# City Council Budget Work Session – January 14, 2020

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** January 14, 2020 11:00 AM EST (2020-01-14T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5301/city-council-budget-work-session-january-14-2020
**Outcome:** Council discussed the current budget status, the employee compensation study, and the 2020-21 budget development process without taking any votes.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held its first budget work session for the 2020 fiscal year on January 14, 2020. The session focused on the status of the current 2019-2020 budget, an update on the employee compensation study, and a preview of the 2020-21 budget development process. No votes were taken, and no motions were made or seconded during this closed work session.

**Current Fiscal Year Status**
Staff reported that the General Fund is on track, with revenues projected to exceed expenses by approximately $800,000, a margin of less than 1% of the $130 million budget. In contrast, the Transit Fund is projected to have a $500,000 shortfall for the current year. Staff attributed this deficit to higher-than-expected fuel and electricity costs (approximately $100,000) and a significant increase in Paratransit service costs. The rise in Paratransit costs is driven by increased ridership, longer trips, and the impending end of a subsidy from Buncombe County, which has historically covered 40-50% of the cost. Staff recommended against implementing extended transit hours in the current fiscal year due to the existing shortfall and logistical challenges following the January 5th service launch, noting that such an extension would cost an additional $250,000–$300,000. A budget amendment to transfer General Fund money to cover the Transit shortfall is expected later in the year.

**Compensation and Classification Study**
Staff presented Phase 1 findings on the feasibility of raising the minimum salary for full-time employees to $31,200 annually (approximately $15/hour). Approximately 93 of the city’s 1,256 employees currently earn less than this threshold. The estimated annualized cost to raise these 93 employees to the new floor is $412,560, including benefits and overtime. Staff noted that raising the floor creates "pay compression," where new hires may earn close to or more than long-tenured employees in higher grades. Addressing compression for an additional 87 employees in lower pay grades would cost between $30,000 and $196,000, with further compression potentially existing in higher pay grades that is not yet fully quantified. Staff stated they are not asking for a decision on the compensation study today but are seeking awareness and input for the upcoming retreat.

**2020-21 Budget Development and Capital Needs**
For the next fiscal year, staff projects $5–$6 million in additional General Fund revenue, driven by property tax growth, sales tax growth, and the sale of the Mission HCA property. However, staff also projects $6–$8 million in additional operating expenses, driven by the full-year implementation of transit service improvements, personnel costs, maintenance of new infrastructure in the River Arts District, and the cost of the proposed minimum wage increase and compression adjustments. Staff emphasized that projected revenue growth is being "eaten up" by ongoing operating cost increases, meaning new strategic investments will require new revenue sources. The Chief Financial Officer reported that the city has identified $600 million in unfunded capital needs across 125 projects, including significant needs for fire stations, water infrastructure, and roads.

**Discussion Highlights**
Council members discussed the financial challenges and proposed funding mechanisms. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler and Council Member Keith Young presented a proposal to generate $4.5 million in new revenue from a 3-cent property tax increase, which they termed a "climate and affordability funding response." Vice Mayor Wisler noted that she and Council Member Young have been working with community groups to develop this proposal. Council Member Keith Young stated that the proposal is in line with shared community values and necessary for a more resilient community. Council Member Brian Haynes expressed the view that the next budget must first address immediate issues such as the heroin and drug needle litter emergency, water system infrastructure, and employee wage adjustments before considering new revenue streams. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that she wants to be "sparing" with property tax increases and wants to ensure the city is not foreclosing on opportunities for valid priorities.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to provide Phase 1 information on the $31,200 minimum wage and compression analysis, as well as data on hiring and retention difficulties for specific positions, by the Council retreat in February. The Assistant Director of Transportation stated that staff is preparing a more detailed analysis of the cost impact of a potential "fare-free" transit system, including the impact on Paratransit capacity. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler stated that she has asked the Finance Department to research legal options in North Carolina to mitigate the impact of a property tax increase on low- and moderate-income households, and staff confirmed this research is happening. Staff confirmed they will bring updated five-year models, detailed budget information, and strategic alignment data to the Council retreat scheduled for February 14, 2020.

**Impact on Residents**
This work session highlighted the tight margins in the city’s current budget and the significant gap between projected revenue growth and rising operating costs for the next fiscal year. The discussion underscored the financial pressure on the Transit Fund due to the loss of county subsidies and the potential costs associated with raising the minimum wage for city employees. The identification of $600 million in unfunded capital needs signals that the city will need to find new revenue sources to maintain infrastructure and fund strategic priorities in the coming years.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0PEnKXqvbI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3235/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0PEnKXqvbI)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
