# City Council Budget Work Session – April 9, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 9, 2019 11:00 AM EDT (2019-04-09T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5302/city-council-budget-work-session-april-9-2019
**Outcome:** Council discussed the Enterprise Funds, Capital Improvement Program, and structural deficit during a closed work session, with no votes taken.

## Summary

On April 9, 2019, the City of Asheville City Council held a closed work session to review the final stages of the budget process. The meeting focused on the Enterprise Funds, the Capital Improvement Program (CIP), and operating budget priorities. No votes were taken during this session, as it served as a preparatory review before upcoming public meetings.

**Key Discussions and Financial Updates**
Staff presented an overview of the Enterprise Funds, highlighting specific changes and costs. For the Transit fund, the City is recommending an additional $1.2 million investment for the first phase of the Transit Master Plan. The CFO noted that taxpayer support for transit has risen from $1.1 million in 2009 to an estimated $6.6 million in 2020. The US Cellular Center fund proposes to "in-source" four currently contracted positions using additional ticketing revenue to reduce turnover and improve customer service. Regarding utility fees, the Water Resources and Stormwater funds plan to insource contracted operations. This will result in a projected fee increase for the average household of $0.55/month for water and $0.15/month for stormwater, totaling an $8.40 annual increase. The Parking fund has no planned fee increases, and the Street Cut Utility fund, which repairs streets damaged by utility companies, continues to bill costs back to the utilities with no resident fees.

A significant portion of the discussion addressed the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) and the city’s long-term debt strategy. The CFO presented data indicating that while the current CIP is approximately $60 million for 2020–2023, identified needs total nearly $400 million, a gap largely attributed to decades of deferred maintenance. Several projects, including the Wesley Grant Center and Walton Street pool, are facing cost overruns of $1.6 million each due to higher bid prices. The proposed cost for the new North Asheville Fire Station 13 is $11 million, which is an additional $8 million to the previously set aside $3.8 million. Fire Chief Scott Burnett confirmed that this estimate includes space for an engine company, battalion chief, police substation, and emergency operations center, meeting needs for the next 50 years. Additionally, the CIO noted the City is behind on computer replacements; the budget proposes increasing the annual allocation to $500,000 to replace roughly 25% of the city’s ~1,300+ computers every year.

**Debate on Revenue and Deficits**
Council members and staff engaged in a detailed discussion regarding the structural deficit and the City’s fund balance. Staff indicated they are working within existing revenue constraints and do not have a path to increase the fund balance to the desired 18% without new revenue. The conversation included a debate on the feasibility of a routine bond program versus raising taxes. CFO Barbara Whitehorn argued that the city needs an ongoing bond program to address core services and avoid deferring issues to future residents. City Manager DK Wesley stated, "We are certainly not advocating that we be irresponsible with debt. We are saying that we need to begin to think about this... we are losing ground quickly."

Some Council members expressed reluctance to raise taxes immediately. One Council Member stated, "I just don't think we should keep kicking the can down the road and sort of starving ourselves... I just don't think we should keep kicking the can down the road." Another Council Member said, "I would actually be looking at the expense end... I don't have that appetite [to raise taxes] this year. I do have an interest in looking to see if we can develop our next bond package." Mayor Esther Manheimer echoed this sentiment, stating, "I think a better course of action is to do some thoughtful planning about our next bond program in my view for 2020... I don't have that appetite [to raise taxes] this year."

The group also addressed a newspaper headline regarding fee increases. CFO Barbara Whitehorn clarified, "The $1.3 million fee increases discussed in the paper is actually adding all of the impact of every fee throughout the city... we aren't raising the fees that impact residents." A Council Member responded, "So it's a garbage number. That was on the front page above the fold of our newspaper... that's an absolutely irresponsible thing to do by our newspaper." Mayor Esther Manheimer added, "I did have a chuckle with my mother this morning 'cause she said, 'It says you're raising fees $1.3 million.' And then together we read the article that the annual change in water fees per customer is an average of $6.60 a month... and that's just totally irresponsible."

**Follow-Ups and Next Steps**
Staff members agreed to provide additional information to the Council prior to the final budget presentation. CFO Barbara Whitehorn will provide updated cash flow timelines and project milestones for capital projects, send the CIP chart, provide a list of pending improvements for the US Cellular Center, update the list of organizational partnerships from the August 2018 Finance Committee review, and project the debt model out to 2040. City Manager DK Wesley will conduct one-on-one meetings with each Council member before the May 14 budget presentation and provide additional information on US Cellular Center capital spending over the last five years. CIO Jonathan Feldman will provide exact numbers for computer replacement requests and actual spending for the last few years.

The adoption of fees and charges, including the water and stormwater increases, is scheduled for the regular council meeting on April 9, 2019. The City Manager’s proposed budget will be presented on May 14, with a budget public hearing scheduled for April 28 and final budget adoption scheduled for June 11.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6NZtoR49g8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3048/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6NZtoR49g8)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
