# City Council Meeting – April 23, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 23, 2019 11:00 AM EDT (2019-04-23T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5293/city-council-meeting-april-23-2019
**Outcome:** Council approved the hybrid vehicle grant and adopted resolutions to permanently close the Commerce and Rose Street rights-of-way, while continuing the Flatiron Building item to May.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on April 23, 2019, beginning with a recognition of students from the City of Asheville Youth Leadership Academy (CAILA) and a proclamation for Building Safety Month. The council then moved to the consent agenda, which included a resolution opposing offshore drilling and a grant application for hybrid vehicles. Following the consent agenda, the council addressed a public hearing involving the continuation of two items to future dates and the permanent closure of two unopened rights-of-way. The meeting concluded with a public comment period covering a residential development pre-application, first responder compensation, and a local homicide investigation.

**Key Decisions**
The council unanimously approved the consent agenda, which included the resolution opposing offshore drilling and the hybrid vehicle grant application. During the public hearing, the council unanimously voted to continue the Flatiron Building item to May 28, 2019, and another item (Item D) to May 14, 2019. The council also unanimously adopted resolutions to permanently close the unopened rights-of-way known as Commerce Street and Rose Street. All votes recorded for these actions were in favor, with no members opposed.

**Discussion Highlights**
Mark Matheny, Director of Development Services, spoke on Building Safety Month, noting that monitoring building and construction standards allows buildings to perform better before, during, and after emergencies, enabling homeowners to return to their homes more quickly. Councilmember Gwen Wisler commented on Matheny’s award, stating, "Mark is like Asheville's version of Sherry Berry, just without the picture... Mark's name is on every permit and every certificate of occupancy that comes out of the door." Wisler also spoke on Consent Agenda Item E regarding corridor studies for Tunnel Road and Hendersonville Road, stating, "I think by doing these corridor studies along Tunnel Road and Hendersonville Road that's critical to ensuring that... we do this planning in a way that is well thought out, that is environmentally sensitive."

**Community Input**
During the consent agenda, a public commenter expressed concern that the hybrid vehicle grant application opposed the city’s stated sustainability goals, citing a 2017 report recommending a transition to a fully electric fleet within 10 years. The commenter asked the council to adopt a strategy for a fully electric fleet. Councilmember Brian Haynes asked if 30-foot electric buses were available; a staff member from the Transportation Department responded that while one company makes such a bus, cities have been sending them back, and clarified that the city is committed to transitioning to electric but is applying for grants to address immediate fleet needs. Another public commenter thanked the council for the offshore drilling resolution and echoed the call to transition to renewable energy.

Regarding the continuation of Public Hearing Item D, a public commenter asked for clarification on why the hearing was moved, noting that residents had rearranged their lives to attend. Mayor Esther Manheimer explained that the request to move the hearing came from the developer and that the city must provide an opportunity for a hearing within a statutory timeline from the planning and zoning hearing.

In the public comment period, an architect representing a client spoke about a pre-application for a 55-unit development on Brevard Road. The architect explained that the client was required to purchase a small adjacent parcel for $200,000 to create a 28-foot-wide entrance, but this space was insufficient to include a required sidewalk. The architect asked if the council would waive the sidewalk requirement given the client’s offer of affordable housing incentives. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that the council does not normally handle pre-zoning requests during public comment and advised the architect to continue working with staff and to meet with individual council members to discuss the technical sidewalk requirements.

Another public commenter advocated for a "climate lens" in budgeting, arguing that increased flooding and storm frequency place pressure on understaffed and underpaid first responders. The commenter requested a raise reflecting hazard pay and the restoration of a previous retirement benefit package for city staff. Members did not respond to this comment. A final public commenter reminded the community of Derek Lee Jr., a child shot and killed the previous summer, and urged anyone with information to contact the Asheville Police Department, noting a $5,000 reward and the option to remain anonymous. Members did not respond to this comment.

**Follow-ups**
A staff member stated that the CAILA students’ visioning document for the city of Asheville would be submitted to the official record. Staff member Chad Bandy noted that conversations have started with property owners to acquire a future easement for a greenway on the southern part of the property associated with the Commerce Street closure. Mayor Esther Manheimer advised the public commenter regarding the Brevard Road development to continue working with staff and to reach out to individual council members regarding the sidewalk requirement.

**Impact**
The permanent closure of the Commerce Street and Rose Street rights-of-way resolves the status of these unopened streets, while the initiation of conversations for a greenway easement on the Commerce Street property suggests potential future infrastructure development in that area. The continuation of the Flatiron Building and Item D to future dates means that decisions on these specific planning matters will be deferred until May 2019. The council’s approval of the corridor studies for Tunnel Road and Hendersonville Road indicates a commitment to further planning for responsible growth in those areas.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nof7dfgRSzI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3032/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nof7dfgRSzI)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
