# Board of Adjustment

**Body:** City of Asheville — Board of Adjustment
**Date:** January 25, 2021 1:59 PM EST (2021-01-25T13:59:30-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5268/board-of-adjustment-jan-25-2021
**Outcome:** The Board of Adjustment denied both zoning variance requests and elected Prateek Bhakta as Chair and Paul Wilczynski as Vice Chair.

## Summary

On January 25, 2021, the City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened to address two zoning variance requests and elect new board officers. The agenda included a request to reduce the minimum lot area for a property on Wilson Street and a request to reduce setbacks for two lots on South Charlotte Street. Additionally, the board voted to adopt the minutes from its September 2020 meeting and to appoint a new Chair and Vice Chair following the expiration of the previous Chair’s term.

## Key Decisions
The board took four formal votes during the meeting. First, a motion to adopt the minutes from the September 2020 meeting passed with a vote of 4-1-1, with three members voting yes, one voting no, and one abstaining. Second, the board voted on the lot area variance for 604 Wilson Street; the motion failed with a split vote of 2-2-2, resulting in the denial of the request. Third, the board voted on the setback variance for Lots 20 and 21 on South Charlotte Street; this motion also failed, with a vote of 2-3-1, leading to the denial of the request. Finally, the board elected Prateek Bhakta as Chair with a vote of 4-0-1 and Paul Wilczynski as Vice Chair with a vote of 3-0-2.

## Discussion Highlights
Regarding the 604 Wilson Street lot area variance, Assistant City Attorney Eric Edgerton clarified the legal standard, noting that "Financial hardship alone is typically not sufficient, but if it’s coupled with some other sort of physical hardship, then you can get there." Petitioner Barry Bialik argued that the primary hardship was the loss of the opportunity to provide affordable or workforce housing. Board Member Paul Wilczynski expressed difficulty with the request, stating, "I’m still struggling with it."

For the South Charlotte Street setback variance, petitioner Chris Harp argued that the lots were reduced by eminent domain for road widening, creating a hardship, and stated, "I think we can still maintain that spirit, the original intent of the zoning without strictly adhering to the zoning rules and regulations here." Board Member Suzanne Vernon Godsey indicated she would have supported a variance for Lot 21 due to its specific hardships, while Board Member Bill Newman opposed the request for Lot 21, stating, "The small lot right there, to me it was too tight for your lot, what you’re trying to put there... I did not like that one [Lot 21]."

## Community Input
Public comments were recorded only for the 604 Wilson Street item. One resident of the neighboring properties on Reed Street argued that the sewer connection could be made without subdividing the lot and that no hardship existed because an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) could still be built. Another resident of 608 Wilson Street raised concerns about parking on the narrow, one-way street and cited visible water damage on Reed Street caused by a damaged sewer line, arguing the neighborhood infrastructure could not support an additional dwelling. In response, one board member stated, "I’m just having an issue trying to wrap my head around that no reasonable use to be made of the property when you can build an adu on it instead of a residential single-family residential structure... I don’t feel like you’re addressing a specific hardship." Another member noted, "It sure would be nice if the flexible development standard could have been applied to this considering it is so incredibly small." No public comments were recorded for the South Charlotte Street item.

## Follow-ups
Staff informed the petitioner for the 604 Wilson Street variance that if a variance is denied, they must wait one year to resubmit unless there is a substantial change in the application. For the South Charlotte Street variance, staff suggested the applicant contact them to evaluate "flexible development standards" or alternative footprint designs, particularly for Lot 20. Additionally, a board member suggested the applicant consider recombining the land to give Lot 21 more frontage area.

## Impact
The denials of both variance requests mean that the property owners cannot proceed with the proposed subdivisions or construction plans as submitted. The 604 Wilson Street owners are now restricted from subdividing the parcel under the current application and face a one-year waiting period before resubmitting. The South Charlotte Street applicants must seek alternative designs or flexible development standards to address the setbacks created by the previous road widening. The election of Prateek Bhakta as Chair and Paul Wilczynski as Vice Chair establishes the new leadership structure for the board.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icGVq1T_bJ4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3279/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icGVq1T_bJ4)
