# City Council Budget Briefing – April 14, 2020

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 14, 2020 11:00 AM EDT (2020-04-14T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5279/city-council-budget-briefing-april-14-2020
**Outcome:** Council discussed the pandemic's impact on city finances and proposed delaying the budget adoption timeline to May and June.

## Summary

On April 14, 2020, the Asheville City Council held a work session to address the financial impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the city’s current and next fiscal year budgets. Due to technical difficulties with phone attendance, several council members participated via live stream. The session focused on analyzing revenue shortfalls, adjusting spending priorities, and planning for the upcoming fiscal year in an environment of significant economic uncertainty.

**Key Decisions and Schedule Adjustments**
No formal votes were taken during this work session. However, staff proposed delaying the budget adoption timeline to allow for more data as the economic situation evolves. Under the proposed schedule, the Manager’s Proposed Budget Presentation would move to May 26, 2020, the public hearing would occur one meeting later than originally planned, and the final budget adoption would take place at the last meeting in June, adhering to the statutory deadline. This schedule change is set to come to the Council for formal action on the May 12 agenda. Additionally, staff decided not to recommend any fee increases for the General Fund or other funds at this time, a decision that results in an approximate $300,000 reduction in revenue estimates. Staff also discussed the possibility of adopting a two-month interim budget as a contingency if uncertainty persists, noting that this was done in 2003, but advised against being the only local government to do so due to potential negative impacts on credit ratings.

**Current Year (FY2020) Financial Impacts**
The City expects a significant decline in General Fund revenues, estimated between $2.5 million and $4 million. The most significant concern is sales tax, with estimates ranging from a 20% decline to a 35% decline for the final quarter, potentially resulting in a loss of $1.4 million to $2.5 million for that period. Property tax is expected to remain on budget, though a slight drop in collection rates could impact revenue by up to $400,000. Other expected declines include state utility taxes, investment earnings, development services, and nature center/recreation fees. Consequently, General Fund expenses are expected to exceed revenues by $2.8 million to $5.5 million, drawing down the fund balance. The Parking Fund faces a major concern as free parking initiatives through June 30 will cost approximately $1.5 million, potentially reducing the fund balance by that amount from an available $2.2 million. The Civic Center Fund is expected to dip slightly into its balance by approximately $100,000, while the Transit Fund is expected to remain over budget, with federal CARES Act funds anticipated to cover the shortfall for fare-free service, which costs approximately $200,000.

**Next Year (FY2021) Planning and Strategic Investments**
For the next fiscal year, baseline revenue growth has dropped from $6.8 million, as estimated in March, to approximately $2 million, with the largest reduction in sales tax estimates amounting to a $2.8 million drop. To help balance the budget, staff reduced projected expenditure growth from $6.8 million to $3.4 million. These cuts include removing the planned 2.5% general pay raise, freezing OPEB and CIP debt contributions, flattening operating budgets, and partially funding RAD trail maintenance. There is currently a $1.5 million gap in the General Fund, and staff are exploring options, including using fund balance, to close it. Regarding strategic investments, no money is currently budgeted for extended transit hours; staff plan to use federal CARES Act funds (approximately $3.8 million) first to offset COVID-related expenses. The $31,200 pay adjustment will proceed, with an annual impact of approximately $450,000 across all funds, but other compensation study recommendations remain unfunded. Limited funding is available for the Green Savings Program, and major capital items like roof replacements are not funded.

**Discussion Highlights**
City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized the uncertainty of the budget, stating, "We are operating in the gray... Some of the numbers just aren't here yet for us to be able to make some very definitive decisions." She affirmed that employee retention is a priority, noting, "Our employees are the most important and valuable resource that we have. The issue of furloughing and layoffs and right-sizing and downsizing for me personally, unless you all direct me otherwise, will be the last resort." Director of Finance Tony McDowell highlighted the unpredictability of sales tax, stating, "What we're going through right now is unprecedented in its nature. So it's challenging to come up with estimates." He confirmed that the general fund balance will decline because expenses are expected to exceed revenues by $2.8 million to $5.5 million. Council Member Julie Mayfield advocated for using CARES Act funds for extended transit hours, stating, "I would advocate for putting that money toward that service... This is a place where we need to do a little jumping off." Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed caution regarding new spending, stating, "I would want to be, before we start spending new money, I want to know if we're going to see a little bit of a normalization on the horizon. I mean, I don't want to be sitting here with a $20 million deficit in the next fiscal year." Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler expressed concern about the economic outlook, stating, "I am very nervous about that [relying on sales tax growth]... We are highly tourist dependent. This will be one of the last things people will put back on to their personal spending." Council Member Vijay Kapoor suggested using the crisis as an opportunity to invest in capital projects, stating, "This is the right time to do it [bonding for capital projects] because what's happening is out in the marketplace a lot of those folks are competing and we may be able to get a lot more done over this time period."

**Follow-ups**
Director of Finance Tony McDowell agreed to reach out to other large municipalities to compare sales tax decline assumptions, check with HR for the most recent healthcare cost data, contact the Alcohol Beverage Control Board for final quarter revenue estimates, revise presentation slides to clarify that current estimates are "worst-case" scenarios, and continue monitoring economic trends and federal/state assistance. City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to provide specific details on which transit routes were scaled back and committed to prioritizing federal CARES Act funds to offset COVID-related expenses before considering service enhancements. Council Member Julie Mayfield suggested exploring partnerships with Uber/Lyft for "first and last mile" transit connections. Council Member Vijay Kapoor asked staff to consider using non-essential employees for training or backlog work while they are on paid leave.

**Impact on Residents**
This briefing provides critical insight into how the pandemic is reshaping the city's financial landscape. Residents should be aware that the city is facing significant revenue shortfalls, particularly in sales tax, which may lead to a drawdown of fund balances in the General, Parking, and Civic Center funds. The decision to delay the budget adoption timeline allows the Council to incorporate more accurate data as the economic situation evolves, rather than locking in a budget based on initial, potentially inaccurate estimates. The commitment to avoid fee increases and prioritize employee retention reflects the city's intent to maintain essential services and workforce stability during the crisis, even as it navigates a projected budget gap for the next fiscal year.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wT-yaNfGUg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3020/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wT-yaNfGUg)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
