# City Council Work Session – February 25, 2020

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** February 25, 2020 11:00 AM EST (2020-02-25T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5300/city-council-work-session-february-25-2020
**Outcome:** Council concurred with staff to proceed with short-term hotel regulatory recommendations, including a public benefits incentive program, before the moratorium expires.

## Summary

On February 25, 2020, the Asheville City Council held a work session to review the findings of the Hotel Development Study initiated in Fall 2019. The session focused on a 55-page briefing book prepared by staff, which utilized the Urban Land Institute (ULI) Technical Assistance Panel process to analyze hotel trends, housing impacts, and economic data in the city.

The briefing book presented several key findings regarding the local hospitality sector. Staff noted that Asheville has experienced a 25% growth rate in hotel development over the last decade, significantly outpacing the 11% population growth rate. Peak occupancy rates reach 85% during summer and fall months, exceeding state and national averages. The data indicated that there is approximately one short-term vacation rental (STVR) listing for every four hotel rooms. Additionally, staff clarified that while 65% of visitors are day-trippers, the 11.1 million annual visitor figure does not include the approximately 50,000 daily commuters. Infrastructure impacts were assessed as lower than residential uses, with hotels generating 2,700 gallons of water and sewer usage per room per month compared to 4,500 gallons per residential unit.

Council members discussed the ULI’s recommendations, which were categorized into revenue-generating, planning, and regulatory areas. Mayor Esther Manheimer described the briefing book as "chock full of a lot of really interesting information" that answered frequent questions. She argued that Asheville’s unique tourism status, including its ranking first in the state for tourism marketing spending and $25 million in annual occupancy tax collections, justifies a different approach to the occupancy tax split than standard committee guidelines. Council Member Sheneika Smith agreed, stating that the current 33% split is "way low" and suggesting it is time to look at a different way of doing business. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler questioned specific wage data in the briefing book, noting discrepancies between Asheville and state averages, and suggested looking at STVRs as a land use issue due to their disproportionate number.

The Council provided verbal concurrence for staff to proceed with prioritized short-term regulatory recommendations before the current hotel moratorium expires. These short-term actions include re-establishing where hotels are permitted by geographic area, developing review standards such as separation distances, and implementing a "Public Benefits" incentive program. This program would offer streamlined review in exchange for benefits like affordable housing, green building, or transit passes. Other short-term items include identifying design improvements for downtown hotels, evaluating Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) thresholds, developing valet parking standards, and implementing a fee or lease agreement for the use of public right-of-way during construction. Long-term recommendations, such as establishing a Business Improvement District or changing the occupancy tax split, were acknowledged as items that may not be resolved before the moratorium ends.

Regarding the legal framework for the "Public Benefits" program, the City Attorney explained that while community benefits agreements are not legally permissible in North Carolina in that specific form, the proposed structure functions as an incentivization program. Mayor Manheimer emphasized the need for enforceable conditions, noting that while hoteliers may promise to pay a living wage, North Carolina law does not allow that to be enforced as a zoning condition. Council Member Sheneika Smith asked how the city would ensure compliance with these promises, prompting staff to confirm they would ensure any proposed public benefits include a clear enforcement mechanism, such as zoning violations or notices of violation.

Staff agreed to conduct additional research and community engagement on the prioritized short-term recommendations, including investigating data inconsistencies regarding restaurant wages and looking into peer city data for day-trip versus overnight visitor ratios. Staff also agreed to explore incorporating STVR data into the analysis and to add "shuttle services" to the list of potential public benefits. The City Attorney agreed to explore the legal viability of structuring the incentives to ensure they are legally enforceable. Staff committed to returning to City Council in late summer 2020 with specific regulatory changes for review.

This work session is significant for residents as it establishes the direction for how the city will manage hotel development once the current moratorium expires. By prioritizing specific regulatory changes and incentive structures, the Council aims to balance the economic benefits of tourism with livability concerns, such as traffic, infrastructure strain, and housing impacts. The upcoming return to Council in late summer 2020 will determine the specific rules that will govern new hotel projects in Asheville.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=niKrrEOBfEU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3047/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=niKrrEOBfEU)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
