# City Council Meeting – February 26, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** February 26, 2019 11:00 AM EST (2019-02-26T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5305/city-council-meeting-february-26-2019
**Outcome:** Council adopted the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan and the Down Payment Assistance program, both passing unanimously.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on February 26, 2019, to address a variety of agenda items, including routine administrative matters, public hearings on urban planning, and the adoption of new housing policies. The meeting began with proclamations for National 211 Month and Zelda Fitzgerald Day, followed by a review of the consent agenda. The council then held a public hearing on the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan and considered new business regarding a Down Payment Assistance (DPA) Policy. The session concluded with a move to closed session to discuss litigation and personnel matters.

**Key Decisions**
The council voted on several items during the meeting. The motion to approve the consent agenda, which included routine items such as a lease agreement with the Men’s Garden Club, was made and seconded; the vote passed with all those in favor saying "aye" and no opposition recorded. Regarding the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan, the council voted to continue the public hearing for the property at 130 and 9999 Rock Hill Road to March 12, 2019, which passed unanimously. The council also voted to adopt the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan as a standalone plan for the River Arts District and as an amendment to the 2004 Wilma Dykeman Riverway Master Plan; this motion passed with all those in favor saying "aye" and no opposition recorded. In new business, a motion was made to adopt the Down Payment Assistance program, which passed with all those in favor saying "aye" and no opposition recorded. Finally, a motion to enter closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding potential litigation and to consider personnel matters was made and passed with all those in favor saying "aye."

**Discussion Highlights**
Mayor Esther Manheimer proclaimed February 2019 as National 211 Month, noting that in 2018, North Carolina 211 responded to more than 40,000 requests for help from local citizens. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler proclaimed March 10, 2019, as Zelda Fitzgerald Day, highlighting her life in Asheville and the event's goal to raise funds for Aurora Studios, which provides art space for people experiencing mental illness.

During the discussion of the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan, Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, clarified that adopting the plan does not bind the city to implementing it or paying for its implementation. She noted that approximately $54,000 of the estimated $485,000 in project costs are already covered by community partners and that the plan only considers public property, placing no onus on the private sector.

Regarding the Down Payment Assistance Policy, Paul D’Angelo, Community Development Program Director, explained that the loan is a 30-year loan with no monthly payments or interest. He clarified that if a home is purchased for $200,000 and the borrower takes $20,000 in down payment assistance, the loan is forgiven in its entirety if the borrower stays in the home for 30 years. Council Member Julie Mayfield described the policy as a significant milestone and a unique tool, encouraging the public to apply by stating, "Please come, come get this money. We want to spend it and we want to put people in houses." Council Member Brian Haynes reminded the public that $500,000 of the bond funding is specifically earmarked for families making under 60% of the area median income, noting, "We have to spend it by October 2023."

**Community Input**
Public comments were received regarding the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan, the Down Payment Assistance Policy, and general open comment. A public commenter regarding the tree plan suggested that the city put more plants in Asheville and hoped that local projects would be approved; members did not respond. A public commenter regarding the Down Payment Assistance Policy expressed support for the program, stating, "I feel real good that somebody is actually willing to give Asheville a chance," and suggested a partnership with the government to ensure funds return to the program, as well as advocating for changes to specific apartment complexes including Lee Walker Heights, PVA, and Hillcrest; members did not respond. During open public comment, a resident suggested the Mayor consider holding a community parade involving law enforcement, the fire department, and the Mayor to better reach the community, and requested increased police presence at the entrances of PVA Hillcrest Apartments to prevent drug and gun activity; members did not respond.

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Paul D’Angelo stated that a press release regarding the Down Payment Assistance program would be issued that evening. He confirmed that an event is scheduled for May 28th to promote the program, described as a "mock home ownership center." He also stated he would meet individually with approximately 24 mortgage representatives associated with NCHFA to ensure they understand the new policy. D’Angelo further stated it is the intention that the down payment assistance policy be a "living document" that can be evaluated and adjusted as needed.

**Impact**
The adoption of the Tree and Riparian Enhancement Plan serves as a standalone plan for the River Arts District and amends the 2004 Wilma Dykeman Riverway Master Plan, providing a framework for tree and riparian improvements on public property. The adoption of the Down Payment Assistance Policy establishes a new mechanism to help residents purchase homes, utilizing bond funding earmarked for families making under 60% of the area median income. The plan’s adoption does not obligate the city to fund implementation, as some costs are covered by community partners.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwY_Z-5y1W0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3051/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwY_Z-5y1W0)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
