# City Council Work Session – October 10, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** October 10, 2023 11:00 AM EDT (2023-10-10T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5299/city-council-work-session-october-10-2023
**Outcome:** Council heard an update on the city’s facility condition and maintenance funding needs, with staff agreeing to provide additional data on space requirements and staff growth projections.

## Summary

On October 10, 2023, the Asheville City Council held a work session to review the first part of the newly completed Comprehensive Facility Study. The session was informational in nature, with no votes taken, motions made, or decisions finalized. The presentation, led by City Manager Deborah Campbell and Walter Ear, Director of Capital Management, assessed the city’s aging infrastructure, current space needs, and long-term capital planning requirements.

The study highlights significant challenges in maintaining the city’s nearly $500 million portfolio of facilities, which received a "C" grade in a condition assessment. A critical finding is the maintenance deficit: while current annual maintenance funding is approximately $1 million, the study indicates that $3.5 million is required annually just to maintain current service levels and prevent asset failure. Walter Ear clarified that this $3.5 million figure covers maintenance only and does not include costs for growth, improvements, additions, or building replacements. He noted that without adequate funding, all facility assets could reach a "nearly failed state" within 13 to 20 years.

Specific building assessments revealed varying levels of need across the city. City Hall is currently in a slight space deficit but may have a technical surplus in 20 years if vacant upper floors are utilized. In contrast, the Municipal Building, which houses Fire and Police, faces a significant space deficit, with the Police Department having a higher need for additional space than Fire. Public Works is facing a large office space deficit and a site deficit, requiring 22 acres compared to the 9 acres currently held. The Oakley Complex was identified as a candidate for replacement rather than renovation due to its age (built in 1965) and poor return on investment for modernization. Additionally, many older buildings were found to be not cost-effective to retrofit for modern sustainability standards, such as electrification and insulation.

During the discussion, Council members raised concerns about the logic behind staff growth projections, questioning whether the city would truly grow by 700 new staff members in the next 20 years. They urged the team to be "thoughtful" about the future of work and hybrid models. Other members highlighted that the cost to maintain and repair older buildings, such as the Thomas Wolfe building, is sometimes comparable to the cost of new construction. One Council member suggested "multi-solving" investments, proposing that spaces like community centers could serve multiple purposes to avoid redundant spending. Taylor Floyd, Budget Manager, clarified that the decision on how to finance these needs will be part of the broader capital budget process.

City Manager Deborah Campbell described the situation as "bittersweet," noting that while there are many needs, the city believes it has a way to address them, though it will take time. She emphasized that the study serves as a "source of information" for potential GO bond decisions and stressed that "our facilities serve those who serve the city." Walter Ear acknowledged the collaborative effort behind the presentation, thanking city staff and consultants including Creech & Associates and Brightly Software.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the session. Walter Ear agreed to provide Council with specific tables detailing the basis for staff growth calculations and the exact numbers behind space needs assessments. He also offered to provide tours of specific facilities, including Fire Station 1 living quarters, so Council members can see current conditions firsthand. Additionally, he agreed to replace an incorrect rendering of the Grant Center pool in the presentation materials. Staff confirmed that discussions have begun with Buncombe County regarding the Oakley Complex site, specifically concerning the library and community center components.

The second part of the study, which includes the 20-year facilities master plan and specific project sequencing, is scheduled to be presented at a work session in November. Staff confirmed that the findings from this study will feed into the capital budget discussions led by Finance in December. There was no public comment period during this work session, as the meeting was closed to the public for the presentation and Q&A.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6_SbMkmO1M
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3045/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6_SbMkmO1M)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
