# City Council Meeting – March 12, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 12, 2019 11:00 AM EDT (2019-03-12T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5298/city-council-meeting-march-12-2019

## Summary

On March 12, 2019, the Asheville City Council held a regular meeting to address a variety of administrative, zoning, and appointment items. The session began with the withdrawal of the Rock Hill Road proposal and the review of the Consent Agenda. The council then heard a presentation on the "Do the Right Thing" essay challenge before moving to three major agenda items: a request to close an alley, a conditional zoning change for a hotel, and a rezoning request for the Asheville Mall redevelopment. The meeting concluded with a review of board and commission appointments and an open comment period focused on state-mandated redistricting.

**Key Decisions**
The council voted unanimously to adopt the Consent Agenda, excluding Item N (the Adventist Health Physician Service contract), which was referred to the Finance HR Committee for further review. Regarding Item B, the council voted to permanently close an unopened right-of-way off Fairfax Avenue; the motion carried with one member voting against. For Item C, the council voted 4-3 to approve a conditional zoning change for 324 Biltmore Avenue from Regional Business District to Lodging Expansion Conditional Zone, allowing for a seven-story, 103-room hotel. The council voted unanimously to continue the 1 South Tunnel Road (Asheville Mall) redevelopment item to April 23, 2019, to allow the developer to revise the design. In the appointments section, the council unanimously appointed Roger Vaught to the Board of Electrical Examiners, Jim Hardy to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee, Nicole Townsend and Ingrid Colwitz to the Human Relations Commission, and Lucius Wilson to the Recreation Boards. The council agreed to interview seven candidates for the Board of Education at the next meeting on March 26, 2019, and decided to re-advertise the public housing seat for the Citizens Police Advisory Committee after no application was received.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the review of the physician contract, a former city physician argued that the Request for Proposal (RFP) process was flawed, citing inadequate advertising and the winning provider’s failure to meet specific certification requirements. Council Member Julie Mayfield moved to pull the item from the Consent Agenda due to unanswered questions, and Mayor Esther Manheimer agreed to refer it to the Finance HR Committee. Interim Assistant City Manager Peggy Rowe stated that staff believes the provider is good but offered to provide more information.

On the Fairfax Avenue alley closure, representatives from West Asheville Presbyterian Church opposed the closure, arguing it would deprive elderly and disabled members of reasonable access to their fellowship hall. Property owners supported the closure, noting the alley was never opened to the public and that negotiations had stalled. Council Member Sheneika Smith voted against the closure, suggesting an easement, while Council Member Keith Young voted in favor, citing the statutory standard for reasonable ingress and egress.

For the 324 Biltmore Avenue hotel, supporters cited the project’s fit with the Lee Walker Heights transformation and its proximity to Mission Hospital. Opponents argued the lot was too small for housing but sufficient for a hotel and that the $625,000 housing donation should not dictate zoning changes. Mayor Esther Manheimer voted in favor, explaining that resident taxpayers currently subsidize tourism because visitor taxes are not fully harnessed, and emphasized that no moratorium on hotel growth has been passed. Council Members Vijay Kapoor and Gwen Wisler voted against the project.

Regarding the Asheville Mall redevelopment, staff did not support the project in its current form, citing a lack of a "compact urban street grid" and non-compliance with height limits. Developers from Seritage Growth Properties argued the project was a "great adaptive reuse" of the abandoned Sears store and asked the council not to let "the perfect be the enemy of the good." Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed concern that the project did not meet the Comprehensive Plan’s vision for a Town Center and asked developers if they would delay the hearing to revise the design.

**Community Input**
During the open comment period on state redistricting, a small business owner urged the council to fight the state’s change to district-based voting, citing that over 70% of voters oppose it. A resident challenged the council to address the "highest achievement gap" in the school system, noting the empty room during the Board of Education discussion. An organizer for the non-binary and transgender community questioned why the city seemed reluctant to fight the General Assembly’s redistricting plan. Members did not respond to the redistricting comments, though the chair acknowledged the comment regarding the school system.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to provide more information about the physician contract RFP and requirements to the council. The council agreed to reconvene to discuss the Asheville Mall project on April 23, 2019. The council will interview the seven Board of Education candidates on March 26, 2019. Staff will re-advertise the public housing seat for the Citizens Police Advisory Committee. Staff also requested that calendar appointments for the Board of Education interviews be updated from 10:00 AM to 9:45 AM.

**Impact**
These decisions affect local development and city services. The approval of the hotel at 324 Biltmore Avenue allows for new lodging capacity near a major hospital, while the continuation of the Asheville Mall project allows developers time to address staff concerns regarding urban design and height limits. The referral of the physician contract to committee ensures further scrutiny of the medical services procurement process. The appointments fill vacancies on key city advisory boards, and the upcoming interviews will determine the next members of the Board of Education.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCDpL911xLw
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3237/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCDpL911xLw)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
