# City Council Work Session

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** January 26, 2021 2:56 PM EST (2021-01-26T14:56:16-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5267/city-council-work-session-jan-26-2021
**Outcome:** Council discussed the affordable housing market and its 2021 work plan, noting that no votes were taken.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held an informational work session on January 26, 2021, to discuss the complexities of the local affordable housing market, the city’s current policy tools, and its strategic plan for 2021. As is standard for work sessions, no votes were taken, no formal actions were approved, and no public comments were accepted. The session served primarily to share data and outline upcoming projects for Council consideration.

**Key Discussions and Market Context**
Staff presented data highlighting a significant mismatch between local wages and housing costs. For homeownership, only 38 of approximately 275 recent listings were priced under $275,000, while the average for-sale price was approximately $660,000. In the rental market, vacancy for affordable units is near zero (0–0.2%), and rents have increased by approximately 5.2% annually since 2014. Staff noted that the average renter salary is approximately $28,000, while the average rent is approximately $1,200 per month, leaving nearly half of renters cost-burdened. City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized that the city cannot solve the crisis alone, stating, "Affordable housing and the delivery of this product is hard and it is complicated... It takes a village... We can't [do it alone]. We don't have the resources. And we have to partner."

**Legal Constraints and Policy Tools**
Legal Counsel Brad Bram clarified that North Carolina is a "Dillon’s Rule" state, meaning the city lacks the legal authority to mandate inclusionary zoning (requiring affordable units in all developments) without a subsidy or incentive. However, Bram noted that the city has more flexibility to impose such obligations as a condition of receiving specific incentives, such as the Land Use Incentive Grant. The city’s current toolkit includes the "20/80/20" policy, which requires 20% of units to be affordable at or below 80% of the Area Median Income (AMI) for 20 years, with a preference for 60% AMI. Council Member Sage Turner discussed the concept of "Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing," noting that even residents who can afford $300,000 homes are being outbid by cash offers. Council Member Kim Roney suggested exploring ways to connect hotel moratorium rules to housing costs to prevent developers from simply buying their way out of housing obligations.

**2021 Work Plan and Project Pipeline**
Staff reported that in 2020, the city leveraged approximately $13 million in investment to support the creation of approximately 373 affordable units. For 2021, the work plan aims for approximately 500 units with a city investment of approximately $23 million. Key projects in the pipeline include:
*   **319 Biltmore:** 250 mixed-income units and commercial space in partnership with Homes Urban, requiring a city land contribution.
*   **Deeperview Purpose-Built Community:** A 60-acre master plan partnership with the Housing Authority aiming for 300 units, including childcare, a school, and a community center.
*   **Talbert Lot:** A land banking strategy to expand the downtown transit center and add affordable housing, with a 50-50 funding partnership with Dogwood Health Trust.
*   **Ashland Avenue:** 42 permanently affordable units on city land, proposed by Haywood Street Community Development.
*   **Neighborhood Lots:** Three city-owned lots in West Asheville and Montfort to be developed by Habitat for Humanity and the Asheville Buncombe Community Land Trust for homeownership.
*   **Homeward Bound:** 85 units of permanent supportive housing for chronically homeless individuals at the old Days Inn on Tunnel Road.

Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed strong interest in the purpose-built community model, stating, "I am very interested in continuing to explore that [purpose-built community] model. And I'm interested in Deaverview being redeveloped with that idea in mind."

**Follow-Ups and Next Steps**
While no decisions were made, staff and members outlined specific next steps for the coming months. Staff indicated they will bring the Ashland Avenue proposal to Council for a vote on February 23, 2021. The 319 Biltmore proposal is scheduled for Council consideration in the spring of 2021, and the Neighborhood Lots for Affordable Housing program will be brought to committees and council in the April–May timeframe. Additionally, Community Development Program Director Paul D’Angelo agreed to follow up with Homeward Bound regarding the cost-sharing model for housing the homeless, specifically exploring how other entities, such as hospitals, might share in the savings generated by housing individuals who are currently homeless. Staff also indicated they will present the mapping of urban renewal properties, including the River District and South Charlotte Street, internally and then to the community.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiZkom0E1j0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3017/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiZkom0E1j0)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
