# Downtown Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** February 12, 2021 9:30 AM EST (2021-02-12T09:30:12-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5257/downtown-commission-feb-12-2021
**Outcome:** The Downtown Commission endorsed a Housing First resolution 7-1-3, tabled the 2020 Annual Report for a special meeting, and elected new leadership.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met virtually on February 12, 2021. The agenda addressed the Vance Monument Task Force report, updates to the noise ordinance, the 2020 Annual Report, a Housing First resolution, leadership elections, and various city and business updates related to design reviews, stormwater management, and pandemic support initiatives.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The commission approved the November minutes as amended by a unanimous vote of 11-0. Regarding the 2020 Annual Report, the body voted unanimously (11-0) to table the discussion of its priorities and direct staff to schedule a special meeting in late February or early March to finalize the document. The commission also voted unanimously (11-0) to transition the Parking and Transportation subcommittee and the Local Living Economy group into informal working groups.

In leadership elections, Brian Moffitt was elected Chair with 6 votes, defeating Andrew Fletcher, who received 4 votes. Ruth Summers was elected Vice Chair with 6 votes, defeating Kimberly Hunter, who received 4 votes. The commission voted on a resolution endorsing “Housing First” as the most effective strategy to end homelessness; the motion passed 7-1-3, with one member abstaining due to a personal conflict of interest regarding eminent domain issues.

**Discussion Highlights**
Bernard Oliphant reported that the Vance Monument Task Force recommended removing the monument and converting the area into green space, noting that City Council is currently reviewing costs and legal aspects. Ben Woody, Development Services Director, provided an update on the noise ordinance, stating that staff recommended delaying the effective date of new standards until after the pandemic to acknowledge financial strain on the entertainment industry. Woody outlined a plan to shift noise enforcement from the Asheville Police Department to the Development Services Department and to work with venue owners to build consensus on amplified sound standards.

Commissioner Robin Raines presented the Housing First resolution, which recommends prioritizing available funding for permanent supportive housing. Commissioner Kimberly Hunter expressed concern that the draft 2020 Annual Report felt “out of touch” with current community realities, particularly regarding Black residents and the pandemic, and requested a retreat to properly discuss these priorities. Staff also raised concerns that the current “view corridors” section in the Unified Development Ordinance is outdated due to new construction obscuring historic views, suggesting the commission consider updating these guidelines.

**Community Input**
A public commenter expressed appreciation that the Guastavino urban trail art piece was reinstalled after being stored in a warehouse. In response, the chair commented that the team did a great job and expressed personal satisfaction with the improvements. Another public commenter shared information about the Asheville Mardi Gras organization’s pivot to a “drive-by house parade” for February 14, noting that $6,500 was raised to donate $100 Ingalls gift cards to people in need. The chair thanked the commenter for the information.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to schedule a special meeting for the Downtown Commission in late February or early March, specifically looking at February 26 or March 5, to finalize the 2020 Annual Report priorities. Ben Woody agreed to continue working with venue owners, musicians, and residents to build consensus on amplified sound standards and to begin implementing non-APD noise enforcement measures. The Asheville Downtown Association representative agreed to send the link to the business impact survey and registration links for the February 23 “State of Downtown” virtual update to commission members. The Local Business Leaders Working Group representative agreed to share the link for the “828 Go Local Challenge” via chat and email.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions impact residents by shaping the future of downtown public spaces, such as the potential conversion of the Vance Monument site into green space and the implementation of a green roof on a new fully impervious site. The shift in noise enforcement aims to reduce the burden on the police department while addressing chronic noise issues in residential areas, which staff noted often correlate with higher minority populations. Additionally, the commission’s engagement with the Asheville Downtown Association and the Local Business Leaders Working Group highlights ongoing efforts to support local businesses experiencing revenue decreases of 25% or more during the pandemic.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEAe1W4Vb8c
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3332/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEAe1W4Vb8c)
