# Riverfront Redevelopment Commission

**Body:** City of Asheville — Asheville Buncombe Riverfront Commission
**Date:** January 14, 2021 4:00 PM EST (2021-01-14T16:00:54-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5272/riverfront-redevelopment-commission-jan-14-2021
**Outcome:** The Planning and Design Review Committee recommended the applicant revise the auto body shop plan and sent written comments on the Grant Center expansion to staff.

## Summary

On January 14, 2021, the Asheville Buncombe Riverfront Commission’s Planning and Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting to review two development proposals: a new auto body repair shop at 17 Trucker’s Place and an expansion of the Grant Center. The committee did not take formal votes on either item. Instead, the group focused on design revisions, regulatory compliance, and providing written feedback to staff before the items proceed to the full Commission.

## Key Decisions
The committee did not approve or deny either application as submitted. For the 17 Trucker’s Place project, the committee recommended that the applicant return with a revised plan, specifically suggesting that the building be rotated 90 degrees to improve pedestrian views and reduce the visual impact of retaining walls, provided that traffic access constraints allow for such a change. For the Grant Center expansion, the committee agreed to send individual written comments to staff regarding stormwater management and egress requirements before the item is forwarded to the full Commission. Staff clarified that while the committee is not required by ordinance to vote before sending an item to the full Commission, a vote or recommendation strengthens the application.

## Discussion Highlights
The discussion for 17 Trucker’s Place centered on the building’s orientation, the height of flood zone retaining walls, signage, and stormwater management. Megan Viren of Cross Development, the applicant’s representative, stated that she would prefer to rotate the building or return to the drawing board rather than attempt to "dress up" the facade or retaining wall. Todd Burnett, the civil engineer, noted that regardless of the layout, the building would be 10 to 12 feet above the road due to building code and flood elevation requirements. Committee Chair Jane Matthews indicated that if no new information or comments were proposed, the committee could vote based on the existing information. Jeremy Goldstein, a committee member, raised questions about whether the design guidelines were attempting to make different sections of the riverfront feel uniform.

For the Grant Center expansion, the primary concerns involved the removal of a bioswale for stormwater management and the screening of the new swimming pool. Kate, a committee member and landscape architect, expressed concern about the removal of stormwater management for the first phase of the project, stating she did not know how it was being handled. Lindsay Roden, another committee member, stated that while she was not opposed to the applicant's first plan, the current plan would be preferable if it worked, emphasizing the need to ensure access requirements were met.

## Follow-ups
The applicant for 17 Trucker’s Place agreed to investigate rotating the building 90 degrees, confirm with transportation staff if the rotated layout meets access spacing requirements, and provide a 3D rendering or section showing the pedestrian view from Swannanoa River Road. Committee members agreed to send individual written comments to staff regarding the Grant Center expansion, with one member specifically agreeing to send comments on plant species via email. Staff agreed to coordinate with the applicant regarding future meeting dates and to relay the committee’s feedback.

## Impact
These reviews are significant for residents as they address the physical development of the riverfront, specifically the visual impact of new construction near the Swannanoa River and the management of stormwater in the Grant Center area. The committee’s focus on rotating the auto body shop aims to mitigate the visual barrier of retaining walls for pedestrians, while the scrutiny of the Grant Center’s stormwater changes addresses environmental management for the expanded facility.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJrHQhYTb6I
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3282/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJrHQhYTb6I)
