# Affordable Housing Advisory Committee

**Body:** City of Asheville — Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
**Date:** January 7, 2021 9:30 AM EST (2021-01-07T09:30:14-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5277/affordable-housing-advisory-committee-jan-7-2021
**Outcome:** The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee agreed to review the Down Payment Assistance policy at a special meeting before it proceeds to the Housing and Community Development committee.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) held a virtual meeting on January 7, 2021. The agenda focused on updates regarding community development projects, a significant review of the Down Payment Assistance (DPA) policy, and the introduction of a new work plan to address housing barriers.

## Key Decisions
The committee voted to accept the minutes from the previous month, with a motion made by Brian Methvin and seconded by Margie Bukowski. Regarding the Down Payment Assistance policy, which was scheduled for the Housing and Community Development (HCD) committee on January 19, the committee did not vote to postpone the item. Instead, they agreed to a compromise where staff would share the draft staff report and proposed policy changes with the committee in advance. To facilitate this review, the committee tentatively agreed to hold a special AHAC meeting on Wednesday, January 13, from 9:00 AM to 10:00 AM. The meeting was subsequently adjourned without objection.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff provided updates on several housing initiatives, including scattered site development, the Sinear Group’s homeownership projects, and the Al Clement development in Oakley. A major portion of the discussion centered on the DPA program, where staff outlined proposed changes such as a potential increase in the subsidy cap and a shift from a forgivable loan to a loan payable upon sale. Staff noted that a third party requested the loan be made non-forgivable to keep funding moving.

Chair Barry Bialik presented data highlighting a severe lack of affordable housing inventory, stating that there were only 17 single-family homes under $275,000 in the entire city of Asheville. He described this statistic as "scary." Additionally, local infill developer Ben Wright presented a case study on his 330 Barnard project, discussing zoning barriers for duplexes in cottage developments and the challenges of converting market-rate properties to affordable units. Wright expressed that creating six vertical duplexes would save green space and decrease costs while providing voucher-accepted housing.

The committee also discussed the Ashland Avenue project on city-owned land. Brian Methvin, representing Haywood Street Church, and Nikki Reed, City Staff, provided updates on neighborhood engagement and the upcoming City Council vote. Reed clarified that while the HCD committee endorsed the land sale in November, it still requires full council approval, scheduled for February 23. Finally, the Chair introduced a draft work plan focusing on three areas—Land, Build, and Connect—proposing the creation of subcommittees to address barriers in each area. Member Andy Barnett commented that while the plan effectively breaks down supply-side solutions, he wanted to ensure the committee did not become locked into a production mindset and neglect demand-side solutions.

## Community Input
Three written public comments were received, all concerning the proposed Haywood Street Church development on Ashland Avenue. One commenter objected to the proposal, arguing that the land was acquired through urban renewal in the 1960s after forcibly removing families, and requested that the city not move forward with the project and include the land in reparations resolution discussions. Another anonymous commenter asked what criteria are used to define "affordable housing" in Asheville and how quality and location are measured. Two additional commenters objected to the proposed project and requested an open discussion with Southside neighbors.

In response to questions about the project's status, Nikki Reed explained that the site did come through urban renewal, but Haywood Street’s desire to build affordable housing in the area predated the city's decision to postpone the sale of other urban renewal properties, which is why this site was exempted. She confirmed that the city is working on a map of properties acquired through urban renewal.

## Follow-Ups
Staff member Paul D’Angelo agreed to share the draft DPA staff report and proposed policy changes with the committee by 5:00 PM on Wednesday, January 13. He also agreed to hold a meeting with 211/United Way to explore a dedicated affordable housing hotline and report back the following month, as well as to follow up with Chris Collins regarding the public availability of pre-Technical Review Committee meeting documents for the Ben Wright project. D’Angelo will also present updated Community Development updates at the February 4 AHAC meeting. Nikki Reed agreed to ensure the city’s project page and FAQ for the Ashland Avenue development are published and shared via the listserv. Brian Methvin agreed to continue neighborhood engagement and send out a packet of information to those who have expressed interest or concern. Chair Barry Bialik agreed to request a slot for AHAC to provide input at the January 19 HCD meeting and to check with legal staff to confirm the feasibility of the January 13 emergency meeting. Member Andy Barnett agreed to provide written comments on the DPA policy changes if he cannot attend the January 13 meeting.

## Impact
This meeting established a clear timeline for the review of the Down Payment Assistance policy, ensuring that committee members have access to draft materials before the item proceeds to the HCD committee. The discussion highlighted the critical shortage of affordable housing inventory in Asheville and the specific zoning and financial barriers developers face when creating affordable units. Furthermore, the introduction of the "Land, Build, and Connect" work plan signals the committee's intent to organize its efforts into specialized subcommittees to systematically address the multifaceted challenges of the local housing crisis.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8uwt4GocseI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3344/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8uwt4GocseI)
