# Boards & Commissions

**Body:** City of Asheville — Boards and Commissions Committee
**Date:** February 9, 2021 10:00 AM EST (2021-02-09T10:00:10-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5258/boards-commissions-feb-9-2021

## Summary

The Boards and Commissions Committee, chaired by Vice Mayor Shanika Smith, met on February 9, 2021, to address board appointments and procedural updates. The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding the School Board appointment process, the committee voted 2-1 to require three currently eligible members and five additional applicants to complete essay questions and interviews. The committee voted to recommend five specific applicants—Michelle Delange, Peyton O'Connor, Steven Blunt, George Seberg, and Jacqueline McCard—to the full Council for this process.

The committee also made several unanimous appointments to other boards and commissions. Susan Darnell was appointed to the Audit Committee, and Christopher Fundenish was appointed to an alternate seat on the Board of Adjustments, with staff directed to re-advertise for the second seat. Krissa Sienkiewicz was appointed to the Civic Center, Tony McDowell (Interim CFO) was appointed to the Fireman’s Relief Fund, and Ben Williamson was appointed to the Riverfront Development Commission.

## Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting focused on the School Board appointment process, where staff presented a pool of 16 applicants. Vice Mayor Shanika Smith noted that bringing together the board of education process and historical data was a "heavy lift" and thanked staff for providing the information on time. The committee also discussed how to handle applications from residents outside city limits. Councilwoman Antoinette Mosley stated she would approach this on a case-by-case basis, noting that from an equity lens, someone who lives outside the city but works in the city could qualify.

Staff reported on efforts to diversify the applicant pool, including targeted outreach and updates to the application form to include demographic data and accessibility features. Councilwoman Kim Roney emphasized the importance of accessibility, stating that she has served with members who have limited resources or no vision, and that documents must be accessible regardless of whether an applicant can see. Staff also provided an update on the Affordable Housing Advisory Commission’s motion to expand its board by two seats and confirmed the availability of free transit passes for committee members.

## Community Input

During the first public comment session, a former Asheville City Schools elementary teacher and parent expressed concern about the lack of protocols to ensure appointed board members provide a quality education. They highlighted worsening inequities in the system and asked how the City assesses current board performance and selects new members during a pandemic, specifically naming two applicants who they felt understood these issues. Members did not respond directly to these specific questions.

In the second public comment session, a resident from East West Asheville thanked the City for making the application process more accessible. They urged the committee to ensure agendas are published consistently, allow live call-in comments, and maintain virtual participation tools such as live streaming even after returning to in-person meetings. Members did not respond directly to these specific requests.

## Follow-ups

Staff member Jerry Goldberg agreed to add JM Pro and Co-Think to his list of outreach targets for vacancy flyers and to reach out to the Center for Participatory Change for translation and interpretation services. Goldberg also stated that the revised application form, which includes more demographic data and language preferences, is expected to be presented to the HRCA in a draft form on the March agenda. Additionally, Goldberg noted that the Affordable Housing Advisory Commission hopes to present a draft resolution to expand its board by two seats on next month’s Board and Commission’s Council Committee agenda. Based on committee feedback, staff will keep applications from non-city residents in the packet but highlight their residency status so the committee can discuss them on a case-by-case basis.

## Impact

These decisions directly shape the composition of the City’s advisory boards and the School Board, which influence local policy, zoning, and education oversight. The approval of the School Board candidates for essays and interviews moves the process forward for the full Council, while the appointments to the Audit, Adjustments, Civic Center, Fireman’s Relief, and Riverfront Development boards fill current vacancies. The committee’s focus on accessibility and diversity in the application process aims to broaden participation in civic governance, ensuring that a wider range of community voices is represented on these boards.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wQiIm5WgqGQ
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3325/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wQiIm5WgqGQ)
