# City Council Meeting – October 23, 2018

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** October 23, 2018 11:00 AM EDT (2018-10-23T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5317/city-council-meeting-october-23-2018
**Outcome:** Council approved the 100% renewable energy goal and the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan, and approved a zoning amendment for the Buncombe County Transfer Station.

## Summary

**City Council Meeting Recap: October 23, 2018**

The City of Asheville City Council convened on October 23, 2018, to address a range of municipal issues, including sustainability goals, urban planning, and infrastructure concerns. The meeting opened with a recognition of 37 city employees who assisted in the response to Hurricane Florence. The agenda included a review of the recent Citizen Survey results and three public hearings regarding the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan, an amendment to the Buncombe County Transfer Station zoning, and a proposed hotel development on Biltmore Avenue.

**Key Decisions**
The Council voted unanimously to approve the Consent Agenda, which included a resolution establishing a 100% renewable energy goal for the city and an Opportunity Zones resolution. Following a public hearing, the Council voted unanimously to recommend the adoption of the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan. Additionally, the Council voted unanimously to approve an amendment to the industrial conditional zone for the Buncombe County Transfer Station on Hominy Creek Road, allowing for reduced landscaping due to state prohibitions on planting on landfill materials. No vote was taken on the proposed seven-story, 103-room hotel at 324 Biltmore Avenue, as the developers respectfully withdrew the application during the public hearing. The Council subsequently voted to enter a closed session to discuss legal and personnel matters, from which they adjourned immediately.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the discussion of the 100% renewable energy resolution, a Council Member described the measure as the city’s next step toward sustainability, emphasizing the importance of committing to a long-term goal. Another Council Member noted that the city’s sustainability office is currently its smallest department with only two staff members, stating that resources would need to increase to execute the goals properly. The Mayor raised questions about the fairness of placing the cost of 100% renewables on a single city rather than legislating it at the state level. Regarding the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan, the Planning & Urban Design Director explained that the neighborhood is one of ten communities impacted by the proposed I-26 connector project and has been identified as an environmental justice population.

For the hotel application, the Mayor stated that the city is at a critical point regarding fiscal health and infrastructure maintenance, expressing discomfort with approving additional hotels until the city addresses its "lack of fiscal diversity" to support needs like sidewalks and public safety. Two other Council Members also voiced opposition, with one citing a "de facto moratorium" on hotels in the central business district and another referencing the need for a work session to determine long-term effects. In response to the opposition, the developer’s representative, Wyatt Stevens, stated that the developers would respectfully withdraw the application.

**Community Input**
Public comment was extensive during the meeting. Regarding the renewable energy resolution, representatives from the local Audubon Society, the Sierra Club, and the Western North Carolina Renewables Coalition spoke in support, presenting petitions and arguing that renewable energy creates jobs and improves public health. Students from Asheville High School, AB Tech, and UNC Asheville also spoke in support, calling it a monumental moment for their generation. A representative of a Unitarian Universalist congregation and a LEED-certified contractor also voiced support. On the Opportunity Zones resolution, a public commenter expressed hope that funds would benefit Southside and other communities, ensuring participation by people of color and low-income individuals.

During the hotel hearing, several members of the public expressed support, including a nearby business manager, a pastor, a local business owner, a resident, and the director of a child crisis facility. The director explained that the hotel would allow parents from 23 counties to stay close to their children. A representative of the Housing Authority also supported the project, citing the developer’s offer of $125,000 for a playground and $100,000 annually for five years to the housing authority. Opponents argued that Asheville is not meeting affordable housing goals and that wages are 16% higher than the rest of North Carolina without corresponding housing affordability. One commenter questioned whether the jobs offered would be sufficient for residents to pay bills.

In general public comment, a former state senator spoke about the poor condition of the public bus transportation system, describing the terminal as "filthy" with broken water fountains. Another public commenter presented a video and audio recording of enforcement issues on Maxwell Street, expressing frustration that the Transportation Department was not present at previous planning meetings and that residents had been dealing with these issues for 14 years.

**Follow-ups**
The Director of Communications & Public Engagement agreed to post a slide that was missed during the Citizen Survey presentation and to place the survey report in a more prominent location on the city website. The Buncombe County Planning Director stated he would return to the transfer station site to verify existing tree credits to ensure the city is not losing net tree canopy. Regarding Maxwell Street, a staff member reported that the city met with police and transportation departments the previous day. Police are prepared to increase enforcement and issue citations for moving violations. The city is working on a plan to have a parking enforcement officer present on the street from 5 to 7 a.m. for the next six weeks to write tickets for parking violations. Staff are also working with residents to ensure they have appropriate hang tags to avoid being ticketed and are in contact with the owners of the grease truck and dumpster services to limit their operating times to daytime hours. A Council Member asked staff to send an email laying out the specific rules for trucks on Maxwell Street to clarify any confusion.

**Impact**
This meeting marked a significant step in the city’s commitment to environmental sustainability with the unanimous approval of the 100% renewable energy goal. The recommendation to adopt the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan addresses planning needs in an area identified as an environmental justice population impacted by the I-26 connector project. The withdrawal of the Biltmore Avenue hotel application reflects ongoing tensions between economic development and the city’s fiscal capacity and infrastructure needs, with the Mayor highlighting the need for revenue diversity to support public services. The actions taken regarding Maxwell Street aim to address long-standing resident concerns about traffic and parking enforcement through increased police presence and clearer regulations for commercial vehicles.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXUm5QlXsM4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3063/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXUm5QlXsM4)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
