# City Council Meeting – October 22, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** October 22, 2019 11:00 AM EDT (2019-10-22T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5283/city-council-meeting-october-22-2019
**Outcome:** Council adopted charter amendments restoring at-large elections and approved the Julian Woods Retirement Community rezoning, while continuing the 1 South Tunnel Road hearing.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on October 22, 2019, to address a range of urban development, transportation, and governance issues. The agenda included the recognition of a $250,000 donation to the affordable housing trust fund, the review of the first-year implementation of the Transit Master Plan, and the adoption of significant charter amendments. Additionally, the council held public hearings on conditional zoning requests and considered new policies regarding affordable housing fees and land use incentives.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The council approved the Consent Agenda, with Item E removed from the list. All other motions presented during the meeting passed unanimously. The council continued the public hearing for a project at 1 South Tunnel Road until December 10, 2019. For the project at 213 Long Shoals Road, the council approved rezoning multiple parcels from Community Business 1 to the Residential Expansion District/Conditional Zone to allow for the 130-unit Julian Woods Retirement Community. The council also adopted ordinances to restore at-large elections for City Council members and to conduct elections via the nonpartisan primary and election method. Furthermore, the council approved a new standalone Affordable Housing Fee Rebate Program and amendments to the Land Use Incentive Grant (Luigi) Policy. The council also approved entering a closed session to consult with an attorney regarding the *City of Asheville v. Parkway Court LLC* claim and to discuss economic development incentives.

**Discussion Highlights**
A major portion of the discussion focused on the funding challenges associated with the Transit Master Plan. Staff presented a service increase launching January 5, 2020, but noted that extending service hours requires additional revenue. Council Member Vijay Kapoor stated that a dedicated revenue source is "really the only way that the numbers are going to work" for the necessary level of transit expansion. Council Member Julie Mayfield assessed that a county sales tax is "really not a possible funding source at this time, due to the politics in the county," suggesting that fighting for funding at the state legislature is easier. Council Member Keith Young emphasized that the money cannot be found in the "proverbial couch," asserting that an additional revenue source is required.

Regarding the charter amendments, Council Member Brian Haynes expressed concern about the shift to at-large elections, stating, "I think going back to an all-at-large system is probably the worst route we could have taken... for the average resident, for minority communities seeking better access to the representatives, it's the worst system out there." The council noted that the General Assembly retains the ability to change the election provisions back, which could lead to litigation. Mayor Esther Manheimer highlighted the $250,000 donation from the Deerfield Retirement Community, noting, "This is, to my knowledge, the first type of gift... to show that we need more than just government partners to be able to leverage affordable housing."

**Community Input**
Public comment addressed several critical issues. Representatives from the Sunrise Movement and Climate Reality Project urged the council to declare a climate emergency, criticizing the city’s current sustainability plan for only reducing emissions by 1% and warning of voting against council members in 2020 if inaction continued. In response, Council Member Julie Mayfield stated the city is doing more than any other in North Carolina, citing the avoidance of a 190-megawatt natural gas peaker plant, and clarified that working with Duke Energy does not mean embracing its goals. Mayor Esther Manheimer added that while local action is important, state-level mandates on renewable energy will have the biggest impact, and offered to help the Sunrise group engage with the state legislature.

Commenters, including representatives from "Better Buses Together," requested that revenue from the sale of Mission Health be used to fund extended evening transit hours via a budget amendment, arguing that a property tax increase is not required for full Transit Master Plan implementation. Council Member Vijay Kapoor countered that the Mission Health dollars are already allocated in the base budget to cover existing expenses, leaving no surplus for new services without cuts. Council Member Julie Mayfield agreed, stating that without new authorized revenue sources, the city cannot fund all desired initiatives, suggesting a property tax increase may be the only option. One resident raised concerns about heroin use and a stabbing near a bus stop at Montana and Hanover Street; council members did not respond. Another commenter suggested the new Long Shoals Road development include subsidized housing, while another proposed a half-cent fuel tax to fund transit; council members did not respond to these suggestions.

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Jessica Morris, Assistant Director of Transportation, committed to providing accurate cost estimates for extending transit hours by December, including scenarios for July 2020, October 2020, and January 2021. Staff will also continue monitoring the operating and transit budgets for potential savings. The Sunrise group’s proposed climate emergency resolution has been sent to the Sustainability Advisory Committee (SACI) to be made "more Asheville specific" before returning to the full council.

**Impact**
These decisions have significant implications for Asheville residents. The adoption of at-large elections and the nonpartisan primary method changes how council members are elected, a shift that drew mixed reactions regarding representation in minority communities. The approval of the Julian Woods Retirement Community rezoning expands residential options in the Long Shoals area. The new Affordable Housing Fee Rebate Program and the recognition of the Deerfield donation aim to strengthen the city's affordable housing resources. Finally, the ongoing debate over transit funding highlights the tension between service expansion and the city's current budget constraints, with staff set to provide further cost data in December.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB9iA6KE52U
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3231/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB9iA6KE52U)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
