economic resilience, and historical redress. By narrowing the focus to public space management and design guidelines rather than a full master plan update, the Commission aims to address immediate needs while acknowledging the long-term nature of broader planning efforts. The emphasis on incentivizing local businesses and ensuring ground-floor activation responds to the economic challenges faced by independent retailers, particularly in the context of the pandemic. Furthermore, the recommendation for justice regarding urban renewal signals a commitment to addressing historical land dispossession, a topic that generated significant discussion regarding the balance between further study and concrete policy action.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8prQzGdkXOQ
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3324/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8prQzGdkXOQ)
