# City Council Meeting – June 25, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** June 25, 2019 11:00 AM EDT (2019-06-25T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5289/city-council-meeting-june-25-2019
**Outcome:** Council approved the conversion of the historic Flatiron Building into lodging and office space, with one member voting against.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council met on June 25, 2019, with Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler presiding while Mayor Esther Manheimer participated via telephone. The agenda included the consent agenda, a City Manager’s report on gun violence, three public hearings regarding street name changes and rezoning, and a continued public hearing on the conditional zoning for the historic Flatiron Building.

**Key Decisions**
The Council approved the consent agenda unanimously, which included a resolution urging Governor Roy Cooper to veto House Bill 370, a measure that would mandate North Carolina sheriffs to cooperate with federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainers. The Council also unanimously approved two street name changes: renaming the most southern portion of Park Avenue North to "Artful Way" to reduce confusion in the West End, and renaming a short portion of Wilbar Avenue to "Lee Garden Lane" to serve as an access drive for the redeveloped Lee Walker Heights housing development. Additionally, the Council unanimously approved a request to rezone a 0.33-acre parcel at 990 Sweeton Creek Road from Industrial to Commercial Industrial, allowing for a broader range of uses including a small "grab-and-go" restaurant.

The most significant decision of the evening was the approval of the conditional zoning request to convert the historic Flatiron Building at 20 Battery Park Avenue into lodging and ancillary uses. A motion to postpone the hearing to July 23, 2019, to gather more information regarding city funds and maintenance history failed with three votes in favor and one opposed. The final motion to approve the project passed; the chair recorded the vote based on a hand raise, with Mayor Manheimer explicitly voting "aye" and one member explicitly stating they would vote "no."

**Discussion Highlights**
During the City Manager’s report, Assistant City Manager Ben Woody highlighted that the Asheville Police Department has submitted the most sexual assault kits for testing of any community in the state. APD Deputy Chief Jim Bonstark presented data showing gun violence crimes are up 14% year-to-date and 55% since 2016, with robberies up 26% and aggravated assaults up 16%. He noted that five of the top ten locations for gun calls are in or around public housing communities and emphasized that APD cannot solve the issue alone, urging residents to report suspicious activity via Crime Stoppers or 911.

The Flatiron Building hearing featured extensive debate regarding the proposal to renovate the building into 71 lodging units (reduced from 80) and a floor of commercial office space. The applicant’s attorney argued that over $10.5 million in renovations are required to make the building safe and that no bank would fund preservation as office space, making the hotel conversion the only viable path. Council members expressed divided opinions: Council Member Sheneika Smith stated she changed her mind to support the project after repeated meetings with the developer, citing the building's inability to continue in its current state. Council Member Julie Mayfield voted in favor, stating she did not believe office rents could support the renovation costs and did not want to watch the building torn down. Council Member Keith Young stated he was "compelled to support" the project to choose adaptive reuse over continued decline, while noting he was "not happy" with the decision. Vice Mayor Wisler voted against the project, stating that the public interest had not been met and that the Council had not determined a saturation point for downtown hotels.

**Community Input**
Public commenters presented varied perspectives on the Flatiron Building project. Several residents urged a "no" vote, arguing that the city is "inundated" with hotels, that the developers did not adequately engage with the local community, and that the project would displace local businesses and artists. One commenter suggested the Tourism Development Authority should fund the preservation instead. Others urged a "yes" vote, arguing that the developer’s voluntary reduction of hotel rooms and addition of office space was a positive step for the mountain tourist economy and that the building had served as a business incubator for 30 years. One commenter expressed disappointment that the motion to postpone did not pass, stating they did not feel comfortable voting "yes" on that night.

**Follow-ups**
Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler stated that the Council needs to "go back to the drawing board" to determine how many hotel rooms constitute saturation in downtown and how to shape the city’s growth over the next 60 years, noting that the City Manager has challenged them to do so. No other specific staff or member commitments to follow up on public comments were recorded.

**Impact**
These decisions reflect the Council's balancing of public safety, urban development, and historical preservation. The approval of the Flatiron Building conversion marks a significant shift in downtown Asheville’s landscape, prioritizing the preservation of a historic structure through adaptive reuse despite concerns about hotel saturation and local business displacement. The unanimous approval of the resolution against HB 370 signals the city's stance on local law enforcement autonomy and community trust regarding immigration enforcement.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DuwR15KXRK0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3029/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DuwR15KXRK0)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
