# City Council Meeting – January 8, 2019

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** January 8, 2019 11:00 AM EST (2019-01-08T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5309/city-council-meeting-january-8-2019
**Outcome:** Council recommended approval of conditional zoning for the White Oak Grove Apartments and the Ferry Road development, and approved a property tax billing agreement with Buncombe County.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on January 8, 2019, addressing routine administrative items, three public hearings regarding zoning and funding, and general public comment. The agenda included the adoption of a consent agenda, amendments to the annual action plan, conditional zoning requests for two major development projects, and the authorization of a new property tax billing agreement.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Council voted to adopt the Consent Agenda, excluding one item due to a conflict of interest. Council Member Julie Mayfield recused herself from voting on a resolution authorizing an agreement with Mountain True to construct and maintain natural surface trails in the Falconhurst Nature Preserve, as she is employed by the organization. With Mayfield recused, the Council voted to approve the trail maintenance agreement. Additionally, the Council voted to approve a resolution authorizing the City Manager to submit an amendment to the 2018-2019 Consolidated Action Plan for the HOME Investment Partnership Program, reallocating $1.39 million in federal funds.

In new business, the Council voted to authorize the City Manager to execute a property tax billing and collection fee agreement with Buncombe County. This shift from a percentage-based contract to a flat-fee contract is expected to save the city over $100,000 annually. The Council also voted to appoint or reappoint members to several boards and commissions, including the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, Board of Adjustment, and Tree Commission, while voting to re-advertise for open positions on the Board of Electrical Engineers, CPAC, Housing Authority, South Seat, and the third seat on SACI. Finally, the Council voted to enter a closed session to discuss personnel matters.

**Zoning and Development Recommendations**
The Council held public hearings on two significant development projects. For the White Oak Grove Apartments at 275/281 Hazel Mill Road, the Council voted to recommend approval of the conditional zoning amendment. The approved conditions included changes to the site plan for sidewalk placement and parking, as well as a requirement that bus passes be provided for affordable housing units for the duration of the 10-year affordability period.

For a 416-unit mixed-use development at 9999 Ferry Road, the Council voted to recommend approval of the conditional zoning request, as amended to require 8% of units to be affordable at 100% Area Median Income (AMI). Mayor Esther Manheimer provided historical context on the site, noting it was previously owned by the City, sold to Henderson County, and later purchased by Buncombe County for economic development before being developed for housing. Council Member Keith Young expressed support for the project but noted his "real anxiety" regarding the affordability levels, stating, "I'm actually going to support the project, but it is begrudgingly on my part... I'm actually experiencing some real anxiety right now... in a sense of knowing that there's nothing about this that is affordable." He also remarked, "8% is better than 5%? Okay."

**Community Input**
Public commenters raised several concerns during the hearings and general comment period. Regarding the Hazel Mill Road project, one commenter supported the inclusion of 80% AMI affordable housing but urged the Council to consider lower AMI levels (50-60%) in future projects to better serve the city’s workforce. Another suggested leveraging volunteer organizations to reduce construction costs, to which no specific member responded directly.

Concerns were more pronounced regarding the Ferry Road development. Commenters expressed worry about the density of 418 units, the impact on wildlife habitat and views, and the addition of commercial traffic to a rural residential street. Several commenters argued that 5% or 8% affordable housing at 100% AMI is not truly affordable for low-to-middle income families and urged the Council to negotiate better terms or lower AMI thresholds. Council Member Keith Young responded to questions about buffers by confirming with staff that a minimum 20-foot undisturbed buffer would be deed-restricted to prevent tree removal. During general public comment, residents debated the state’s gerrymandering legislation (Senate Bill 813), with some urging the Council to file an injunction and others arguing against it based on demographic data. One commenter expressed disappointment that the Council unanimously approved the Ferry Road development with only 8% affordable housing at 100% AMI. Council Member Keith Young responded by explaining that for-sale affordable housing is a new area for the Council and that they are working with staff to develop standards for it. Another commenter raised concerns about inconsistent enforcement of zoning and parking violations on Maxwell Street.

**Follow-ups**
Staff member Deborah Campbell agreed to email a summary of parking tickets written on Maxwell Street to Council Member Keith Young. Additionally, the developer of the Ferry Road project and City staff, specifically Paul D’Angelo, will work out the specific triggering factors for the 8% affordable housing commitment to ensure the condition is enforceable. Council Member Keith Young stated that the Council needs to develop standards for affordable housing in for-sale projects, similar to those already in place for rental properties.

**Impact on Residents**
These decisions affect local infrastructure, housing availability, and city finances. The new property tax agreement is expected to provide predictable savings of over $100,000 annually. The zoning recommendations for the Hazel Mill Road and Ferry Road projects, if ultimately approved by the Planning Board and Council in subsequent steps, will add new residential and commercial units to the city, with specific conditions aimed at providing affordable housing options and managing environmental impacts. The reallocation of $1.39 million in HOME program funds will shift federal resources to different projects within the city’s housing plan.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kGP4zRgQ1w
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3054/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kGP4zRgQ1w)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
